So is this game supposed to be a better Pokemon or not? If it plays nothing like Pokemon then any comparisons should be irrelevant.
I guess others have given their opinion, but for me this is better pokemon for a few reasons.
1. I've been playing pokemon for since the 90s, and at this point I just want to get in and start playing. I remember I almost put Moon down because the tutorial was vibes of the game didn't feel like it ended till I was midway through second island - so the open tutorial is a absolutely massive improvement to me where I can just get to playing.
2. For me at least, exploration and seeing new mons was one of the most exciting parts of each pokemon game. I still would like having turned based combat as an option as that's where a ton of the depth from pokemon come from, but I'm not opposed to this combat method as well as it's doing its own thing. But for the two earlier mentioned traits of exploration and seeing new mons I think this game out does recent pokemon games as well.
3. The base building and what not is totally different though and I think it works for giving me a reason to catch extra Pals though as I can bring them back to base and have something to do.
4. Pokemon is better when it comes to a carrot on a stick though, wish and hope that Palworld adds an elite 4 type of end game or something as I'd love there to be a final boss culmination after you reach endgame. (maybe there is but I'm trying to stay un spoiled on that part)
So to me outside of turn based combat and story pal world has surpassed nearly every other reason I'd play a newer Pokemon title.