Finished FF2, around 12 hours on the clock. Better than ever! And still I think the worst main FF, and one I don't really recommend to anyone. The leveling system being really bad in previous versions drew a lot of ire, but there's so many other problems with the game that were kind of masked as everyone focused on just the leveling system. The terrible dungeon design and ridiculous encounter rate tank the rest of the game. I just really, absolutely hate the dungeons. Trap rooms, long snaking linear corridors make it feel like the "rail shooter" of RPGs. Like half of the play time is spent running down single-tile-wide hallways and the random encounters you fight in those hallways.
I never felt the need to do anything that felt it was abusive. I only had 3x Evasion by the end, and only got ambush-locked once in the final dungeon, which thanks to the saving wasn't a real loss of time. I still got around 3500-5000 HP in 12 non-grindy hours, never targeting myself or drawing out fights intentionally. The last boss being hard mostly came to me not understanding mechanics (Berserk increases spell damage, which I figured out during the fight?) or that I never leveling any of the defensive buffs so had to stack it 1 at a time.
+ The music is the best version of that OST.
+ QOL makes a huge difference in playability.
+ The revised leveling mechanics are much better than I remember playing them.
- Dungeons are terrible
- The encounter rate is too high.
- Dungeons are really terrible
- Worst exploration in the series
- Leveling mechanics are still prone to abuse. Having to cast buffs over and over to level them is ridiculous.
- Good lord I hate the dungeons.
- Boss fights are still really bad in 1989 or whatever.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but the original FFIII doesn't have actual characters, just four blank slate avatars like in FFI, right?
That's why I always theoretically assumed the 3D remake would be better since it includes actual characters like Luneth and Refia. Not much, but better than literally nothing.
The thin characters in FF3 DS aren't worth doubling or tripling the playtime.