My mind refuses to believe this. This behavior is just disgusting. The police getting their own children out has me fucking livid.
We'll need to see the timeline of events before giving proper judgement. If the killer was already holed up somewhere then the police actions were correct. But if he was still actively killing, it was obviously horrendous. My initial guess is that the police force lacked the translators & community advocates to properly explain the choices they made during the tragedy.
So you agree that emergency drills cause people to do horrible things like this? Because that's literally what the tweet ends with.
That's still deeply stupid and no better. Anything to deflect from the gun issue.No no he's saying plants the idea of how to effectively commit the crime, not the idea of committing it itself
Hayes is saying the shooter planned the attack based on the drill protocols he knew would be in place because he went through the drills.
God, the community would've been better served by spending that money on literally anything else, even something cop-adjacent like animal control, to say nothing of social services. If the cops were going to call CBP anyway — and maybe that makes sense in a small town? — they don't need this funding.
That's a botched up paraphrase from a NY Post article. I wouldn't hinge on it until there's another source.Didn't they go into get their own kids out though while keeping all the other parents out? Like this whole thing sounds dodgy af.
What's ghoulish is the pr for the cops was their boss saying they did such a good job securing the scene abd isolating the shooter/barricading him in a class room
Only what that actually meant is from what I've gathered:
1. They barely engaged with the shooter outside the school after he emerged from a crashed vehicle
2. They followed followed him inside (aka they conceeded entrance to the school to him because they were afraid if being hurt).
3 They tracked him to a classroom, an occupied classroom full of kids and teachers, watched him lock the door.
4. Then the cops backed off feeling proud that they isolated the shooter... while the shooter proceeded to butcher those kids and teachers over the next 40 minutes because no one could bother to defeat a locked door
5. And in the end whike they retreated to the exterior to pacify distraught parents with more force and effort than anything they did in the name of stopping the shooter... it was a maverick ICE agent who took it upon himself to go in, get a staff member to unlock the door finally after 40-60 minutes and took down the shooter.
6. The police then rewrote all these events as acts if effective heroism and made it sound like they prevented more death, when in reality all those deaths were 100% enabled by their decisions and cowardness.
Looking at the swat photo the majority appear to be Minorities themselves. I think this had less to do about race and more to do about the corrupt and broken police system working as intended. The police exist to punish and put fear into citizens. They do not exist to protect the citizens. The police unions have made sure of that in that it is basically procedure to never risk their own safety while on duty.
Do you have an article on this? I hope this gets blasted everywhere... i doubt it will change anything, but this need to be known... damn this is horrible
Honestly, yes it is and you should know better. Well then let's just do fucking nothing and see how great that turns out.[
No it isn't
There's not much evidence that these drills do anything, except give cops a chance to play out their bad guy fantasies and traumatize children.
I've yet to see any meaningful evidence that these drills save lives, and now we've seen they've been in place so long that shooters are getting old enough to have gone through the drills themselves and use the protocols to their advantage.
There's a video posted here where the cop spox confirms it.That's a botched up paraphrase from a NY Post article. I wouldn't hinge on it until there's another source.
"Think of the property damage!"excuse me??? a staff member had to unlock the door with a KEY
I guess their guns are only for shooting people, not locks
As I said earlier in the thread , sometimes doing things that is security theatre and not actually evidence based effective, can be worse than doing nothing . For example if you do breast scans when a person is younger it's far likelier to led to false positives that lead to treatment a patient doesn't need. In this case if the drills don't work and I'm not sure I'be ever seen evidence they do work, in best case you are traumatising generations of children for something with no benefit and worst case as mass shooters are young men, they are not long out of school and have the drill preparation's fresh in their head. That's without getting into the fact that by doing school shooter drills it has allowed politician's to make it seem like they have done something , and not actually implement things that have evidence to work like gun control laws and dealing with the issues of radicalised racist/sexist young men. Why do you think politicians are suddenly focusing on arming teachers as a solution? They want to seem to do something even if it doesn't work. Look gun control laws is the thing I would focus on but I don't think the idea that doing shooter drills isn't a great idea and has negative impacts on kids is that controversialHonestly, yes it is and you should know better. Well then let's just do fucking nothing and see how great that turns out.
It's literally just there to distract from the actual issue: people having too easy access to guns. Anything to keep us from talking about the actual issue.
One can easily argue that accepting active shooter drills is acquiesing to not doing anything either. Similar to tornado drills and fire drills, shooter drills are accepting that armed gunmen are a natural occurrence. I would like to see stats on how many active shooter drills have saved lives as opposed to traumatizing kids and at worst, giving some kids an idea on how shootings can be implemented but I already have a feeling that they're not as beneficial.Honestly, yes it is and you should know better. Well then let's just do fucking nothing and see how great that turns out.
It's literally just there to distract from the actual issue: people having too easy access to guns. Anything to keep us from talking about the actual issue.
Honestly, yes it is and you should know better. Well then let's just do fucking nothing and see how great that turns out.
It's literally just there to distract from the actual issue: people having too easy access to guns. Anything to keep us from talking about the actual issue.
Active shooter drills became one of the most common school safety measures implemented nationwide in recent years, despite widespread fears that the procedures heighten anxiety, and evidence that school shooters, like the one in Parkland, Florida, use knowledge of the drills to their advantage. Teachers unions in February called for schools to not conduct active shooter drills with students. Now, new research adds data to those concerns.
A report released Thursday, obtained in advance by NBC News, found active shooter drills in schools correlated with a 42 percent increase in anxiety and stress and a 39 percent increase in depression among those in the school community, including students, teachers and parents, based on their social media posts.
The Indiana Legislature passed a law last year requiring each district conduct an active shooter drill in the first 90 days of the school, which the state has not waived in light of the COVID-19 pandemic. The Indiana State Teachers Association said it lobbied unsuccessfully to tack on a prohibition on the firing of plastic projectiles during the drills.
Jaclyn Schildkraut, a professor of criminal justice at the State University of New York at Oswego, studies school lockdown drills.
The drills were necessary, she said, because adolescents felt "more prepared and more empowered. It is better to have it and not need it than need it and not have it."
But the drills may harm the mental health of students, while doing little to prevent mass shootings.
"There hasn't been a strong body of evidence that these drills are helping," Megan Carolan, vice president of research at the Institute for Child Success, said.
In fact, some critics say, the focus on "hardening" schools could detract from strategies that could actually prevent shootings from taking place. Those measures could include stricter gun laws, better threat assessment and more mental health counseling in schools to help students cope with strong emotions.
"The response was executed perfectly, yet four children were killed and multiple injuries occurred," said Karen McDonald, the Michigan prosecutor whose office is overseeing the criminal case. "We really can't train ourselves out of this tragedy."
According to a new report by Everytown for Gun Safety, the National Education Association (NEA) and the American Federation of Teachers, unannounced active shooter drills are a detrimental and unproven school safety tactic.
"Everywhere I travel, I hear from parents and educators about active shooter drills terrifying students, leaving them unable to concentrate in the classroom and unable to sleep at night," said NEA President Lily Eskelsen García. "That is why, if schools are going to do drills, they need to take steps to ensure the drills do more good than harm."
Are active shooter drills in schools currently doing any good? That's hard to say because "there is extremely limited research available on drills' effectiveness," according to the report. Two studies have suggested they can be constructive if they are announced in advance and take proactive measures to reduce student anxiety.
In addition to criticizing unannounced shooter drills, the report also singles out so-called ALICE drills. ALICE stands for alert, lockdown, inform, counter, and evacuate. During these drills, schools carry out an actual simulation of a shooter situation, complete with pretend intruders who often fire off blanks or rubber pellets.
Not surprisingly, the psychological toll can be significant, says Janet Shapiro, dean of the Graduate School of Social Work and Social Research at Bryn Mawr College.
"Young children have a hard time telling the difference between fantasy and reality especially when stressed or anxious," Shapiro told NEA Today in 2019. "Which is why you hear about many younger students crying inconsolably during drills. Even second and third graders can regress under the stress of a lockdown drill and the fear and anxiety they may cause — the drill itself calls attention to the possibility of a mass shooter in the school, and kids vary in terms of their ability to reassure themselves that the drill is not real."
A drill at an East Orange, New Jersey middle school in 2018 left one student wondering if she was going to "finish the day alive."
"That drill made me get mad at the school and everything," the eighth-grader said. "It really made me angry and sad and feel kind of trapped, because what am I supposed to do?"
In December, a senior and her classmates at Lake Brantley High School in Orlando were traumatized after a drill prompted them to hide in closets and locker rooms, not knowing whether there was a real gunman lurking on campus. She told the Orlando Sentinel that she woke up the following morning not wanting to return to school.
Unbelievably, staff at Meadowlawn Elementary School in Indiana were lined up against a school wall and shot in the back with pellet guns. "They told us, 'This is what happens if you just cower and do nothing,'" one teacher told The Indy Star. "I was hit four times. It hurt so bad," one teacher said.
And in 2013, A history teacher at Worcester's Claremont Academy in Massachussetts left the classroom sobbing after an active shooter drill involved a hooded man pointing a gun at teachers' heads and shouting "bang!"
So, despite a lack of evidence over their effectiveness and rising fears over the toll on students and staff, why are active shooter drills in schools so common?
As the Everytown report points out, school safety is big business, and these drills are a $2.7 million industry. The ALICE Training Institute ("The company behind America's scariest school drills," says the The Huffington Post) cultivates the belief that a more "proactive" tactics are the way to save student lives. For example, ALICE trainers advise students and educators to consider "countering," or confronting an intruder - advice many experts believe is dangerous.
Eager to demonstrate decisive, quick action, school districts officials have purchased products ranging from mega-expensive state-of-art surveillance technology, to metal detectors, facial recognition software, bullet-proof whiteboards, and fortified entries. It's time to stop fortifying our schools, and focus on proven strategies that will protect our students.
While these improvements would be a welcome step, undue attention on drills leaves too little space for more proven solutions, said Sari Kaufman, a survivor of the shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland and a member of the Students Demand Action national advisory board, "like keeping all firearms in the home secured and passing red flag laws."
At the national level, the House of Representatives passed two bills aimed at expanding background checks on gun purchases, but both have stalled from lack of support from the U.S. Senate and White House.
"The fact that we're focusing on these drills at all is a failure of the Administration and Senate to take any meaningful steps to address the fact that too many very dangerous people have very easy access to very dangerous weapons," said Eskelsen García. "We need to pass common-sense measures to keep guns away from people who shouldn't have them."
Cogan says there is no evidence to show that the drills are effective in preparing students, teachers, and administrators to deal with gun violence in schools.
"While the incidence of school shootings is rare, now more than 95 percent of schools across the country have active-shooter drills," says Cogan, who also works as a school nurse in Camden. "We do not prepare our students for fire drills by making them walk through smoke and debris-filled hallways."
Cogan worries about the impact that the drills have on the psychological development of young children, and the effect the drills have on school nurses.
In the article, the authors share concerns from school nurses who have participated in active-shooter drills. One nurse reports that her heart sank the day she was in her office when she heard the sounds of gunshots from the school's loudspeaker. She did not know if it was an unannounced lockdown drill or if there was an active shooter in the building. Instinctively, she locked her office door, closed the blinds, and hid in a corner. After she found out it was just a drill and the gunfire sounds were from an app used by the person running the drill, she did not understand the need to endure the fear and concern for herself and everyone in the building.
"Our brains cannot always differentiate when an incident is real or just a drill," says Cogan, who adds that there is no evidence that even some of the most recognized programs – including Alert Lockdown Inform Counter Evacuate (ALICE), which uses a run, hide, fight options framework – are effective in preventing injuries.
Among the problems Cogan sees with the programs are that they are not evidence-based and do not consider the students' ages and developmental stages, if they have special health care needs, or if they have learning challenges.
"These are reactive measures and are not taking into consideration the need for preventative programs to create a culture of kindness, acceptance, and safety in schools," says Cogan. "Money is being spent on hardening schools instead of softening them."
Active shooter drills vary widely across the country. Some unfold unannounced and involve actors dressed as masked gunmen, teachers being lined up and shot with an airsoft rifle and students as young as 3 years old told to hide in a small space for long periods of time, the report said.
"What these drills can really do is potentially trigger either past trauma or trigger such a significant physiological reaction that it actually ends up scaring the individuals instead of better preparing them," said Melissa Reeves, former president of the National Association of School Psychologists, in the report.
Evidence is "scant" that drills are effective at preventing deaths in school shootings while there is "extremely limited" research on their effectiveness, the authors wrote in the report.
One can easily argue that accepting active shooter drills is acquiesing to not doing anything either. Similar to tornado drills and fire drills, shooter drills are accepting that armed gunmen are a natural occurrence. I would like to see stats on how many active shooter drills have saved lives as opposed to traumatizing kids and at worst, giving some kids an idea on how shootings can be implemented but I already have a feeling that they're not as beneficial.
The alternative to schools is to do nothing.
This is an insane argument.
Looks like the police went and got their own kids while simultaneously blocking other parents from going in
Source?Looks like the police went and got their own kids while simultaneously blocking other parents from going in
There is no source. A NYPost article quoted someone as saying the cops evacuated their own kids but there was no elaboration on what that actually meant and no other outlet has reported that.
Shitty time to find out that the police aren't the good ones.I thought others with guns would stop this shit. 🤔
Man fuck this shit. It's infuriating seeing the pigs standing around with their guns not doing shit when the pro gun advocates are always spilling this dumb shit narrative that you just need others with guns so they can go rambo and stop shit. Clearly the fuck not.
Next time someone says that, this video should be shown.
There is no source. A NYPost article quoted someone as saying the cops evacuated their own kids but there was no elaboration on what that actually meant and no other outlet has reported that.
There is no source. A NYPost article quoted someone as saying the cops evacuated their own kids but there was no elaboration on what that actually meant and no other outlet has reported that.