If this wasn't Silent Hill, I probably would have just laughed at the botched launch with the broken app, absolute disaster of chat-function and lack of moderation, ridiculous monetization, mind-numbingly basic puzzles, NPC cameos and non-functioning audience voting and live quick-time events and other (non-)gameplay aspects etc. and then forgot about it and moved to the next thing.
But because this is Silent Hill, one of the greatest video game IP's ever produced and my favorite series of all time, I need to see this train-wreck through.
The real catch is the actual story, how it is delivered and the characters within. I think a lot of Ascension's commentary get focused on the things mentioned above, but there's so much wrong with the actual series.
The acting and the animation is one thing. There's a real lack of emotions in the scenes and the characters despite the fact the developers really want the audience to have a connection to the characters or their fate (which should be the thing why people would want to spend money or time in the app to have the ability to vote). The viewer is given all these characters they have no reason to care about at all.
Instead of giving the audience time to connect with the characters, the series just throws the viewer in the middle of these scenes that just don't work. After the first day or two, the daily episodes are couple minutes long at best, so the story must jump from a one scene to another, but there's no connection with what happened before. The locations don't match, there's always some new character (or even worse, an audience avatar) introduced and promptly discarded, or some monster shows up that instead of being uncanny, scary, or disturbing, ends just being funny or ridiculous. And because there are 3 stories going at once, it gets more and more hard to care about what has or will happen.
Every main and secondary character has a pretty basic set of problems.
- Karl, a sad man who might have or have not killed his wife (who was a terrible person), but he's not really sure himself about that either. Maybe it was a monster….
- Astrid, hates his dad for killing her mother (who she also kinda hated) with a troubled son and and alcoholic sister. Of yeah, she soon might or might not kill her son (which hasn't happened yet, but they already spoiled this.)
- Rachel who might have or not killed her fellow cultist Joy (also an addict), also the cults nro.1 zealot (by the characters description in the game, but it doesn't seem like that at all in the actual story). She also has a daughter, wouldn't be surprised if she get's killed too.
- Toby, an alcoholic who wants to revenge the cult for killing her sister (Joy), but is also haunted by because, she made her sister an addict too or something.
- Then there's Eric, Rachel's husband and Toby's friend whose fault is that he's soft? I think. Or maybe is that he needs to choose between his wife or a friend (we the audience, don't have any kind of connection to either Eric, Rachel or Toby, so it's hard to care.).
When you have 3 might-be murderers, 3 addicts, 2 troubled kids (3 if you count Eva, Karls neighbor/babysitter or something like that) and more, the cast is already bigger than all of Silent Hill 1-4 combined. Then there's the cultist, the police, the random audience NPC-characters (whose role has been pretty been to give the audience the three options they can choose for every damn scene in the most obvious way). It's so hard to care about any of these.
The pacing is off in both the actual episodes and scenes itself. And it doesn't help that you instantly notice the change of tone when the audience choice scene changes to a normal scene, because the cuts are often so unnatural. To add to that, there has been multiple scenes, where the voice actors seems to forget to the accent they should be speaking with, that it creates an actual uncanny feeling that might have been the most disturbing part of the series.
I don't get in to if the series understand or respects the Silent Hill lore yet before the story is finished. But like in today's episode, where they in a minute part directly stole an scene from SH2 (the first lying figure appearance) and kinda tried to do the "they looked like monsters to you"-scene from SH3 (both with a lot less success), I wouldn't put my money on it…
To sum it, maybe I'm hate watching this, but at the same time I really want to see what ridiculous thing comes up in the next episode.