This. I think there was too much trying to find the boogeyman of why the numbers aren't good, people just aren't interested in it, it seems. I know this is the PlayStation Studio thread, and I myself put PS games on somewhat of a pedestal also, but not every game needs to be vehemently defended because it's associated with the brand. I'm not saying people didn't genuinely defend the game because they liked it, but I feel like of this was an EA or Ubisoft game, this game would not have taken up so much of the conversation and energy that it did. And on the flip side, I don't think it would have received much of the vitriol it did either.While I do not deny that there is a hatred for Concord from PlayStation fans, I do not think that really bleeds over into PC. I doubt that the whole "PS Studios is doing too much live service games" conversation has much of an effect on the PC community. They aren't on their knees begging for more single player games from Sony like those who own a PS5. They just play whatever comes their way really. Concord just didn't catch on at all in the PC crowd after two weekends of the beta. If a AAA game from a studio full of veterans can't get more than 2,400 players on at any point in a beta, then that is a bad sign. Yes, there is plenty of hate going around between "controversies" like live service/GAAS and pronouns, but that alone isn't going to drag the game this bad. Helldivers 2 was certainly able to beat the former and become a success. While the $40 price tag probably hurts given that it is a hero shooter, it is proven time and time again that people are willing to pay for great games. I think that there is a good game in Concord, I had fun with the beta, but it seems to be missing that "it" factor that will keep it from going viral.
The only other thing I can think of is the PSN requirement for PC being an issue. If that is legitimately hurting Concord's chances, then Sony needs to examine that.
I think maybe FairGame$ has a better shot if the game is very different than what is already out there. For me personally. I had fun with Concord, but I was never gonna be a hero shooter guy so I was never the audience. But it was fun enough that I may pick up on discount.