Status
Not open for further replies.
Oct 25, 2017
35,709
I have to wonder if Rockstar's high placement is due to people confusing him with Rocks D. Xebec.
He literally had one scene, was treated like a joke, and hasn't appeared since. Unless he's a meme pick.
 

Dougieflesh

One Winged Slayer
The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
32,725
Milky Way Ghetto
latest


My mans really just casually rolled up into the Top 50
This was the funniest placement for me
 

grand

Member
Oct 25, 2017
27,622
I have to wonder if Rockstar's high placement is due to people confusing him with Rocks D. Xebec.
He literally had one scene, was treated like a joke, and hasn't appeared since. Unless he's a meme pick.
It's not rank choice voting so it doesn't take much to push a random character above more iconic characters. Based on previous polls, the Top 20 likely took 90% of the votes so the rest is just static noise in terms of ranking.
 

Furisu

Poutine on the Ritz
Member
Dec 5, 2018
3,009
I am happy that my three favorite characters (Buggy, Moria, Big Mom) made it into the top 100

I am also surprised that Cracker, Mont d'Or and Perospero made it into the top 100. Charlotte family did better than I expected.
 

Lotus

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
113,530
I am happy that my three favorite characters (Buggy, Moria, Big Mom) made it into the top 100

I am also surprised that Cracker, Mont d'Or and Perospero made it into the top 100. Charlotte family did better than I expected.

Glad Perospero got some love

As always, oof at Smoothie
 

grand

Member
Oct 25, 2017
27,622
You know who didn't rank in the entire Top 200? Caribou. Oda has successfully made everyone forget him before the inevitable plot twist
 

Compbros

Member
Oct 30, 2017
6,089
Carrot is a real shock at top 20. It felt like Carrot for Strawhat was pushed aside when Yamato debuted and she hasn't done much in Wano yet. I'm surprised the recency bias didn't put Kaido top 20.
 

grand

Member
Oct 25, 2017
27,622
Carrot is a real shock at top 20. It felt like Carrot for Strawhat was pushed aside when Yamato debuted and she hasn't done much in Wano yet. I'm surprised the recency bias didn't put Kaido top 20.
It's a fan favorite underage sexy bunny girl who is one of the top 2 shipped characters in the series

If anything, her popularity is the only thing keeping her relevant in the series lol

**Note: this goes both ways as Law was instantly popular upon reveal. But at least with Law, Oda gave him a plot & character arc
 

Lotus

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
113,530
Dragon could be Shanks tier by now if Oda would just finally give him focus lol
 

Rouk'

Member
Jan 10, 2018
8,893
Updated top with the change compared to the 6th poll

21./ Nefeltari Vivi (24↑)
22./ Bentham (25↑)
23./ Eustass Kid (37↑)
24./ Kozuki Oden (NEW)
25./ Perona (23↓)
26./ Brook (19↓)
27./ Smoker (33↑)
28./ Franky (20↓)
29./ Gol D. Roger (39↑)
30./ Dracule Mihawk (22↓)
31./ Edward Newgate (28↓)
32./ Going Merry (60↑)
33./ Silvers Rayleigh (38↑)
34./ Buggy (35↑)
35./ Enel (44↑)
36./ Kuzan (26↓)
37./ Woop Slap (00↑)
38./ Tashigi (33↓)
39./ Vinsmoke Reiju (14↓)
40./ Bartolomeo (30↓)
41./ X Drake (90↑)
42./ Koby (58↑)
43./ Rob Lucci (43=)
44./ Monkey D. Garp (00↑)
45./ Charlotte Pudding (29↓)
46./ Marshall D. Teach (49↑)
47./ O-Kiku (NEW)
48./ Izo (81↑)
49./ Kozuki Hiyori (NEW)
50./ Shirahoshi (32↓)
51./ Pell (57↑)
52./ Issho (53↑)
53./ Sakazuki (70↑)
54./ O-Tama (NEW)
55./ Killer (129↑)
56./ Ulti (NEW)
57./ Ben Beckman (55↓)
58./ Koala (36↓)
59./ Borsalino (77↑)
60./ Gaimon (63↑)
61./ Pedro (63↑)
62./ Monkey D. Dragon (85↑)
63./ Thousand Sunny (100↑)
64./ Bepo (42↓)
65./ Kaido (97↑)
66./ Rockstar (00↑)
67./ Dr. Hiriluk (76↑)
68./ Rebecca (41↓)
69./ Paulie (100↑)
70./ Urouge (50↓)
71./ Namule (00↑)
72./ Señor Pink (47↓)
73./ Cavendish (13↓)
74./ Gecko Moria (111↑)
75./ Karoo (55↓)
76./ Monet (81↑)
77./ Kaku (70↓)
78./ Orlumbus (00↑)
79./ Emporio Ivankov (77↓)
80./ Morgans (00↑)
81./ Belle-Mère (77↓)
82./ Basil Hawkins (75↓)
83./ Denjiro (NEW)
84./ Gin (121↑)
85./ Jewelry Bonney (68↓)
86./ Charlotte Linlin (70↓)
87./ Marguerite (104↑)
88./ Wyper (134↑)
89./ Kung-Fu Dugongs (86↓)
90./ Charlotte Mont d'Or (00↑)
91./ Caesar Clown (54↓)
92./ Kin'emon (113↑)
93./ Zeff (90↓)
94./ Vista (00↑)
95./ Charlotte Perospero (00↑)
96./ Kawamatsu (NEW)
97./ Pandaman (51↓)
98./ Bartholomew Kuma (129↑)
99./ Charlotte Cracker (00↑)
100./ Chouchou (97↓)
101./ Nekomamushi (31↓)
102./ Baby 5 (70↓)
103./ Penguin (70↓)
104./ Kuro (129↑)
105./ Mont Blanc Noland (00↑)
106./ Falafra (48↓)
107./ Iceberg (00↑)
108./ Mikita (86↓)
109./ Laboon (100↓)
110./ Kyros (141↑)
111./ Vinsmoke Niji (94↓)
112./ Bacchy (00↑)
113./ Curly Dadan (192↑)
114./ Makino (86↓)
115./ Vinsmoke Ichiji (58↓)
116./ King (NEW)
117./ Gedatsu (00↑)
118./ Kalifa (62↓)
119./ Hannyabal (108↓)
120./ Diesel (00↑)
121./ Daz Bonez (134↑)
122./ Bellamy (129↑)
123./ Magellan (00↑)
124./ Higuma (00↑)
125./ Dr. Kureha (140↑)
126./ Page One (NEW)
127./ Belo Betty (NEW)
128./ Viola (138↑)
129./ Kalgara (121↓)
130./ Sugar (121↓)
131./ Raki (68↓)
132./ Foxy (00↑)
133./ Alvida (00↑)
134./ Ryuma (00↑)
135./ Jabra (129↓)
136./ Leo (94↓)
137./ Fish-Woman Nami (00↑)
138./ Conis (175↑)
139./ Arlong (104↓)
140./ Kumacy (77↓)
141./ Sasaki (NEW)
142./ Vinsmoke Yonji (90↓)
143./ Galdino (00↑)
144./ Queen (NEW)
145./ Ryunosuke (00↑)
146./ Rocks D. Xebec (NEW)
147./ Nezumi (00↑)
148./ Nojiko (00↑)
149./ Hina (121↓)
150./ Tyrannosaurus (113↓)
151./ Shimotsuki Yasuie (NEW)
152./ Tom (121↓)
153./ Kuina (94↓)
154./ Lord of the Coast (00↑)
155./ Thatch (138↓)
156./ Jaguar D. Saul (113↓)
157./ Fisher Tiger (00↑)
158./ Capone Bege (52↓)
159./ Hiking Bear (148↓)
160./ Nico Olvia (108↓)
161./ Krieg (63↓)
162./ Marianne (Miss Goldenweek) (155↓)
163./ Spandam (86↓)
164./ Gyro (00↑)
165./ Shachi (100↓)
166./ Boa Sandersonia (00↑)
167./ Sengoku (134↓)
168./ Black Maria (NEW)
169./ Scratchmen Apoo (179↑)
170./ Stussy (NEW)
171./ Kozuki Toki (NEW)
172./ Lucky Roux (121↓)
173./ T-Bone (00↑)
174./ Maynard (00↑)
175./ Straw Hat (Humanized) (NEW)
176./ Charlotte Smoothie (158↓)
177./ Spencer (NEW)
178./ Otohime (00↑)
179./ Mansherry (104↓)
180./ Kozuki Momonosuke (113↓)
181./ Babanuki (NEW)
182./ Koza (00↑)
183./ Kaya (113↓)
184./ Jack (168↓)
185./ Saint Charlos (00↑)
186./ Shakuyaku (00↑)
187./ Speed (NEW)
188./ Mont Blanc Cricket (00↑)
189./ Toko (NEW)
190./ Momonga (138↓)
191./ Victoria Cindry (00↑)
192./ Pearl (00↑)
193./ Kurozumi Kanjuro (175↓)
194./ Vinsmoke Sora (66↓)
195./ Shirley (00↑)
196./ Hattori (00↑)
197./ Vergo (121↓)
198./ Chimney (00↑)
199./ Gama Pyonnosuke (NEW)
200./ Portgas D. Rouge (175↓)
 
Last edited:

Cantaim

Member
Oct 25, 2017
34,133
The Stussining
Don't think I saw Whoop Slap on any of the rankings (unless I missed him at the bottom 50). Will be curious to see if he actually did crack the top 20 like some One Piece Youtubers wanted.
 

grand

Member
Oct 25, 2017
27,622
Don't think I saw Whoop Slap on any of the rankings (unless I missed him at the bottom 50). Will be curious to see if he actually did crack the top 20 like some One Piece Youtubers wanted.
He's #37

The Top 20 will be:
  • Luffy
  • Zoro
  • Sanji
  • Law
  • Ace
  • Robin
  • Nami
  • Sabo
  • Hancock
  • Shanks
  • Yamoto
  • Katakuri
  • Rosinate
  • Usopp
  • Chopper
  • Crocodile
  • Carrot
  • Marco
  • Jinbe
  • Doflamingo

In some order (my order is the midterm rankings)
 

Cantaim

Member
Oct 25, 2017
34,133
The Stussining
He's #37

The Top 20 will be:
  • Luffy
  • Zoro
  • Sanji
  • Law
  • Ace
  • Robin
  • Nami
  • Sabo
  • Hancock
  • Shanks
  • Yamoto
  • Katakuri
  • Rosinate
  • Usopp
  • Chopper
  • Crocodile
  • Carrot
  • Marco
  • Jinbe
  • Doflamingo

In some order (my order is the midterm rankings)
Ah you are right I missed him as for some reason I thought he had a different color scheme then he actually did. Thank you for the clarification.
 

edo_kid

Member
Oct 27, 2017
11,106
For a character that only gets L's he pretty high up... *cue pokémon music* who's that?

Its Smoker!!!
 

grand

Member
Oct 25, 2017
27,622
Good time to reiterate my idea that Carrot will get pulled into the Page One/Ulti fight. Usopp & Nami desperately need a physical fighter to help them and Carrot could fit the mold. I originally thought Chopper would be that character but he seems to be firmly tied up with the Live Floor.

Granted, Big Mom seems to have taken part of that role, though I doubt Page One is down for good. More damning is how far away Carrot is from everyone. Literally no one is hanging out at the docks anymore (unless Caribou is up to something)
 

Morlas

Looking for a better cartoon show.
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
74,276
Totally normal ass discussion, as expected of this thread
 

Geg

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,930
My internet was down all day so I had to watch the popularity thing on my shitty phone lol. I'm satisfied I got what I wanted with Carrot in the top 20.

So is Oda gonna draw like a color spread with all 50 characters in it? That seems unfeasible lol
 
Status
Not open for further replies.