Hmm, my rankings after sinking 158 hours into ER and beating it:
1) Bloodborne
2) Elden Ring
3) Demon's Souls
4) Dark Souls 3
5) Dark Souls
Not a fan of Sekiro and Dark Souls 2, so I'm not ranking them. Elden Ring still feels to me like an evolution of Dark Souls, and didn't really feel like enough of its own thing mechanically (the weapon arts and spirit summons are great, but they still felt like something that could naturally fit into the Dark Souls world). With all that said, I can eventually see myself going back and playing through it again, but unlike Bloodborne, I didn't immediately jump into a NG+ playthrough, because the game is massive, daunting, and the final boss made me so heated that I was too relieved to finally be done with it to jump into NG+ right away lol.
Bloodborne remains the GOAT From game for me still. ER is definitely a top tier From Software souls like, though.
EDIT: Ah, the screenshot in the OP was broken for me, so I didn't see tier rankings. Um, I guess I'd tier rank them:
S: Bloodborne, Elden Ring
A: Demon's Souls, Dark Souls 1, Dark Souls 3
C: Dark Souls 2, Sekiro
No B's and D's for me lol