As seen in my edit I know I said in my original post film critics and he's not, but still a respected person in the industry.
I'm not trying to say I disagree with flaws that Kojima has in his writing, but the "he'd get annihilated by film critics" posts seem a bit much when you have people who are highly respected in that industry praising lots of aspects of his work.
I also don't want him to make films either as we lose his unique approach to gameplay
I actually agree with that 2nd graf. I was personally too hasty and as a result went into hyperbole. I'm still not totally convinced he'd make a well-reviewed movie, but I was being way too hasty in saying he'd get savaged based on writing alone. As others have pointed out, he has some really decent chops for cinematography. Appreciate the links!