The Devs were pretty active on the subReddit before it got super toxic, and still post the patch notes there, respond to some comments about bugs after each patch etc. So they're definitely getting the feedback from players.
I don't think everyone in this OT needs to be loving the game. But I'm with Zastava that I don't want it to become anything like the toxic cesspool of negativity that subReddit is. The ONE, sole redeeming quality of Era that keeps me around is that the game OTs here are usually full of people mostly playing and enjoying the game at hand, with a lot of the negativity being in threads around issues in the game, the review thread etc. I'd like to see it stay that way. And so far it has. People, myself included, are civilly posting about their experiences with the game and pointing out both what they're enjoying and what they aren't.
The toxic people have mostly stayed out after the first couple of week and just come into separate threads when ones where made about issues with the level 1 weapon, or equipping one legendary only got their own threads. And that's the way it should be IMO. When major negatives arise, threads should be made to call attention to them on the front page of Gaming--and that also keeps this OT in Hangouts from getting tons of shitposts and leaves it for those of us still playing and mostly enjoying the game to casually and civilly chat about it.
I hope Era stays this way with the OTs being generally positive, casual chats after the first couple of weeks--even for divisive games like this. If that changes, and they end up toxic like game-specific subReddits for divisive games I'd just be completely done with online gaming communties as the OTs here are the last bastion for me.
I dont think the OT here will ever be that bad. Mostly from what I've seen everyone here plays the game and is mostly positive about it. Plus mods would be in them pretty quick if it was just people coming to one off a post in here.
The soundtrack is phenomenal. Agreed though that it is a little sad to see a lot of the good in the game overlooked. It feels like no one really compliments how great it all looks, how well put together the cutscenes are, some top tier animation work both in cutscenes & gameplay, the soundtrack, etc. I suppose much of it is subjective but all of that stuff is very well done imo.
I know for myself that there's a lot of positive, especially when I was enjoying the main path and the conversations in the game, and there's plenty of times I admire the game while I'm playing it whether that be its music, or the beautiful world. But my experience has been at least a good 40% spent in loading screens, error messages, and being kicked to the main screen right before the after action report. Just quick play alone has been roughly 60% bugged for me where I have to quit out because the mission won't continue and there's no way forward. It's so hard to appreciate the good in this game when I can't even play it free of these issues. I have yet to actually quit out of Anthem by choice. I usually stop playing when it boots me out lol. Not the greatest of feelings that the games leaves you with.
With that being said, for people that have had experiences like mine, I can't blame them for over looking all the positive, they by all means should have thrown their copy in the trash day 1. But like you mentioned, its a shame, because there's a lot of good that the developers at BioWare achieved with this game. There's a lot of success and it's sad that a lot of people will never get to experience the positive that the game has to offer.