Honestly think he just doesn't like slow storytelling wrestling. If Punk and MJF would of done Car Crash Wrestling with flips and super moves and no selling he would of given it 7 out of 5 stars. But because it's "old" school in slow and methodical Wrestling it's just not for him. Which is fair and what makes AEW great something for everyone.
Except he didn't give the Bucks match 5 stars this time. I agree with most of his ratings for a change... except MJF/Punk and Cargill/Tay should have been slightly higher.