Yeah, a lot of the comments for that article are trash. It's not hard to understand that people just want things to look nice. Also I notice people are often dismissive by saying this was never a problem before. GameCube, the first Nintendo console to use icons for games hid them away, requiring you to go into the console settings and launch the game from there. Wii games was the first time icons became important to a Nintendo system and, as far as I know, every single game featured a title for their channel icon. The worst thing they could be was boringly animated. (I rather miss seeing a screen full of all these moving icons which blared out a little jingle when you selected one.) DS, 3DS and Wii U all had basic square icons so had no room for titles, they were still uniform however. Switch is the first to have this clash of two different styles. It's also the first system that keeps an icon of every game you've played even when you've taken the game cart out - it's very much wanting to show you your complete collection digitally.
I think comparing it to the album art of your music collection is very apt. There are those who will be lazy and not care about proper tagging and every cover is just a default 🎵 , whereas other will be very particular and want everything exact (and if some album art is ugly you could always replace it with your own 😊). Just because you don't care how things look doesn't mean those that do are crazy. I'm sure someone will point out there are album covers that have no words on them, but good luck trying to convince me your icon to your unknown property is as
iconic as The Dark Side of the Moon. (I actually didn't mind Super Meat Boy's original wordless icon since they've used that iconigraphy since the beginning of that game's development, but that game is very much an exception).
One comment on the NintendoLife article called this a meme. Dude, get lost.
I've noticed the word meme being used more and more to describe pretty much anything. Yes,
broadly speaking, a shared line of thinking amongst a community is a meme, but I highly doubt those using it as a substitute for phrases like 'argument', ' line of thinking', 'slang' etc are actually aware of the scientific origins of the word.