You know, I had no idea Spoony's Ultima stuff was 2012. Looking at his IMDB, I kind of time shifted a lot of stuff up in time. I thought FFVIII concluded shortly after 2008 (hence him using the election footage in it) and FFX being in 2009/2010. I stopped watching him entirely, look at this list, I guess 2011-ish and last thing I really sat and watched was the FFXIII review. So, in my mind, he was a lot earlier, and as a result I didn't see how/why people would find out about him today who didn't know about him during that time. I would check in every once in a while and see nothing but vlogs/wrestling and leave. Still, unless you are searching for his couple of big projects (Final Fantasy stuff, Phantasmagoria, and Ultima) I don't think a lot pops up. And, even before my break-off with following him, you could see the seams coming apart even before he finished the damn FFVIII review, which had huge gaps, as was with FFX which took a while as well. Heck, compare the play though of Phantasmagoria 2 with The Ripper. And, even taking your 2012 as the drop-off year, that's more than half a decade at this point.
Also, since he was on Blip/TGWTG, I don't know what his numbers/popularity were back then. I know he won a few awards here and there, but that was almost a decade ago. I guess I never pegged him, outside of those couple of videos/projects, as hugely popular, and it'd be like me asking "what happened to Handsome Tom, or GameJew, or The New Adventures of Captain S" and so on. (I'm still sad we never got a season 2 of New Adventures of Captain S, and no one ever knows what the hell I'm talking about when I bring it up).
I'll be honest, I was conflating my view of the whole spoony thing as something broader than it should have been.
The sad thing, and I'll let it be that, is that trying to find a chronology of his stuff, I stumbled upon his subreddit, where it appears his "fans" hang out, and it's a giant mess filled with people making fun of him, stalking his girlfriend, posting intimate details of his life, and outright gleeful at their harassment of him on twitter and the triumphant banning of him on twitter. And that's like me only looking at it for like 15 minutes. It's, like, no wonder he doesn't like his fans and would blow up at them.
Oh my god Captain S, damn that takes me back.
He did a crossover with AVGN right?