I remember the day I went to Walmart with my grandmother and I casually out 2 posters in the cart: One was of Sable from the WWF, one was Jenny McCarthy. I don't know why I thought she would have no reaction, but she asked me what they were (they sold them rolled up), I took her over to the poster rack to show her, and I'll never forget the look on her face lol. She told me "just get one" so I picked Jenny McCarthy. This was of course way before she turned out to be a shithead, I was like 12 years old.
I just found the poster online too haha, won't post it here obviously but it did bring back the memory.