Yeah, anyone who knows IGN's history with the Final Fantasy franchise should be more surprised that VII made it onto this list at all: It only made it into the 50s on their Top 100 RPGs list and couldn't even make it into their Top 5 Final Fantasy games. The overall impression I get is that most staff at IGN consider it an overrated mess. I'm somewhat surprised that any one of IV, IX, XII or Tactics didn't make the list at all as they've all usually been favoured over VII.Makes more sense when you see that FFVII topped IGN's "Most Overrated" list
Yeah, anyone who knows IGN's history with the Final Fantasy franchise should be more surprised that VII made it onto this list at all: It only made it into the 50s on their Top 100 RPGs list and couldn't even make it into their Top 5 Final Fantasy games. The overall impression I get is that most staff at IGN consider it an overrated mess. I'm somewhat surprised that any one of IV, IX, XII or Tactics didn't make the list at all as they've all usually been favoured over VII.
Wait, hold up! They took the Mario Galaxy series out because they felt like there was to much Mario!! The heck kind of decision making is that!? There is no way in this world a Galaxy game should not make a top 100 list.
Also, personally, Metroid Prime should be in the top 5.
All I did was post that I found its spot on the list humorous. You were the one going on about "grown men crying" or whatever you were talking about. Seems you might have a little more invested in this than you let on champ. ;)Because it's funny that some very vocal people are bothered that a game they don't really like is being ranked so highly. You don't see me bothered by games I think are hot trash or not all that great populating the list as folk just like what they like and there's nothing wrong that, whether those games are ranked #1 or whatever
So are games like Bloodborne, The Witcher 3, and God of War and folk have no problem calling them classics at this point
It is a classic. I don't recall ever disputing that
Considering that you've complained about the game being beloved several times, it seems that you're the one who's invested here. I'm not the one upset because games I don't really like are ranked highly. That and that post was a response to someone else about how folk here really can't seem to understand that these rankings are all that subjective so I'm not sure why you went for that and not the actual response I had for you but I can hazard a guessAll I did was post that I found its spot on the list humorous. You were the one going on about "grown men crying" or whatever you were talking about. Seems you might have a little more invested in this than you let on champ. ;)
That #55 is like the objectively mistake in that list.Ok but in all seriousness. Rise of the Tomb Raider is hardly the 55th best game on any of the systems it's released on, let alone of any game of all time.
The way the guy on the far right talks about OOT... fuck that guy, fuck everything about him, I don't need to hear anything else he says to know he has garbage opinions.
some of you are way too bitter about a damn list of videogames.
The way the guy on the far right talks about OOT... fuck that guy, fuck everything about him, I don't need to hear anything else he says to know he has garbage opinions.
Considering that you've complained about the game being beloved several times, it seems that you're the one who's invested here. I'm not the one upset because games I don't really like are ranked highly. That and that post was a response to someone else about how folk here really can't seem to understand that these rankings are all that subjective so I'm not sure why you went for that and not the actual response I had for you but I can hazard a guess
Yeah, it should've been higher. Would've gotten even more folk upset in this thread ;)
The Sims, which is #6 on the Most Overrated list, is #64 in the top 100.Makes more sense when you see that FFVII topped IGN's "Most Overrated" list
No thanks. It'd end up looking just like IGN's list, except it'd also have MGS4 in it.BTW, has there ever been an Era top 100 games of all time? Maybe we should do that.
You could almost get the impression that Nintendo makes some great games and has been doing so for some time now.
I really don't agree Zelda ALTTP deserves a number 2 spot. I played it a few weeks ago with a bit of nostalgia (my brother and I weren't able to finish it decades ago) and it is one of my least favorite 2D Zeldas. ALBW and Minish Cap both are miles ahead and Oracle of Seasons was also much more fun. It surely was revolutionary at its release, but by today's standards it is nothing special.
I agree with Portal 2 and BOTW, though. Two of my all time favorites.
Lol.The real Top 10
10. Puyo Puyo Tetris
9. Tetris Effect
8. Resident Evil 4 HD
7. Tropical Freeze
6. NES Tetris
5. Tetris DS
4. Resident Evil 4 GameCube
3. Tetris 99
2. Resident Evil 4 Wii Edition
1. Game Boy Tetris
nah, we all know only Sony produces great games, come on sonYou could almost get the impression that Nintendo makes some great games and has been doing so for some time now.
10- Super Mario 64
9- Red Dead Redemption
8- Half Life 2
7- Tetris
6- Super Mario Bros 3
5- Zelda Breath of the Wild
4- Super Metroid
3- Portal 2
2- Zelda A Link to the Past
1- Super Mario World
The real Top 10
10. Puyo Puyo Tetris
9. Tetris Effect
8. Resident Evil 4 HD
7. Tropical Freeze
6. NES Tetris
5. Tetris DS
4. Resident Evil 4 GameCube
3. Tetris 99
2. Resident Evil 4 Wii Edition
1. Game Boy Tetris
No thanks. It'd end up looking just like IGN's list, except it'd also have MGS4 in it.
barf.
I don't think I've seen Baldur's Gate 2 in the top 10 of any top games of all time list tbh but I'd be happy to see one .
i prefer BG1 its my favorite RPG
It's all subjective so I won't shit on their list but I will say it's mostly so far removed from my personal taste that I have multiple games that would make my top 10 that didn't even make their 100.
Who is "we"?At some point we need to accept that Tetris is literally just OK and nothing more, no version of it would belong even in a top 500 best games of all time.