Don't understand why people are trying to "kill" the E3.
I really enjoyed it, all these years, and I'll be sad if it goes away.
Xbox and Nintendo will probably just do their own digital showcases instead if E3 ends. The central argument against E3 with it being unnecessary applies just as much to SGF.His summer events have been duds the last two years. If there's no E3 event at all then sure it'll be great because it's the only show in town.
I dunno. I am sure I didn't post in the ER thread. I hadn't played a souls game until I started DeS PS5 about six weeks ago so ER really hasn't been on my radar until the network test stuff. I'm sure I saw the headlines but I had no idea it was part of any online event. Literally never heard of Summer Games Fest until last night in this thread.How though? You must have seen/posted in the Elden Ring trailer thread from last year's Summer Games Fest last?
I dunno. I am sure I didn't post in the ER thread. I hadn't played a souls game until I started DeS PS5 about six weeks ago so ER really hasn't been on my radar until the network test stuff. I'm sure I saw the headlines but I had no idea it was part of any online event. Literally never heard of Summer Games Fest until last night in this thread.
Gonna be honest, i started seeing more of that the moment Sony stopped showing upDon't understand why people are trying to "kill" the E3.
I really enjoyed it, all these years, and I'll be sad if it goes away.
started with sony dropping out then the leak rightfully cont itWhat's up with all the E3 hate? Microsoft and Nintendo still manage to put on some good shows. Wish Sony made a return.
What's with the E3 "love" ?What's up with all the E3 hate? Microsoft and Nintendo still manage to put on some good shows. Wish Sony made a return.
What's up with all the E3 hate? Microsoft and Nintendo still manage to put on some good shows. Wish Sony made a return.
I mean Nintendo's basically just been doing a direct for ages which could just as easily be done outside of the context of e3 (Hell you could argue they do do that since at this point there's not much difference between the e3 directs and all the other ones). The fact is Nintendo was actually way ahead of the curve on this one lolWhat's up with all the E3 hate? Microsoft and Nintendo still manage to put on some good shows. Wish Sony made a return.
started with sony dropping out then the leak rightfully cont it
What's with the E3 "love" ?
You don't need the ESA or E3 to organize your own show around the same time.
Because Microsoft and Nintendo can continue to put on good shows without E3 at all. It's not needed anymore.
I mean Nintendo's basically just been doing a direct for ages which could just as easily be done outside of the context of e3 (Hell you could argue they do do that since at this point there's not much difference between the e3 directs and all the other ones). The fact is Nintendo was actually way ahead of the curve on this one lol
i have no particular love for sony and i can assure you it's not thatIt's the same group aligned with the same console who don't want E3 to be a thing. And it started around the same time Sony started having nothing to show at the event.
Sony does a thing. Sony is 'very smart' and does the right thing most all the time. The thing Sony no longer does is incorrect. That is the progression on lots of topics in this space and this is one of them.
It's just another proxy console war.
It's the same group aligned with the same console who don't want E3 to be a thing. And it started around the same time Sony started having nothing to show at the event.
Sony does a thing. Sony is 'very smart' and does the right thing most all the time. The thing Sony no longer does is incorrect. That is the progression on lots of topics in this space and this is one of them.
It's just another proxy console war.
Beyond maybe SDCC (and even that has been somewhat supplanted by stuff like DC Fandome and Disney+ Day/Star Wars Celebration), I can't really think of any big "industry announce all things together and put on a show" in the entertainment industry - much more valuable for the different companies to create their own bespoke methods of communication that is tailored to their own needs and fans than try and get stuff together to announce things at the same time as everyone elseI miss when E3 was just a week for all the companies to put on fun shows and announce games. Ever since Sony pulled out the industry has felt a lot less fun.
You can assure me it isn't that for YOU.i have no particular love for sony and i can assure you it's not that
the esa is quickly becoming a relic, and in an all-digital world, E3 doesn't hold any value to publishers when they can just do their own shows without a middleman, and control their own narrative rather than be pitted against each other. the big 3 all knew this already, and without the inertia of past years and a show floor, they've got nothing to gain from being affiliated with it.
at the end of the day you're treating what was a week of advertisements and industry elbow rubbing as a holidayYou can assure me it isn't that for YOU.
I don't care what you want to call it, E3 week is a blast for anyone who isn't married to Playstation platforms. Granted, it was definitely better when they were there and if it takes getting away from ESA to bring them back into the fold I'm all for renaming it whatever.
A week to celebrate the industry with all the major players in one place trying to outdo each other while the entire industry descends on one place to get scoops, network, creat content for home audiences is great for everyone involved. The people who aren't involved are pretty much the only detractors. Sure, there are some people who truly hate the ESA and that is their main reason. But I think we are kidding ourselves if we believe thst is really the driving force on a place like Resetera. The main reason you see the upswell of negativity here is because a large group of the community is currently left out of the celebration every year.
Wait. Why do you think it is unhealthy?at the end of the day you're treating what was a week of advertisements and industry elbow rubbing as a holiday
that's unhealthy
I've not owned a Sony platform since the PS2 and I don't give a rats ass about watching endless marketing events either.You can assure me it isn't that for YOU.
I don't care what you want to call it, E3 week is a blast for anyone who isn't married to Playstation platforms. Granted, it was definitely better when they were there and if it takes getting away from ESA to bring them back into the fold I'm all for renaming it whatever.
A week to celebrate the industry with all the major players in one place trying to outdo each other while the entire industry descends on one place to get scoops, network, creat content for home audiences is great for everyone involved. The people who aren't involved are pretty much the only detractors. Sure, there are some people who truly hate the ESA and that is their main reason. But I think we are kidding ourselves if we believe that is really the driving force on a place like Resetera. The main reason you see the upswell of negativity here is because a large group of the community is currently left out of the celebration every year.
So why do you care if it exists or doesn't exist at all? Are you taking a side against an E3 type event?I've not owned a Sony platform since the PS2 and I don't give a rats ass about watching endless marketing events either.
Yep, E3 was great for gamers. E3 dying is a loss.I miss when E3 was just a week for all the companies to put on fun shows and announce games. Ever since Sony pulled out the industry has felt a lot less fun.
I'm responding to your insistence that everybody who isn't a Sony fan must feel the way you feel. I felt that would have been clear given my reply quoted the post when you made that insistence.So why do you care if it exists or doesn't exist at all? Are you taking a side against an E3 type event?
You specifically say you don't care at all, though. I obviously wasn't talking about people completely apathetic to the event because they don't even hold an opinion of the event. So, my post doesn't apply to them at all.I'm responding to your insistence that everybody who isn't a Sony fan must feel the way you feel. I felt that would have been clear given my reply quoted the post when you made that insistence.
because nothing you're promoting as a plus for it is exclusive to the E3 format. putting a bunch of reverence around a single event does nothing but limit the scope of the spotlight they can shine on the big names that can afford ESA fees and a position on the showfloor.
In my opinion it is a much better situation for absolutely anyone involved and for the consumer/watchers to have little events/streaming throughout the year that focusing in one specific day. That's why I am also not okay with hot The Game Awards are, you don't see trailers and ads for new movies being part of the Oscar/Golden Globes/Emmys ceremonies.Sure, they could all do Directs, but what's the fun in that? At least with E3, we know when to expect it, and we get a weekend filled to the brim with game videos from all major publishers (other than Sony). I guess I just prefer that model compared to spacing out several events over the course of a few months.
If that's what you meant it wasn't clear in your post, which contained things like:You specifically say you don't care at all, though. I obviously wasn't talking about people completely apathetic to the event because they don't even hold an opinion of the event. So, my post doesn't apply to them at all.
E3 week is a blast for anyone who isn't married to Playstation platforms
I'm still waiting for you to make an argument for this that isn't god awful.because nothing you're promoting as a plus for it is exclusive to the E3 format. putting a bunch of reverence around a single event does nothing but limit the scope of the spotlight they can shine on the big names that can afford ESA fees and a position on the showfloor.
we can get the same level of excitement multiple times a year thanks to all of the big 3 doing their own shows, and since they can cater this to a global audience, rather than the US-centric E3, they can include far more indie and foreign developers in those displays
nobody gains anything from E3 that can't be better replicated elsewhere, outside of a weird tribalism for it
Splitting the shows into smaller events over the course of the year definitely diminishes the impact of the event imo. You seem to be trying to put your personal preferences as facts. Even going so far as to say that someone who prefers something different than you as having unhealthy behavior. I guess we would have to move on here? I don't think we are going to come to an understanding, unfortunately.because nothing you're promoting as a plus for it is exclusive to the E3 format. putting a bunch of reverence around a single event does nothing but limit the scope of the spotlight they can shine on the big names that can afford ESA fees and a position on the showfloor.
we can get the same level of excitement multiple times a year thanks to all of the big 3 doing their own shows, and since they can cater this to a global audience, rather than the US-centric E3, they can include far more indie and foreign developers in those displays
nobody gains anything from E3 that can't be better replicated elsewhere, outside of a weird tribalism for it
For he most part, yes, majority of the events would seemingly happen without SGF, however there were events hosted by Geoff, including SGF kick-off event, an odd reveal here and there, and Gamescom.I still don't get what Summer Game Fest actually is. Wasn't it last year just a calendar and list of links to streaming events that would have happened anyway, even if there would be no SGF? I found it quite bad.
I should have peppered a few more imo in there. But I do think there is a LARGE group of detractors that are simply detractors because Sony isn't doing it anymore.If that's what you meant it wasn't clear in your post, which contained things like:
Just a reminder that the community around gaming is more diverse in opinion and outlook than what you believe and what motivations you ascribe to others.