Even after I've read a ton of reviews I am so undecided . Generally the ones giving it high praise are unashamed kojima fanboys and they even admit it (yong / skillup), however there are some things that I find really appealing and some that I know will be a massive grind to get through.
Love the world , traversal ideas (ladders/ropes) , insane story
Hate the idea of managing weight, constantly managing balance, long fetch quests being the only gameplay mechanic.
Given that fetch quests is such a core part of the game (40 hrs) I'm not sure I can push my way through it.
I was kind of hoping the horror parts would be more interspersed into the main world but it sounds like it is pretty easy to avoid.