• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

Deleted member 47318

User requested account closure
Banned
Sep 1, 2018
994
Inpressive that a spin-off (or more correctly, side-series) of a racing game on a single retail platform is somehow outpacing the year's biggest Ubisoft title that's available on three.
 

Apex88

Member
Jan 15, 2018
1,428
Once again people show a lack of understanding of the UK market.

More copies of FH4 are being sold via bundles than at retail. Digital is of course an unknown. Retail pricing has already hit the £30 mark as so many bundled codes are hitting the market.

All hardware received a boost in the UK thanks to RDR2's launch. With practically every XB bundle SKU either being an official FH4 bundle or an added value retailer addition. Fewer than 20k total will put a title in the UK top 10.


The UK is a small market. It's no more important than France, Germany etc., and a fraction of the entire European market. The weird importance given over to the UK is one of the reasons there is such a distorted view of the overall software market.
 

Pariah

Member
Oct 29, 2017
3,950
Soon we'll see Odyssey included in more bundles. Other european countries are adopting that move already. I guess when that happens, numbers will get closer, if not identical.
 

R.T Straker

Chicken Chaser
Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,715
Why are so many in this thread in such denial about FH4's sales? What's there to accomplish by downplaying it?

Not the first case either. *cough* MHW *cough*. Console wars are wierd.

Grats to the team, stellar game.
 

Zappy

Banned
Nov 2, 2017
3,738
I think this thread shows a lot of people don't really follow Xbox news. Because a) xbox sales are up YoY - the brand is recovering and the positivity around it is in full swing and b) FH3 did incredibly well sales wise and FH4 was highly anticipated and improved on FH3 in many ways.

But the sort of disbelief that a 90+ MC rated Xbox game is selling well, is a bit ridiculous given a and b above. Its one of the big releases towards the end of the year and one of the graphically most impressive games around. Of course it will do well. There is no need to knock Odyssey in this. FH4 has just been doing well, regardless of comparison. Xbox is still a vibrant market in the UK and whilst it doesn't sell as well as the PS4 its still quite significant and the brand is strengthening over the past 6 months after a very weak couple of years.
 

Prine

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
15,724
TLDR summary of the thread so far:
1) It's only for one week!
2) Oh it's LTD? Then obviously it hasn't outsold PS4 + XBO versions of ACO combined, this is XBO only
3) Oh right.. it's outselling both combined, really? Well Assassin's Creed Odyssey has bombed big time
4) It hasn't? Hmm.. well FH4 is cheaper than ACO, I've seen it cheap in places. That's the reason.
5) Game Pass helps increase sales
6) No it doesn't
7) Yes it does
8) No it doesn't
9) Sea of Thieves! 1
0) Bundles!! 11) RDR2

Its so repetitive, same circle in most well performing Xbox threads. Analyst themselves have step in to dismiss the downplaying, and yet it still goes on! The dissonance is quite something.

Edit: now the market itself is being questioned, lol. Fine, question it, but why would you specifically decide to do it in this type of thread?
 

Lukas Taves

Banned
Oct 28, 2017
5,713
Brazil
I don't know about the UK, but in other places FH4 is currently moving more units via bundles than the standalone game. It makes this specific comparison a bit more tricky.

Not to say FH4 isn't a great success, cause it is (and deservedly so).
Bundles are not exclusive to FH4, many of the touted as best selling games exclusives this generation had insane bundle sales.

I do think it's important to put bundle sales into perspective, but not in a way to dismiss the brand appeal.
 

chris 1515

Member
Oct 27, 2017
7,075
Barcelona Spain
TLDR summary of the thread so far:

1) It's only for one week!
2) Oh it's LTD? Then obviously it hasn't outsold PS4 + XBO versions of ACO combined, this is XBO only
3) Oh right.. it's outselling both combined, really? Well Assassin's Creed Odyssey has bombed big time
4) It hasn't? Hmm.. well FH4 is cheaper than ACO, I've seen it cheap in places. That's the reason.
5) Game Pass helps increase sales
6) No it doesn't
7) Yes it does
8) No it doesn't
9) Sea of Thieves!
10) Bundles!!
11) RDR2

Forza Horizon 4 is selling well but probably less than AC at it peaks. After like I said Racing games are popular in Europe and I would be curious to see the worldwide number if an Xbox console is more popular in continental europe maybe next generation.
 

TooBusyLookinGud

Graphics Engineer
Verified
Oct 27, 2017
8,099
California
Why are so many in this thread in such denial about FH4's sales? What's there to accomplish by downplaying it?

Not the first case either. *cough* MHW *cough*. Console wars are wierd.

Grats to the team, stellar game.
Because MS was suppose to sell off the Xbox division remember? No one buys Xbox games even though they are on Gamepass.

People in this thread act like MS don't R&D potential products and services. This place is turning into a hive mind just like the old stop.
 
Last edited:

Paxton25

Member
May 9, 2018
1,904
Are we pretending that UK sales are somehow representative of global performance? That's why these threads always irritate me. The UK is a tiny part of the overall market. To put it in perspective, Japan is about double the UK's size.

It's bizarre that people pay so much attention to UK sales when the UK is about as relevant as France, Germany, Italy or Spain.
Yeah how dare people talk about on of the biggest gaming markets in the world. How silly of them.
 

VinFTW

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,474
Forza Horizon 4 is selling well but probably less than AC at it peaks. After like I said Racing games are popular in Europe and I would be curious to see the worldwide number if an Xbox console is more popular in continental europe maybe next generation.
lmao what does this even mean?

This whole thread is one big "but..."

Grats to the team at PG, this is really impressive.
 

Paxton25

Member
May 9, 2018
1,904
Once again people show a lack of understanding of the UK market.

More copies of FH4 are being sold via bundles than at retail. Digital is of course an unknown. Retail pricing has already hit the £30 mark as so many bundled codes are hitting the market.

All hardware received a boost in the UK thanks to RDR2's launch. With practically every XB bundle SKU either being an official FH4 bundle or an added value retailer addition. Fewer than 20k total will put a title in the UK top 10.


The UK is a small market. It's no more important than France, Germany etc., and a fraction of the entire European market. The weird importance given over to the UK is one of the reasons there is such a distorted view of the overall software market.
It's bigger than the french gaming industry, not really sure why you are getting so annoyed at people talking about the UK.
 

Gamer17

Banned
Oct 30, 2017
9,399
honestly thats impressive. congrats to the dev. they are very talented. hope we get number leak so we have perspective on what we are discussing for uk market .
 

Femto0

Banned
Apr 28, 2018
2,591
Impressive results congrats to Playground unfortunately i don't like racing games but I will be day 1 for fable ;))
 

TechnicPuppet

Member
Oct 28, 2017
10,870
TLDR summary of the thread so far:

1) It's only for one week!
2) Oh it's LTD? Then obviously it hasn't outsold PS4 + XBO versions of ACO combined, this is XBO only
3) Oh right.. it's outselling both combined, really? Well Assassin's Creed Odyssey has bombed big time
4) It hasn't? Hmm.. well FH4 is cheaper than ACO, I've seen it cheap in places. That's the reason.
5) Game Pass helps increase sales
6) No it doesn't
7) Yes it does
8) No it doesn't
9) Sea of Thieves!
10) Bundles!!
11) RDR2

12 Even if true the UK market is teeny weeny
 

chris 1515

Member
Oct 27, 2017
7,075
Barcelona Spain
lmao what does this even mean?

This whole thread is one big "but..."

Grats to the team at PG, this is really impressive.

People are surprised because they think AC is a 10+ millions games but it is not the case anymore... The topic is not only about the Forza Horizon performance but it shows too the AC sales decreasing at the same time. Forza Horizon 4 sold well and the franchise is the best selling racing game at least in US and UK. But I think the sales can improve next generation if Xbox sales improve in continental Europe because most of racing sales game are in Europe.
 

Mr Delabee

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,165
UK

_id

Banned
Apr 18, 2018
212
I think RDR2 will open a lot of people up to the one x and they will see just how powerful the console is. Eventually they will seek out other graphically enhanced games and there's no other better than fh4 so gratz to them.
 

Starlatine

533.489 paid youtubers cant be wrong
Member
Oct 28, 2017
30,539
People are surprised because they think AC is a 10+ millions games but it is not the case anymore... The topic is not only about the Forza Horizon performance but it shows too the AC sales decreasing at the same time. Forza Horizon 4 sold well and the franchise is the best selling racing game at least in US and UK. But I think the sales can improve next generation if Xbox sales improve in continental Europe because most of racing sales game are in Europe.

Odyssey had the best opening for ac games in a while, if not ever (don't quite remember now)

How the hell the series are "declining"
 

pswii60

Member
Oct 27, 2017
26,726
The Milky Way
It was (don't know if it still is) the 5th biggest market in the world after China , USA, Japan and Germany.

32.4 million is now tiny....
UK is still the 5th largest videogame market in the world.
Correct me if im wrong, but isnt the uk market proven to not be representetive of global sales?
No single market is truly representative of global sales, obviously. But you look at that UK top 10 and is it really that much different to the rest of the Western markets?
 

Mr Delabee

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,165
UK
UK is still the 5th largest videogame market in the world.

No single market is truly representative of global sales, obviously. But you look at that UK top 10 and is it really that much different to the rest of the Western markets?

I updated my comment as I found a report that said it was now the biggest market in Europe, so that would make it the 4th biggest market in the world.
Although that's tiny apparently.
 

chris 1515

Member
Oct 27, 2017
7,075
Barcelona Spain
Odyssey had the best opening for ac games in a while, if not ever (don't quite remember now)

How the hell the series are "declining"

No AC retail sales decrease by 26 % compared to AC Origins for launch in UK

http://www.pushsquare.com/news/2018...les_down_26_percent_from_origins_at_uk_retail


https://www.jeuxvideo-live.com/news...le-les-ventes-lors-sa-premieere-semaine-87448

And AC franchise is not the juggernaut it was before sales after one week but AC Odyssey is the best AC sales this generation. We know it sold more than 1.59 millions worldwidw first week.

  • Assassin's Creed III - 3.52 millions
  • Assassin's Creed II - 3.27 millions
  • Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag - 2.36 millions
  • Assassin's Creed: Revelations - 2.22 millions
  • Assassin's Creed Unity - 1.59 million
  • Assassin's Creed Origins - 1.51 million
  • Assassin's Creed - 1.24 million
  • Assassin's Creed Brotherhood - 990 000 exemplaires
  • Assassin's Creed Syndicate - 920 000 unités

https://www.altchar.com/games-news/578577/ac-odyssey-sets-record-first-week-sales-for-the-franchise
 
Last edited:

chris 1515

Member
Oct 27, 2017
7,075
Barcelona Spain
...so it's not declining?

Did AC Odyssey sold more than AC 3? No the serie is not at it peak anymore. Worldwide many PS4 exclusivity sold better first two weeks, maybe Halo 5 too. AC Odyssey is the best AC sales this generation we just don't know the number because Ubi soft hide it, the game sold more than 1,59 millions and less than last generation AC... And it is a decline from it peaks.
 

Starlatine

533.489 paid youtubers cant be wrong
Member
Oct 28, 2017
30,539
Did AC Odyssey sold more than AC 3? No the serie is not at it peak anymore. Worldwide many PS4 exclusivity sold better first two weeks, maybe Halo 5 too. AC Odyssey is the best AC sales this generation we just don't know the number because Ubi soft hide it, the game sold more than 1,59 millions and less than last generation AC... And it is a decline from it peaks.

"Not being on its peak" and "the series are declining" are two different things

One purposefully framed to belittle the merits of the others
 

Vault

▲ Legend ▲
Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,664
AC was declining but Origins and Odyseey have been an upswing for the series
 

Lukas Taves

Banned
Oct 28, 2017
5,713
Brazil
I've seen there are some new rules for posting around here now.

Pretty much all threads about the gamepass goes to "It doesn't make Sony to launch their games on gamepass, look at all those uncharted 4 sales".

I guess "a sale is a sale, no matter how that sale was made and even if the game was played" only matters when trying to downplay a high player count due gamepass.

When counting actual sales then of course bundles should be discounted, unless of course it's a ps4 bundle.

I'll make notes so I can comply with the rules on neewer threads.
 

chris 1515

Member
Oct 27, 2017
7,075
Barcelona Spain
"Not being on its peak" and "the series are declining" are two different things

One purposefully framed to belittle the merits of the others

I just expose a fact. Forza Horizon sales are rising, Forza Horizon 4 will probably sold more than Forza Horizon 3 but compare AC franchise, it is a fact but another one AC peak sales are currently probably out of reach for Forza Horizon franchise. Maybe one day it will not be the case but Xbox consoles need to sold much more in continental Europe.
 

VinFTW

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,474
People are surprised because they think AC is a 10+ millions games but it is not the case anymore... The topic is not only about the Forza Horizon performance but it shows too the AC sales decreasing at the same time. Forza Horizon 4 sold well and the franchise is the best selling racing game at least in US and UK. But I think the sales can improve next generation if Xbox sales improve in continental Europe because most of racing sales game are in Europe.
You are literally coming into a thread and stating FALSE things. Things you have no actual proof of. Why?

Why do you need to make up a reason for FH4 outselling AC?
 

Prine

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
15,724
I updated my comment as I found a report that said it was now the biggest market in Europe, so that would make it the 4th biggest market in the world.
Although that's tiny apparently.

Last time a looked, even when German market edged UK, the console section of UK is and has always been the biggest in EU. Not sure if other markets are seeing a decline in physical sales similar to the UK, which undoubtably would impact UKs market reporting.
 

chris 1515

Member
Oct 27, 2017
7,075
Barcelona Spain
You are literally coming into a thread and stating FALSE things. Things you have no actual proof of. Why?

Why do you need to make up a reason for FH4 outselling AC?

Where do I said false thing is AC Odyssey is the best selling AC of all time? No it is a fact recognized by Ubi Soft themselve. We just know first week sales are the best current generation more than 1,59 millions maybe it is 1,6 millions or 1,61 millions we have no idea Ubi did not give a number. One reason for FH4 to outsold AC Odyssey is the franchise growing the other reason is AC sales declining compared to the peak sales of the franchise. AC is not able to sold more than 3 millions first week, just a fact. It is the reality.

EDIT: And Another fact physical sales of AC Odyssey are in decline of 26% compared to AC Origins in UK. And the topic compare physical sales of FH4 against physical sales of AC Odyssey In UK AC physical sales decline between AC Origins and AC Odyseey. Again a fact!

EDIT: And FH4 is the best racing games and the growth of the franchise is normal and great, Playground gams and Microsoft disserve it. It is by far the best racing game on the market. Another fact they disserve more sales and it will arrive the day Xbox is more popular in continental Europe.
 
Last edited:
Oct 27, 2017
1,849
User Banned (1 day): Drive by post that doesn't contribute to the thread
Another amazing Xbox thread

Downplay, the thread
 

Visanideth

Banned
Oct 31, 2017
4,771
People need to realize that Assassin's Creed declining doesn't in any way, shape or form detract from the huge success that FH4 is.
 

OG_Thrills

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,655
In France, sell.fr provides the Xbox One Top 3 (using GSD data). We can see that AC:O charted better than Forza Horizon 4 on Xbox One between week 40 and 42.
But with the release of RDR2 in week 43 they're both out of this top 3 unfortunately.
Code:
France Xbox One Top 3 (sell.fr)

Week 40:
  1. AC:O
  2. FIFA19
  3. FH4

Week 41:
 1. COD:BO4
 2. AC:O
 3. FIFA19

Week 42:
 1. COD:BO4
 2. FIFA19
 3. AC:O

Week 43:
 1. RDR2
 2. COD:BO4
 3. RDR2 Special Edition

I appreciate the info but I'm referring to the pal chart which includes all software from all platforms. Specifically the frequency of XBOX exclusives selling well enough to chart? I'm sure they do pop up here and there but I've never seen it sustained with even an irregular frequency.
 

-girgosz-

Member
Aug 16, 2018
1,042
People are surprised because they think AC is a 10+ millions games but it is not the case anymore... The topic is not only about the Forza Horizon performance but it shows too the AC sales decreasing at the same time. Forza Horizon 4 sold well and the franchise is the best selling racing game at least in US and UK. But I think the sales can improve next generation if Xbox sales improve in continental Europe because most of racing sales game are in Europe.

Origins is above 10 million for sure
 

Hitokiri03

Member
Oct 25, 2017
975
Can we call the Motorsport games little side project now? :P

Playground Games is definitely one to watch next gen as they expand to other genres.
 

Braaier

Banned
Oct 29, 2017
13,237
Wow! Well deserved! I really enjoyed my time with it on Game Pass. Too bad my subscription is ending.
 

Starlatine

533.489 paid youtubers cant be wrong
Member
Oct 28, 2017
30,539
People need to realize that Assassin's Creed declining doesn't in any way, shape or form detract from the huge success that FH4 is.

People need to realize the series were declining but are now on a upswing again

This is not Forza against the lowest point AC ever been
 

chris 1515

Member
Oct 27, 2017
7,075
Barcelona Spain
People need to realize that Assassin's Creed declining doesn't in any way, shape or form detract from the huge success that FH4 is.

Did I say Forza Horizon don't disserve it success not all, it is by far the best racing game. And I consider it is incredible to grow sales for a racing franchise within current gen context. Forza sales are good but not as good as before. Gran Turismo sales are bad compared to franchise peak. Multiple racing games studio are now dead Evolution studios, Studio Liverpool, Codemasters is ok but lost money last year.

I think for exemple Forza Horizon 3 probably sold more than Gran Turismo Sport and I am curious to know where the ceiling for Forza Horizon sales are and I think the day Xbox console are more popular in continental Europe, we will have the answer.
 

Visanideth

Banned
Oct 31, 2017
4,771
People need to realize the series were declining but are now on a upswing again

This is not Forza against the lowest point AC ever been

It's not Forza against the highest either. In fact, aside from the curiosity of the entire thing, Forza Horizon being a blockbuster series is not something that needs a relative position to AC to being justified.

FH4 would be a smashing success even if AC sold more than it did.
 

Yurinka

Banned
Oct 30, 2017
1,457
Maybe he's counting Forza vs ACO Xbox SKUs only?

Because if not it's hard to believe that Forza is outselling such a multiplatform beast since AC games sell like 3 times more than the Forza games worldwide.
 

Theorry

Member
Oct 27, 2017
61,318
Did I say Forza Horizon don't disserve it success not all, it is by far the best racing game. And I consider it is incredible to grow sales for a racing franchise within current gen context. Forza sales are good but not as good as before. Gran Turismo sales are bad compared to franchise peak. Multiple racing games studio are now dead Evolution studios, Studio Liverpool, Codemasters is ok but lost money last year.

I think for exemple Forza Horizon 3 probably sold more than Gran Turismo Sport and I am curious to know where the ceiling for Forza Horizon sales are and I think the day Xbox console are more popular in continental Europe, we will have the answer.

How do you know? Yet we got this in the last NPD thread.