• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

0VERBYTE

Banned
Nov 1, 2017
5,555
Pretty sure her hair is brown or browner than red in the books.

I haven't even read all the books but I feel like some of y'all need to do a quick "book vs games" search before you criticize some of the Netflix decisions, considering they are explicitly not basing it on the games.
Well they should have based some of it on the games too. Literally millions of people was introduced to The Witcher from the game. Most of the fanfare came from the games not the books so you are going to get alot more of "thats not my triss" and "thats not yennefer" comments.
 

Foov

Member
Oct 25, 2017
44
I think he looks fine but the wig looks synthetic and not real. They should really spend the money on getting a better quality, real-hair wig.
 

Ferrio

Member
Oct 25, 2017
18,125
I can do without the beard, but he needs to be roughed up a bit. Needs the scar, don't go so heavy on the makeup.
 

feyder

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
1,156
That wig its a joke. There are even cosplay that looks better
328b8129763cf6304d795148db630abc.jpg

witcher-cosplay-kalendar5_vhs7.jpg
Good Lord I'd let him run me over
 

Pwnz

Member
Oct 28, 2017
14,279
Places
The biggest problem is the chin. If you cover that part, it's not horrible. I think it's just so different that the games that it's jarring.
 

Deleted member 25600

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 29, 2017
5,701

Wracu

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
2,396
It will look better on film.

But it is starting at a bad place. That wig is way too much volume and length for his face. I don't care about beard or no beard, but a beard would help that look immensely. Taken as is, that isn't even a good cosplay outfit.

Cavill circa immortals would be a better look all around.
 

broncobuster

Member
Oct 26, 2017
8,139
They'll get some feedback that's for sure

Seemed like a confident tease so maybe it's closer to final thing?

They can hopefully do better

Kinda feel they released it in time for Halloween. I don't think they're filming starting this week.

But yeah, they gotta change the wig. As much shit as certain people throw at this series, this is constructive criticism worth hearing.
 

Anton Sugar

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
3,946
Well they should have based some of it on the games too. Literally millions of people was introduced to The Witcher from the game. Most of the fanfare came from the games not the books so you are going to get alot more of "thats not my triss" and "thats not yennefer" comments.
Well...it's not. That doesn't mean they won't borrow anything from the games (in fact, I'm sure they will, because they know that's where the fanbase is coming from).
 

Einchy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
42,659
They'll get some feedback that's for sure

Seemed like a confident tease so maybe it's closer to final thing?

They can hopefully do better
Yeah, usually for these things they're confident that this is what they want so they show it off to the fans.
Like we had this one for Man of Steel back in 2013 or so.
EYXS8Py.jpg

And we recently had this one, which I wouldn't be surprised inspired the Geralt reveal.


They're supposed to start filming REALLY soon, so if they feel the feedback is way too negative, they'll have to very quickly change it. I'd say chances are that it stays the same.
 

Kinthey

Avenger
Oct 27, 2017
22,485

SArcher

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 26, 2017
2,669
With the risk of getting myself into hot water I want to address the posters who keep telling pro-beard people that "Geralt didn't have one in the books, read the books you gamer plebs". The showrunners are clearly not going for total accuracy with the adaptation if we consider who they have cast as Triss, Yennefer and Fringilla (yes, I'm here referring to the actresses' racial backgrounds). So I think it's perfectly fine for folks to go "Cavill would probably look more convincing with a beard/facial hair". That's all I'm saying.
 

Manu

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
17,191
Buenos Aires, Argentina
With the risk of getting myself into hot water I want to address the posters who keep telling pro-beard people that "Geralt didn't have one in the books, read the books you gamer plebs". The showrunners are clearly not going for total accuracy with the adaptation if we consider who they have cast as Triss, Yennefer and Fringilla (yes, I'm here referring to the actresses' racial backgrounds). So I think it's perfectly fine for folks to go "Cavill would probably look more convincing with a beard/facial hair". That's all I'm saying.
Geralt not having a beard is a part of his character and personality. Racial makeup isn't (at least not for those other characters.)
 
Nov 1, 2017
8,061
Pretty sure her hair is brown or browner than red in the books.

I haven't even read all the books but I feel like some of y'all need to do a quick "book vs games" search before you criticize some of the Netflix decisions, considering they are explicitly not basing it on the games.

I feel like you shouldn't believe people only played the game. I got all the books in English since they began releasing and their release schedule was slow as dirt.
 

Kurdel

Member
Nov 7, 2017
12,157
Too much of a pretty boy for the part.

But he does have raw man-sex charsima oozing out of every hairy hole in his body, looking forward to this!

tumblr_ozp8gdbZza1w0gw85o1_500.gif
 

Deleted member 4434

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
668
..........I really want him to have a beard.

I read some of the books (it's a long term on-going project lmao) and I don't recall whether he had a beard or not but I'm 100% OK if they derail from that part of the canon and give the man a beard.
And let him be played by Anson Mount because I can't unsee Superman.
 

Pwnz

Member
Oct 28, 2017
14,279
Places
Cavill is a big fan of the games and a gamer. Not absurdly unlikely he reads this. If you do, upgrade the wig, make up the facial hair to match your head, and get scars.

Why can't you people just be normal. Damn.
 

ebs

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
443
He needs to look way less tan. More pale, more gaunt, scarred. Don't even get how that looks remotely like a "mutant"
 

Crossing Eden

Member
Oct 26, 2017
53,571
Showrunners: We're adapting the books

Gamers: Sounds good it'll be just like the witcher 3

Showrunners: This is most definitely an adaptation of the book series

Gamers:Sounds good check out this photoshop of Henry Cavill as Witcher 3 Geralt

Showrunners: Here's the cast

Gamere: Hey, this doesn't look like the Witcher at all what gives?

Showrunners: Here's a makeup test

Gamers: D:< WHERE'S MUH BEARD
 

BossAttack

Member
Oct 27, 2017
43,183
Showrunners: We're adapting the books

Gamers: Sounds good it'll be just like the witcher 3

Showrunners: This is most definitely an adaptation of the book series

Gamers:Sounds good check out this photoshop of Henry Cavill as Witcher 3 Geralt

Showrunners: Here's the cast

Gamere: Hey, this doesn't look like the Witcher at all what gives?

Showrunners: Here's a makeup test

Gamers: D:< WHERE'S MUH BEARD

Pretty much.

Also, no one played The Witcher 1 or The Witcher 2. Heathens.

People, he's not starting out with a beard. He might grow one in Ryker style, but this is a "younger" Geralt, not famous, seasoned Geralt.
 

SArcher

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 26, 2017
2,669
Showrunners: We're adapting the books

Gamers: Sounds good it'll be just like the witcher 3

Showrunners: This is most definitely an adaptation of the book series

Gamers:Sounds good check out this photoshop of Henry Cavill as Witcher 3 Geralt

Showrunners: Here's the cast

Gamere: Hey, this doesn't look like the Witcher at all what gives?

Showrunners: Here's a makeup test

Gamers: D:< WHERE'S MUH BEARD

With the risk of getting myself into hot water I want to address the posters who keep telling pro-beard people that "Geralt didn't have one in the books, read the books you gamer plebs". The showrunners are clearly not going for total accuracy with the adaptation if we consider who they have cast as Triss, Yennefer and Fringilla (yes, I'm here referring to the actresses' racial backgrounds). So I think it's perfectly fine for folks to go "Cavill would probably look more convincing with a beard/facial hair". That's all I'm saying.
 
Nov 1, 2017
8,061
Pretty much.

Also, no one played The Witcher 1 or The Witcher 2. Heathens.

People, he's not starting out with a beard. He might grow one in Ryker style, but this is a "younger" Geralt, not famous, seasoned Geralt.

*Holds up his copy of Witcher and CE of The Witcher 2 for PC*

Even going by the books, of which I have this still looks pitiful. Beard or no beard.
 

Lunar Wolf

Banned
Nov 6, 2017
16,237
Los Angeles
Showrunners: We're adapting the books

Gamers: Sounds good it'll be just like the witcher 3

Showrunners: This is most definitely an adaptation of the book series

Gamers:Sounds good check out this photoshop of Henry Cavill as Witcher 3 Geralt

Showrunners: Here's the cast

Gamere: Hey, this doesn't look like the Witcher at all what gives?

Showrunners: Here's a makeup test

Gamers: D:< WHERE'S MUH BEARD

Thank you, lol.

A bunch of posters here are denser than rocks.
 
Oct 27, 2017
12,374
It's a bad wig. I really feel like he's got a good look for the role, yes he could with a beard, but I think the biggest thing is the hair just looks really unnatural.

The length isn't helping either, but something about the way it's cut for him makes it just look like somebody flopped a pair of drapes on his head.
 

PlanetSmasher

The Abominable Showman
Member
Oct 25, 2017
116,669
It's a bad wig. I really feel like he's got a good look for the role, yes he could with a beard, but I think the biggest thing is the hair just looks really unnatural.

The length isn't helping either, but something about the way it's cut for him makes it just look like somebody flopped a pair of drapes on his head.

Exactly. It's a bad wig. Get a shorter, thicker one that doesn't look quite as wiry and elf-ish and you're golden. It's just too long and too floppy for Geralt.
 

BossAttack

Member
Oct 27, 2017
43,183
*Holds up his copy of Witcher and CE of The Witcher 2 for PC*

Even going by the books, of which I have this still looks pitiful. Beard or no beard.

My only gripes are the hair and eyes. Both of which can be easily fixed. The hair looks cheap, but it's just a first costume test so I expect it to look better. And, he needs those yellow cat eye contacts. Make-up and lighting will make everything look fine.

These are the same posters that laughed and made a big stink regarding DC's Titans costume design, then lo' and behold when you see the final product with the proper lighting, color grading, and makeup it looks completely fine. The internet loves shitting on stuff.
 

SArcher

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 26, 2017
2,669
My only gripes are the hair and eyes. Both of which can be easily fixed. The hair looks cheap, but it's just a first costume test so I expect it to look better. And, he needs those yellow cat eye contacts. Make-up and lighting will make everything look fine.

These are the same posters that laughed and made a big stink regarding DC's Titans costume design, then lo' and behold when you see the final product with the proper lighting, color grading, and makeup it looks completely fine. The internet loves shitting on stuff.

Raven, Beast Boy and Starfire look like complete ass in the show.
 
Oct 26, 2017
3,896
Given the other liberties being taken with this adaptation giving Cavill Geralt a beard shouldn't be a dealbreaker. Cavill can definitely pull this off but they need to do something to make him look less like Superman wearing a Thranduil wig.