-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
-
We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
What game has the "best" NPC's ever?
- Thread starter Ghost of Jhoto
- Start date
Really wish they had just exported this NPC into GTAV, dude always cracked me up
"THEM WHITEBOYS HAD ME ON CRYSTAL METH"
every time lmao
The actual objectively right answer is the Trails series, it's basically this:
But across multiple games and even series.
But across multiple games and even series.
BotW. The attention to detail goes a long way to make up for the fact that very few have any real amount of depth or meaningful interaction with them. The unique names, appearances and even just a few lines for every single person in the game really helps to make them not feel like they're there to fill space, but actually live and belong in that world.
One of my biggest hopes is that BotW2 will make greater use of them and bring in that much needed depth and interaction with them to truly bring them alive.
One of my biggest hopes is that BotW2 will make greater use of them and bring in that much needed depth and interaction with them to truly bring them alive.
This is my first time seeing this, now i can't stop watching the series, lol
My only complaint was constantly having to rescue some of the same people over and over again.
I just, kinda, wish they would stay rescued, ya know?
Mushrooms aren't going to collect themselves, but yeah that ruin by the plateau was pretty egregious.
RDR2, GTAV, and GTAIV. Rockstar are the best at what they do and clearly other devs are playing catch-up.
But a shoutout has to go to Oblivion and Skyrim too since they felt more like characters with routines rather than just NPCs that re-spawn. The "radiant AI" wasn't as cool as they made it out to be, but it still made for much more interesting NPCs.
You have to think that programming good NPC/crowd behavior is really challenging, but considering Cyberpunk has been in development for so long and is targeting really high-end specs, the bad crowd AI is really weird.
But a shoutout has to go to Oblivion and Skyrim too since they felt more like characters with routines rather than just NPCs that re-spawn. The "radiant AI" wasn't as cool as they made it out to be, but it still made for much more interesting NPCs.
You have to think that programming good NPC/crowd behavior is really challenging, but considering Cyberpunk has been in development for so long and is targeting really high-end specs, the bad crowd AI is really weird.
The NPCs in Xenoblade Chronicles are so good I spend something like 20 hours just trying to solve all the little problems and squabbles in the first village, burning myself out on the game in the process😭
Lucy from Wolves in the Walls is the closest we've ever come to a true virtual character in a game that you can have a natural interaction with. Granted, it's entirely scripted linear sequences but the way they pull it off really makes you connect on a level unseen anywhere else.
Red Dead 2 also has great NPCs. If we combined Red Dead's AI with the level of connection and interaction you have with Lucy, we'd have something truly special.
Red Dead 2 also has great NPCs. If we combined Red Dead's AI with the level of connection and interaction you have with Lucy, we'd have something truly special.
Xenoblade X's NPCs are always updating what they have to say as you progress and through quests, you can develop the relationships between them and track those relationships via a huge interconnecting chart. It really makes the hub city feel alive which heightens the game's theme.
Stardew Valley, I guess?
I think it's really hard to pull of believable NPCs in big open world games.
I remember the first time playing The Witcher 1 and being quite impressed when villagers tried to hide when it rained. It's kinda ironic how bad the NPCs are in Cyberpunk.
I think it's really hard to pull of believable NPCs in big open world games.
I remember the first time playing The Witcher 1 and being quite impressed when villagers tried to hide when it rained. It's kinda ironic how bad the NPCs are in Cyberpunk.
Animal Crossing, all of the villagers is one of the main reasons why I love the series so much. I always feel excited to see who I'll get when somebody moves out or who will be my first villagers when first starting.
RDR2 has the best NPCs of any game I've ever played. Not only do none of them ruin the experience if you aren't paying attention, but If you pay attention you can literally watch an NPCs regular life.
I can't find it now but there's that farmer family near the the second camp that has a weekly routine that takes them across nearly the entire map even into regions that you can't travel into until end game. It's amazing. Search for the video of you can.
man the videos in this tread
I can't find it now but there's that farmer family near the the second camp that has a weekly routine that takes them across nearly the entire map even into regions that you can't travel into until end game. It's amazing. Search for the video of you can.
man the videos in this tread
Last edited:
I think Moon: Remix RPG had really good NPC interactions. Of course, the game is somewhat based around that, so the authored experiences were important. Earthbound had really good NPC dialogue too. Modern games? I'm not sure, I liked the way FF7R dealt with it in that you kind of just heard dialogue in passing, nothing really stopped you in your tracks if you didn't want it to.
Does modded Skyrim count? Handful of mods give the game the best NPC's and immersive conversations
RDR2. Besides stuff already mentioned in here one of the most impressive things is that every NPC looks unique (or the game does a masterful job at hiding clones) and like real persons full of life.
Not even to mention the amazing camp stuff, which is insane. Or how animals behave...
RDR2 is such an incredible achievement, hard to believe it exists.
Not even to mention the amazing camp stuff, which is insane. Or how animals behave...
RDR2 is such an incredible achievement, hard to believe it exists.
I really liked the NPCs in Legend of Mana on PS1. They were well drawn and had great dialogue. Many of them had their own quests like in Majora's Mask, but they also would come and fight along with you with their own unique moves.
Shenmue 1/2/3 and Deadly Premonition. All of them have individual NPCs that go about day/night schedules and have a ton of charm to them. My top pick would be Shenmue 1 because they all have so much dialogue throughout the game, and most of the fun when replaying the game is seeing what the different NPCs will say, I'm always discovering a funny/cool piece of new dialogue.
I remember in RDR2 I antagonized this one guy. Usually the NPCs get a little mad or just laugh it off when you insult them just once, but not this guy. The INSTANT I insult him he launches at me full force, instantly attacking with no warning. We fight and he won't back down so I wind up shooting him. Then on his body I find a letter from his wife saying she's leaving him because of his temper.
He didn't have a formal role in the game or a name or anything, just some random NPC. It was so crazy.
Last edited:
