• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

Captjohnboyd

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,569
I know those in the thread had been asking about Disability/SSI/Retired folks and wanted to copy and paste something I found on AARP.ORG

"
Social Security recipients eligible

AARP worked to ensure that individuals who are collecting Social Security benefits for retirement, disability or Supplemental Security Income will be eligible for the stimulus checks, based on their tax returns or Social Security Administration data. AARP successfully fought to guarantee that low-income Social Security recipients will receive the full $1,200 check, not $600 as originally proposed.


If you are receiving Social Security benefits but didn't file taxes in 2018 or 2019, you will be eligible to receive a stimulus check without a tax return based on data available to the IRS from your annual Social Security benefits statement. The government will send you a direct deposit or check using the information from your Form SSA-1099 Social Security Benefit Statement or your Form RRB-1099 Social Security Equivalent Benefit Statement. You will not have to file a 2019 tax return to get a stimulus check.


The bill does not set a date for when the direct deposits and checks will start to go out, saying only that the Treasury secretary will send the payments "as rapidly as possible." The money could be sent either by mail or direct deposit."

Link here: https://www.aarp.org/politics-society/advocacy/info-2020/coronavirus-stimulus-checks.html

Says you dont need to file anything special or anything and that the info Social Security already sends the IRS would suffice to get you the stimulus check.
That's absolutely wonderful news. My mother is retired and hadn't filed in a couple of years. I was worried she'd be left out
 

El Bombastico

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
36,110


twitter.com

😷 David Gura 🏡 on Twitter

“President Trump "has told people he wants his signature to appear on the direct payment checks," the @WSJ reports. "Normally, a civil servant—the disbursing officer for the payment center—would sign federal checks." https://t.co/X9dibJ474h”


Okay, so I after a cash in the check via phone app, I'll post a picture of myself burning the signature off the check.
 

Deleted member 12790

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
24,537
No. This is a new credit.


No. In fact, you may pay less taxes next year, depending on if you get the cash this year or not and if you're eligible or not.



You don't pay it back at all.

At least, not for now. Read your own link.

TKM posted a technical explanation and the language in the bill that supports not paying it back.

much appreciate yours and everyone else who is replying's help ITT.
 

Deleted member 12790

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
24,537
twitter.com

😷 David Gura 🏡 on Twitter

“President Trump "has told people he wants his signature to appear on the direct payment checks," the @WSJ reports. "Normally, a civil servant—the disbursing officer for the payment center—would sign federal checks." https://t.co/X9dibJ474h”

People should start calling trump the most "socialist president ever" -- literally putting his name on the "government handout" to lower income people -- just to watch republican brains short out and shoot sparks.
 

Beef Supreme

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,073
No. This is a new credit.


No. In fact, you may pay less taxes next year, depending on if you get the cash this year or not and if you're eligible or not.



You don't pay it back at all.

At least, not for now. Read your own link.

TKM posted a technical explanation and the language in the bill that supports not paying it back.

Oh OK. My mistake. I did read the article and it does say that you "may" have to pay some back if you make over 75k. But for all of those under 75k worrying about next year's return, then don't. It's free.
 

SilkySm00th

Member
Oct 31, 2017
4,827
Girl listened to advice I gave her when we first started dating and spammed it immediately.

Ridiculous ego boy and his garbo signature can take a leap but I'm happy this is signed and moving forward. The UI benefits are gonna help a few of my friends immensely
 

reKon

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,902
That's pretty much how it works....from Forbes

"The stimulus is an advance of a refundable tax credit on your 2020 taxes.


In other words, the bill created a refundable tax credit and the IRS is paying out the amount of that tax credit to eligible taxpayer now. Since the IRS does not have your 2020 tax year information, it will use a previous year's information to calculate the amount.


This is a tax credit so it is not considered taxable income for 2020.


If the IRS gives you too much of a stimulus check, you could be asked to pay back the difference but not until you file your return on April 15, 2021. You will not be assessed interest on the over-payment amount. If the IRS pays you too little, you'll get the difference added to your tax refund next year."

Link


So unless you make over $75000, there's pretty much nothing to worry about and this is essentially a free check.

Wow, I think is a major detail that a lot of people are missing out on who are in between that 75K to 99K range.

This WP article doesn't factor in an estimate for 2020 taxes: https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/business/coronavirus-stimulus-check-calculator/

From a tax planning perspective, this means that if you have the choice between a ROTH 401K and traditional 401K, contributing everything more towards the traditional 401K would potential prevent having to payback because your reported income would be lower by the amount contributed.
 

darkazcura

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,908
You don't pay it back unless you make over 75,000 in 2020. It will be a tax credit on your next return. It's a free check.

Details



It will be a credit on your next tax return. In other words, you will file your taxes as if this stimulus check never existed. The credit was created so the check is not taxable.

What I am saying is you don't have to pay anything back even if you end up making 100k in 2020. That is what the tax professionals are saying in this thread. See Pet's post above.
 

Daria

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,882
The Twilight Zone
Oh OK. My mistake. I did read the article and it does say that you "may" have to pay some back if you make over 75k. But for all of those under 75k worrying about next year's return, then don't. It's free.

It's a nontaxable check. Individuals whose income is up to $75,000 will receive a $1,200 check. The check amount starts to lower by $50--correct me if I'm wrong, somebody--for every $1,000 of income **OVER** $75,001.

Individuals who make over (possibly) $99,000 do not receive a check.

The income thresholds for families is different.
 

Pet

More helpful than the IRS
The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
7,070
SoCal
It does not take a penny from your return in 2020. The credit is established to make this check nonexistent as far as taxable income. In other words, let's say your yearly income was 50k and with this check it made it 51200. 2020's tax form will have an automatic credit of 1200 so that they;re only taxing the 50k you made to begin with. I know it's confusing. I had a tax lawyer explain it to me yesterday and it took me a little while to take everything in.
You need a new tax lawyer if that's really how they explained it to you.

This check IS the credit.

It's a refundable credit for 2020. However, because people need the money now, it's an advance of that refundable credit. You're getting a check, which is the method for how the credit is being paid out. It's the same thing.

Also, credits reduce your tax, not your taxable income. If your income is 100,000 and your tax is 20,000 (20% rate), a credit of 5,000 will reduce your tax to 15,000. A deduction reduces your taxable income. If your taxable income is 100,000 and you have an additional deduction of 5,000, your new taxable income is 95,000. Your tax will be 19,000.

Also, refundable credits are not counted as income.

Refunds can be taxable. But refundable credits, a specific portion of a refund, are not taxable. Most people that file taxes in the US that have taxable refunds, have taxable refunds due to the state income tax refund and receiving a benefit (which you get by itemizing).



Oh OK. My mistake. I did read the article and it does say that you "may" have to pay some back if you make over 75k. But for all of those under 75k worrying about next year's return, then don't. It's free.
The "may" is because it's entirely possible there could be new laws or bills or whatever that changes/modifies the CARES Act.

As of right now, no.


edit: I'm going to quote TKM because TKM did a far better job of explaining this than I did.

SEC. 6428. 2020 Recovery Rebates for individuals.



Emphasis mine. I believe this is the relevant section. The advance credit under subsection (f) is based on either 2018 or 2019 adjusted gross income. The 2020 credit is reduced by this amount but not below zero.

Scenario 1: So if based on 2019 income, I receive an advance credit of $1200 and come to find out my 2020 AGI is $99,000 then the math would be:

Eligible 2020 Recovery Rebate amount $0.00
Less subsection (f) credit (based on 2019) -1,200.00
Net 2020 Recovery Rebate: $0.00, cannot be below zero, no repayment

Scenario 2: My 2019 AGI is $85,000 and I receive a partial credit of $700 but my 2020 AGI is $75,000 when I finally file:

Eligible 2020 Recovery Rebate amount $1,200.00
Less subsection (f) credit (based on 2019) -700.00
Net 2020 Recovery Rebate: $500.00, I'd receive the additional $500 credit on my 2020 Form 1040.

Scenario 3: My 2019 AGI is $100,000 and I receive no advance credit but my 2020 AGI is $75,000 when I finally file:

Eligible 2020 Recovery Rebate amount $1,200.00
Less subsection (f) credit (based on 2019) $0.00
Net 2020 Recovery Rebate: $1200.00, I'd receive the full credit on my 2020 Form 1040.

edit: FYI, the Senate version text appears identical:

S.3548
 

reKon

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,902
That's pretty much how it works....from Forbes

"The stimulus is an advance of a refundable tax credit on your 2020 taxes.


In other words, the bill created a refundable tax credit and the IRS is paying out the amount of that tax credit to eligible taxpayer now. Since the IRS does not have your 2020 tax year information, it will use a previous year's information to calculate the amount.


This is a tax credit so it is not considered taxable income for 2020.


If the IRS gives you too much of a stimulus check, you could be asked to pay back the difference but not until you file your return on April 15, 2021. You will not be assessed interest on the over-payment amount. If the IRS pays you too little, you'll get the difference added to your tax refund next year."

Link


So unless you make over $75000, there's pretty much nothing to worry about and this is essentially a free check.

I take back what I said ... This contradicts what you've just explained above:

taxfoundation.org

Congress Approves Economic Relief Plan for Individuals and Businesses

On Friday afternoon, the Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security (CARES) Act passed the House of Representatives by a voice vote. The bill now moves to the President for signature.
 

greepoman

Member
Oct 26, 2017
1,976
Wow, I think is a major detail that a lot of people are missing out on who are in between that 75K to 99K range.

This WP article doesn't factor in an estimate for 2020 taxes: https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/business/coronavirus-stimulus-check-calculator/

From a tax planning perspective, this means that if you have the choice between a ROTH 401K and traditional 401K, contributing everything more towards the traditional 401K would potential prevent having to payback because your reported income would be lower by the amount contributed.
As people have mentioned there is supposedly a " no claw back" language in the bill but your advice works in reverse if you are over the threshold in 2019 and close to it in 2020 where you could contribute to bring your AGI below the threshold. It won't change what you get (or don't get initially) but you will get it when you file your 2020 taxes.
 
Oct 26, 2017
16,409
Mushroom Kingdom


twitter.com

😷 David Gura 🏡 on Twitter

“President Trump "has told people he wants his signature to appear on the direct payment checks," the @WSJ reports. "Normally, a civil servant—the disbursing officer for the payment center—would sign federal checks." https://t.co/X9dibJ474h”


There it is. Expected this


He's going to attempt to use this stimulus as a positive for himself, particularly for reelection.
Little does he know $1200 isn't going to do jack shit for people in the long run and the body count from the pandemic are going to be devastating.
 

Jarmel

The Jackrabbit Always Wins
Member
Oct 25, 2017
19,507
New York
So let me try this again. Congress created a new tax credit for this year for people making under $75,000 AGI (so after certain deductions from your paycheck like health policies). For a person making over $75,000, that $1200 credit decreases by $50 per $1000. So if you're making $95,000 then this tax credit doesn't apply to you.

The way they're handing out these checks is based on what you filed for 2019 or 2018 tax-wise. So if you filed for $50,000 in 2019 but you make $95,000 now, then you would get the full $1200 and not pay anything back or lose anything off your refund for 2020 taxes. For this tax credit specifically, you can't 'owe' the IRS anything. Now, if you made $95,000 last year and only $75,000 this year then you wouldn't receive a check at the present time but next year you would get $1200 added to your refund, or deducted from how much you owe.

Modify those numbers depending on if you are head of a household or filed jointly or have X number of brats running around.

That sound about right?
 

reKon

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,902
As people have mentioned there is supposedly a " no claw back" language in the bill but your advice works in reverse if you are over the threshold in 2019 and close to it in 2020 where you could contribute to bring your AGI below the threshold. It won't change what you get (or don't get initially) but you will get it when you file your 2020 taxes.

damn Forbes contributors...
 

Deleted member 12790

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
24,537
You need a new tax lawyer if that's really how they explained it to you.

This check IS the credit.

It's a refundable credit for 2020. However, because people need the money now, it's an advance of that refundable credit. You're getting a check, which is the method for how the credit is being paid out. It's the same thing.

Also, credits reduce your tax, not your taxable income. If your income is 100,000 and your tax is 20,000 (20% rate), a credit of 5,000 will reduce your tax to 15,000. A deduction reduces your taxable income. If your taxable income is 100,000 and you have an additional deduction of 5,000, your new taxable income is 95,000. Your tax will be 19,000.

Also, refundable credits are not counted as income.

Refunds can be taxable. But refundable credits, a specific portion of a refund, are not taxable. Most people that file taxes in the US that have taxable refunds, have taxable refunds due to the state income tax refund and receiving a benefit (which you get by itemizing).

Thank you so much for this post
 

Jarmel

The Jackrabbit Always Wins
Member
Oct 25, 2017
19,507
New York
In general, tax credits are way better than deductions because credits are per dollar to your tax bill and deductions are a percentage per dollar based on your income bracket.
 

Pet

More helpful than the IRS
The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
7,070
SoCal
The way they're handing out these checks is based on what you filed for 2019 or 2018 tax-wise. So if you filed for $50,000 in 2019 but you make $95,000 now, then you would get the full $1200 and not pay anything back or lose anything off your refund for 2020 taxes. For this tax credit specifically, you can't 'owe' the IRS anything. Now, if you made $95,000 last year and only $75,000 this year then you wouldn't receive a check at the present time but next year you would get $1200 added to your refund, or deducted from how much you owe.

Modify those numbers depending on if you are head of a household or filed jointly or have X number of brats running around.

That sound about right?
You nailed it except for the cutoff.

The language states the credit is reduced by 5% if your AGI exceeds $75,000.
1,200 / 0.05 = 24,000.
24,000+75,000 = 99,000.

So, the total phaseout should be 99,000 for single people, not considering kids and stuff.

H.R.748 § 6428


"(c) Limitation Based On Adjusted Gross Income.—The amount of the credit allowed by subsection (a) (determined without regard to this subsection and subsection (e)) shall be reduced (but not below zero) by 5 percent of so much of the taxpayer's adjusted gross income as exceeds—


"(1) $150,000 in the case of a joint return,


"(2) $112,500 in the case of a head of household, and


"(3) $75,000 in the case of a taxpayer not described in paragraph (1) or (2).




damn Forbes contributors...

I mean, they're not totally wrong. It is entirely possible that something will change between today and the 2020 filing season.

But as the language is.... nope.
 

CHUNKYBOWSER

Member
Nov 13, 2017
103
Osaka, Japan
Sure. But those of us that file are tax exempt up to a certain amount, so I'm wondering whether that has any bearing on eligibility.
I'm in the same situation. As far as I can tell, even if our income is exempt, we still "filed" our taxes, so we should be eligible for the check. The one problem I see is whether or not they'll mail the check to our overseas address.
 

Woody

Member
Mar 5, 2018
2,069
I'm in the same situation. As far as I can tell, even if our income is exempt, we still "filed" our taxes, so we should be eligible for the check. The one problem I see is whether or not they'll mail the check to our overseas address.

I kind of doubt that, but who knows. I'd rather have someone in the States deposit it for me.
 

dragoncdf

Banned
Oct 29, 2017
18
I'm confused. I entered the workforce in January of this year. Which means no tax return for 2018 or 19. Does that mean no check?
 

Pet

More helpful than the IRS
The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
7,070
SoCal
I'm confused. I entered the workforce in January of this year. Which means no tax return for 2018 or 19. Does that mean no check?

You might get a check next year when you file your 2020 taxes, provided that you do nothing now and you qualify.

People claiming dependents don't get any extra money. Only people claiming the child credit (which is different) get extra money.

To add onto this- people who are claimed as dependents don't get money either because dependents exemptions are a deduction under IRC §151(c).

FROM CARES ACT:

"(d) Eligible Individual.—For purposes of this section, the term 'eligible individual' means any individual other than—
"(2) any individual with respect to whom a deduction under section 151 is allowable to another taxpayer for a taxable year beginning in the calendar year in which the individual's taxable year begins, and
 

devSin

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,199
I'm confused. I entered the workforce in January of this year. Which means no tax return for 2018 or 19. Does that mean no check?
People who don't file and don't receive assistance (disability or retirement or SSI) just have to wait for guidance.

You may be able to file a return for 2019 if you really want your money now, but they're supposed to have a solution eventually for people who qualify but for who they don't have financial information (like the homeless or indigent).
 

Witness

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
9,879
New York
I know those in the thread had been asking about Disability/SSI/Retired folks and wanted to copy and paste something I found on AARP.ORG

"
Social Security recipients eligible

AARP worked to ensure that individuals who are collecting Social Security benefits for retirement, disability or Supplemental Security Income will be eligible for the stimulus checks, based on their tax returns or Social Security Administration data. AARP successfully fought to guarantee that low-income Social Security recipients will receive the full $1,200 check, not $600 as originally proposed.


If you are receiving Social Security benefits but didn't file taxes in 2018 or 2019, you will be eligible to receive a stimulus check without a tax return based on data available to the IRS from your annual Social Security benefits statement. The government will send you a direct deposit or check using the information from your Form SSA-1099 Social Security Benefit Statement or your Form RRB-1099 Social Security Equivalent Benefit Statement. You will not have to file a 2019 tax return to get a stimulus check.


The bill does not set a date for when the direct deposits and checks will start to go out, saying only that the Treasury secretary will send the payments "as rapidly as possible." The money could be sent either by mail or direct deposit."

Link here: https://www.aarp.org/politics-society/advocacy/info-2020/coronavirus-stimulus-checks.html

Says you dont need to file anything special or anything and that the info Social Security already sends the IRS would suffice to get you the stimulus check.

Thank you, my mom will be thrilled.
 

FeistyBoots

Member
Oct 27, 2017
3,506
Southern California
Probably answered, can't comb through the thread though - for the unemployment expansion and +600 weekly payments, *must* you have *become* unemployed due to the pandemic?

I was already on unemployment, which was paused when I went on SDI in February and was reopened today, with me being able to start receiving benefits again in 2 weeks.

As I'm currently homeless, knowing the answer to this is really important. Thanks in advance.
 

Marnie

The Fallen
Dec 3, 2018
794
Probably answered, can't comb through the thread though - for the unemployment expansion and +600 weekly payments, *must* you have *become* unemployed due to the pandemic?

I was already on unemployment, which was paused when I went on SDI in February and was reopened today, with me being able to start receiving benefits again in 2 weeks.

As I'm currently homeless, knowing the answer to this is really important. Thanks in advance.

Per the FAQs on the NYT website:


"I'm already receiving unemployment benefits. Will I receive any help?

Yes. Even if you're already receiving unemployment benefits for reasons unrelated to the coronavirus, your state-level benefits will still be extended by 13 weeks. You will also receive the extra $600 weekly benefit from the federal government."

So it does appear that you should receive it, and I hope you do.
 

FeistyBoots

Member
Oct 27, 2017
3,506
Southern California
Per the FAQs on the NYT website:


"I'm already receiving unemployment benefits. Will I receive any help?

Yes. Even if you're already receiving unemployment benefits for reasons unrelated to the coronavirus, your state-level benefits will still be extended by 13 weeks. You will also receive the extra $600 weekly benefit from the federal government."

So it does appear that you should receive it, and I hope you do.

Thank you!
 

Infcabbage

Member
Oct 28, 2017
1,578
Portland, Oregon
I know those in the thread had been asking about Disability/SSI/Retired folks and wanted to copy and paste something I found on AARP.ORG

"
Social Security recipients eligible

AARP worked to ensure that individuals who are collecting Social Security benefits for retirement, disability or Supplemental Security Income will be eligible for the stimulus checks, based on their tax returns or Social Security Administration data. AARP successfully fought to guarantee that low-income Social Security recipients will receive the full $1,200 check, not $600 as originally proposed.


If you are receiving Social Security benefits but didn't file taxes in 2018 or 2019, you will be eligible to receive a stimulus check without a tax return based on data available to the IRS from your annual Social Security benefits statement. The government will send you a direct deposit or check using the information from your Form SSA-1099 Social Security Benefit Statement or your Form RRB-1099 Social Security Equivalent Benefit Statement. You will not have to file a 2019 tax return to get a stimulus check.


The bill does not set a date for when the direct deposits and checks will start to go out, saying only that the Treasury secretary will send the payments "as rapidly as possible." The money could be sent either by mail or direct deposit."

Link here: https://www.aarp.org/politics-society/advocacy/info-2020/coronavirus-stimulus-checks.html

Says you dont need to file anything special or anything and that the info Social Security already sends the IRS would suffice to get you the stimulus check.
Thank you so much for this.
 

dark494

Avenger
Oct 29, 2017
4,602
Seattle
Per the FAQs on the NYT website:


"I'm already receiving unemployment benefits. Will I receive any help?

Yes. Even if you're already receiving unemployment benefits for reasons unrelated to the coronavirus, your state-level benefits will still be extended by 13 weeks. You will also receive the extra $600 weekly benefit from the federal government."

So it does appear that you should receive it, and I hope you do.
But what about long-term unemployed people who fell out of unemployment benefits before this, are they SOL?