I hate protecting stuff in games. Do you?

[daninthemix]

For some reason I just recently played Crackdown 2 for the first time, and was baffled as to why they'd taken a perfectly mindless (but brilliant) game about jumping, shooting and blowing things up, and made all the missions about protecting stuff instead.

And I realised I just always hate this - having to protect any character or object (be it a car, Mcguffin or whatever) that isn't the player character. It's a bit of a vicious circle actually - because I hate these mission types more, I'm more likely to fail at them, and therefore be stuck in a re-attempt loop of a type of gameplay I despise.

I get the general sense that escort missions are widely reviled, but what about when the person/object you're protecting is stationary?

How do you feel about protection missions in general, and do you have any noteworthy examples that are either especially bad or good?

 

[Deleted member 54320]

Honestly it depends. If its a character or thing that I actually care about then, I'm kinda okay with it?

Most of the time though, it's annoying.

 

[Tambini]

You didn't like Tomb raider?

 

[Deleted member 32374]

Fighting off enemies trying to kill you and a helpless, defenseless and unarmored escort is F.U.N.

Fucking
Unbelievable
Non sense

RE4 is famous for how awful these where.

Now, beyond escort missions, I'm not opposed to defending various stationary points. Many games are specifically designed for this and do it well.

 

[Deleted member 15428]

To be honest I'm tired of killing stuff in games. Now that I think of it, it's somewhat disturbing

 

[TheBaldwin]

Fighting off enemies trying to kill you and a helpless, defenseless and unarmored escort is F.U.N.

Fucking
Unbelievable
Non sense

RE4 is famous for how awful these where.

Now, beyond escort missions, I'm not opposed to defending various stationary points. Many games are specifically designed for this and do it well.

Click to shrink...

I can't link the video, but Ashley is probably the best example of an escort mission done well. You just tell her what to do and she fucking does it.

But destiny's whole game design off 'wait in this area to kill enemies in a circle until done' is tedious

 

[ThisThingIsUseful]

God of War 2 had one where you had to protect the translator.

On Titan Mode, it took off a few years of my life.

Fighting off enemies trying to kill you and a helpless, defenseless and unarmored escort is F.U.N.

Fucking
Unbelievable
Non sense

RE4 is famous for how awful these where.

Now, beyond escort missions, I'm not opposed to defending various stationary points. Many games are specifically designed for this and do it well.

Click to shrink...

I thought the U was for uranium bomb.

 

[Nec]

I like tower defenses.

 

[Billfisto]

Oh, I absolutely loathe protecting things. Especially if it's a longer mission and they do something absolutely BS like having a bunch of rocket launcher guys come out all at once at the end of the mission or something.

If I absolutely need to defend something (for storyline purposes or whatever), at least make it like Destiny 1, where it's more of a "hold this point" mechanic, rather than giving the item its own health pool.

 

[Khrno]

I agree OP. I'm very good at attacking, but quite shitty at defending on FIFA.

 

[Deleted member 984]

Natalya in Goldeneye started that dislike for me.

 

[DJ_Lae]

They're pretty much always bad, as you introduce an element of (poor) AI into your gameplay and all the frustration that comes with it.

My most memorable escort mission is probably still from WoW - Marshall Windsor, who would charge forward, seemingly at random, and aggro every enemy before you could.

 

[Dukie85]

As long as it's not Ashley, I don't care.

 

[StarPhlox]

I generally think that, but then one of my favorite games this year is A Plague Tale: Innocence where most of what you do is protect your little brother. The game is a long escort mission (with some variety peppered in, to be sure) and it is more powerful because of it.

 

[Albatross]

The worst, stationary or not.
I recently played Just Cause 3 and it felt like 70% of the story missions involved defending someone or something.

 

[Cat Party]

You didn't like Tomb raider?

Click to shrink...

lol

 

[Oneself]

It's generally atrocious and I hate it too. Especially the cheap, time filling parts where "you shoot at them while I fix some shit as slowly as possible". This is, 99% of the time, just plain bad game design, worse than escort missions IMO.
Just when that asshole NPC starts fixing something or unlocking a door for 5 minutes, waves and waves of enemies obviously arrive... Thank God there were ammo crates in that room for no reason too!

 

[Cathcart]

Well I usually play support or healer, so...


yes.

 

[kalgore]

Natalya in Goldeneye started that dislike for me.

Click to shrink...

100% this.

The final mission/encounter in Bioshock Infinite also.

 

[mbpm]

As long as it's not Ashley, I don't care.

Click to shrink...

LEOOOOOON

 

[BeaconofTruth]

Nah, I love Resident Evil 4. When done right it's a satisfying gameplay challenge. A lot of times they are done poorly. Like most things it's about execution, not the concept itself.

 

[Billfisto]

It's generally atrocious and I hate it too. Especially the cheap, time filling parts where "you shoot at them while I fix some shit as slowly as possible". This is, 99% of the time, just plain bad game design, worse than escort missions IMO.
Just when that asshole NPC starts fixing something or unlocking a door for 5 minutes, waves and waves of enemies obviously arrive... Thank God there were ammo crates in that room for no reason too!

Click to shrink...

I love it when the "hacking" or whatever is clearly tied to the number of enemies you've killed and not the actual time that's elapsed, too.

You shoot that last guy and coincidentally they're all "And... we're in!"

 

[Deleted member 2752]

But what about the ancients? They need defending

 

[Deleted member 5148]

To be honest I'm tired of killing stuff in games. Now that I think of it, it's somewhat disturbing

Click to shrink...

I should try this for a year...what games are you looking forward to play?

and now back on topic, I generally don't mind unless is a game where the a.i is really random and I have to restart the mission, over and over. First game that comes to mind is any rockstar game, red dead redemption or gta.

 

[Deleted member 15428]

I should try this for a year...what games are you looking forward to play?

and now back on topic, I generally don't mind unless is a game where the a.i is really random and I have to restart the mission, over and over. First game that comes to mind is any rockstar game, red dead redemption or gta.

Click to shrink...

Cyberpunk 2077, Judgment, FF VII Remake, Super Mario Maker 2, Control and Death Stranding. And maybe Modern Warfare. At least some of them don't rely on realistic killing

 

[justiceiro]

I recently played through the section of Zelda to where you have to protect the chariot and man, did I wished to stop playing in the spot.

Blast corps was hard, but fun though.