• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Proteus

Member
Oct 25, 2017
7,981
Toronto
It's an inferiority complex masked in claims of superiority. They are always going to be seen as secondary to Earthers despite how hard they work to grow their planet.
 

Lonestar

Roll Tahd, Pawl
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
3,558
Going by Ty Franck*, co-writer of the books and a writer on the Show, the Amazon order of episodes will be 10, down from the 13 we've been getting.

But assume that the episodes themselves will be longer than the current commercial filled episodes.

*From the most recent "The Churn" podcast.
 

Moff

Member
Oct 26, 2017
4,781
Didn't like this episode at all, lots of silly stuff, especially the Drummer/Ashford situation.
 

Almagest

Member
Oct 28, 2017
1,447
Spain
Going by Ty Franck*, co-writer of the books and a writer on the Show, the Amazon order of episodes will be 10, down from the 13 we've been getting.

But assume that the episodes themselves will be longer than the current commercial filled episodes.

*From the most recent "The Churn" podcast.
If we get one-hour episodes we'll end up with an even longer season, I think, so that's all right.
 

Zoe

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,237
I wonder if Drummer would have made the same call as Ashford to bring on everybody's wounded.
 

Lonestar

Roll Tahd, Pawl
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
3,558
I wonder if Drummer would have made the same call as Ashford to bring on everybody's wounded.
Feels like she would. She got to the point of recognizing that while they were stuck there, the rest of the ship was leaderless and in chaos. Knowing she was already injured (probably moreso than Ashford), she took on a much more serious injury to free up the 2nd in command for the good of the ship.

That much altruism tells me she'd recognize the need for spinning up the drum, and she'd recognize that everyone else in the bubble would need it as well.

There's also the possibility of Ashford (and theoretically Drummer), deciding to invite everyone else to the Behemoth, before Mars/Earth decided to invade and take over the Behemoth for themselves.

In this situation, Gravity is as important a resource, as water and food are.




Sneak Peak
But, it's a gigantic doozy of one, like, it's surprising they'd talk about this here.
 
Last edited:

Razgriz417

Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,107
<3 Drummer. Knowing that Bobby wasn't with the drop ship in the book to get Holden makes me wonder how all of that played out. Did they still have the same back and forth about executing him?
 

Kirblar

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
30,744
Going by Ty Franck*, co-writer of the books and a writer on the Show, the Amazon order of episodes will be 10, down from the 13 we've been getting.

But assume that the episodes themselves will be longer than the current commercial filled episodes.

*From the most recent "The Churn" podcast.
This seems like a good change for pacing's sake.
 

Almagest

Member
Oct 28, 2017
1,447
Spain
<3 Drummer. Knowing that Bobby wasn't with the drop ship in the book to get Holden makes me wonder how all of that played out. Did they still have the same back and forth about executing him?
I don't think so, they were going straight for the kill. Also, I'm pretty sure they didn't take Holden with them either.
Edit- Will keep book talk in tags.
 
Last edited:

Killthee

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,169
Going by Ty Franck*, co-writer of the books and a writer on the Show, the Amazon order of episodes will be 10, down from the 13 we've been getting.

But assume that the episodes themselves will be longer than the current commercial filled episodes.

*From the most recent "The Churn" podcast.
Did Amazon get the international rights then? Cause if Space still has the Canadian rights they'll likely stick to the 43 minute runtime so Space can run their ads just like CBS does with Star Trek Discovery cause Space has the Canadian rights for it.
 
Last edited:

Lonestar

Roll Tahd, Pawl
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
3,558
Did Amazon get the international rights then? Cause if Space still has the Canadian rights they'll likely stick to the 43 minute runtime so Space can run their ads just like CBS does with Star Trek Discovery cause Space has the Canadian rights for it.
Don't know if anything has been announced for international airing.

I don't think so, they were going straight for the kill. Also, I'm pretty sure they didn't take Holden with them either.
<3 Drummer. Knowing that Bobby wasn't with the drop ship in the book to get Holden makes me wonder how all of that played out. Did they still have the same back and forth about executing him?

Try to keep book talk behind spoiler bars, please.

I don't think Holden was catatonic for very long after "touching" the system. Sure, they tried to kill him right off the bat, but once mechanized walking things came out, and their grenade tossing LT got dematerialized, they were ok with just "noping" the hell out of there with Holden. But they pretty much treated him coldly on the way back to the other ships.
 

Einchy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
42,659
Aight, Ashford is cool in my book now. I mean, I liked the character a lot, but he seemed like an asshole that was just going to be trouble for Drummer but he seems like a good trying to do what's best for everyone, even Inners, in this episode.
 

Jackpot

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
1,827
I'm glad they changed Ashford. One of the books' worst failings is how absurdly evil for evil's sake some of the characters are.
 
Oct 26, 2017
6,261
Also on board the Ashford liking - although still dubious. We'll see.
Really fond of how the show focuses on the effects of gravity and its absence on things like blood. This episode was great for it.

I'm glad they changed Ashford. One of the books' worst failings is how absurdly evil for evil's sake some of the characters are.

9869.jpg


(couldnae resist sorry)
 

harry the spy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,078
I thought it was abundantly clear that he was an antagonist. It's just now, we don't know if he is anymore. Not a book reader, btw.
He is only set up at once initially, since he is in opposition to Drummer, and Drummer is depicted as sympathetic. But besides being a bit of an arrogant jerkass, he has done nothing to actually make him an antagonist from the plot's point of view. In fact besides not respecting Drummer's rule he is depicted as making more sense than Drummer. So no, he is not clearly an antagonist.
And by commenting on him being a cartoon villain, we now know that in the books at least he is likely an antagonist from the plot's point of view. Unless they change that in the TV show, it's a spoiler, and it has nothing to do in this thread.
 

Deleted member 22490

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 28, 2017
9,237
He is only set up at once initially, since he is in opposition to Drummer, and Drummer is depicted as sympathetic. But besides being a bit of an arrogant jerkass, he has done nothing to actually make him an antagonist from the plot's point of view. In fact besides not respecting Drummer's rule he is depicted as making more sense than Drummer. So no, he is not clearly an antagonist.
And by commenting on him being a cartoon villain, we now know that in the books at least he is likely an antagonist from the plot's point of view. Unless they change that in the TV show, it's a spoiler, and it has nothing to do in this thread.
In the plot's view, he is the antagonist to our protagonist which was Naomi and Drummer and now just Drummer. Doesn't matter if he is right sometimes or gives sound advice, he was positioned against Drummer. We were certainly not supposed to trust him when he was introduced. But after this last episode, things may change.
 

Zelas

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
6,020
Anna doesnt know about zero g wounds yet can handle a MMU? They must have designed that thing with some really intuitive controls lol.

I thought it was abundantly clear that he was an antagonist. It's just now, we don't know if he is anymore. Not a book reader, btw.
As a TV only viewer I definitely didnt view him as a straight up antagonist. He's even less of one now. Regardless that book comparison should have been behind tags. Any book talk really.
 

kurahador

Member
Oct 28, 2017
17,533
Really didn't expect Anna of all people to save Naomi.

Hope we get to see juiced up Melba vs Amos in the finale.
 

principal

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Feb 14, 2018
1,279
guys need some quick mafs

was it possible for her to go from one ship to another in the suit? how close were the other ships?

speed was about 100kph
 

Crispy75

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,054
The position of all the ships, including the Roci, was on the big screen on the Nathan Hale. Didn't see how close, but that info is there...
 

darkwing

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,949
do they need gravity for medical reasons? I'm guessing it would be a killer for those who are bleeding especially internally
 

Lonestar

Roll Tahd, Pawl
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
3,558
do they need gravity for medical reasons? I'm guessing it would be a killer for those who are bleeding especially internally
Yeah, they said as much in this most recent episode. Hard to heal in Zero-G, but the Spinning Drum creates a little bit of gravity (1/3rd of normal), so bringing injured people to the Behemoth to heal is the right thing to do.
 

darkwing

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,949
woah, love the science detail on the show then, tempted to read the books, is it the same grounded science wise?
 

SpartyCrunch

Xbox
Verified
Oct 25, 2017
2,497
Seattle, WA
Man this season is killing it. I love the attention to detail, and even the quieter moments on the Behemoth were so good!

Can someone remind me what the previous "speed limit" was inside the ring, and what it changed to? I may have mis-read but I thought the change was so huge that it would squish even people who were buckled in.
 

Lonestar

Roll Tahd, Pawl
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
3,558
Man this season is killing it. I love the attention to detail, and even the quieter moments on the Behemoth were so good!

Can someone remind me what the previous "speed limit" was inside the ring, and what it changed to? I may have mis-read but I thought the change was so huge that it would squish even people who were buckled in.
From memory, I think the original speed limit was something like 18,000 (but I'm not sure if that's in meters per second or miles per hour), but now it's something like 28 meters per second. Which, according to google conversion, is 62 mph. Goddam that's slow.

Which, if it'll take 7 months to get back to the ring, means that the distance from the station orbit they're at, to the ring, is about 300,000 miles (7 months=210ish days=5040 hours x 62 miles per hour.) That's inside the distance between the earth and the moon.

If it was the original speed limit was 18,000 meters a second, that same 300k distance would take something like 7 hours.
 

Irminsul

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,034
From memory, I think the original speed limit was something like 18,000 (but I'm not sure if that's in meters per second or miles per hour), but now it's something like 28 meters per second. Which, according to google conversion, is 62 mph. Goddam that's slow.
Neither, it was 18,000 km/h, which is 5,000 m/s. Meaning a deceleration at devastating, but survivable 15 g (or 147.15 m/s²) should've taken 33.79 seconds. I don't now, though, if anyone was actually going at the speed limit at that time.

If we calculate the other way, saying 28 m/s is the new speed limit and everyone was decelrated at the same 15 g for 2 seconds, the max speed of any vessel with survivors should be ~ 320 m/s or 1160 km/h (721 mph).

Oh yeah, and everyone at speed limit was decelerated at 253.5 g. That doesn't sound too healthy.

Just as an aside, I don't think silly Imperial units are used a lot in the Expanse (but I might remember that wrong) ;)
 

Lonestar

Roll Tahd, Pawl
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
3,558
oh, I'm sure Imperial's probably not involved, but I and plenty other people are mentally stuck on it. I can't tell you how "fast" 100 km/h is, but I can "feel" how fast 70 mph is. Amurica.

I do know, as a message in the book, the deceleration occurred over a time period of 5 seconds.

I was also thinking of how fast the bullets would need to be going, to be stopped. But also thinking, they were fired before the grenade, which is what caused the slowdown. So those bullets would have only been going 18000 kmh. Which, I think, is faster than Bullets on earth go anyway. Basically, it feels kind of like an error. The fastest bullet seems to go about 4,000 feet per second, which is 4300 km/h, about 1/4th of the original speed limit.

But then, it was Martian bullets, and maybe they go really fast.
 

Irminsul

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,034
Ah, 5 seconds, that looked much more instantaneous in the series. I thought I was being generous with 2 seconds.

With that amount of time, everyone should've gone at 764 m/s / 2750 km/h / 1708 mph before to be decelerated at 15 g. I now remember that they said they were going at 33% below the old speed limit, which would mean they were decelerated at 68 g. Which still isn't really survivable. Well, anyway, you've got a good point with the bullets. They must've gone really fast.
 

Deleted member 22490

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 28, 2017
9,237
Anna doesnt know about zero g wounds yet can handle a MMU? They must have designed that thing with some really intuitive controls lol.


As a TV only viewer I definitely didnt view him as a straight up antagonist. He's even less of one now. Regardless that book comparison should have been behind tags. Any book talk really.

He was clearly an antagonist. Naomi's and Drummer's reaction to him cements that. Now was he a villain? Not as he was depicted in the show.

I didn't catch/understand who that was near the end of the episode that saved Naomi from mech-suit Clarissa.
It was Ana with some electroshock therapy
 

Lonestar

Roll Tahd, Pawl
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
3,558
Ah, 5 seconds, that looked much more instantaneous in the series. I thought I was being generous with 2 seconds.

With that amount of time, everyone should've gone at 764 m/s / 2750 km/h / 1708 mph before to be decelerated at 15 g. I now remember that they said they were going at 33% below the old speed limit, which would mean they were decelerated at 68 g. Which still isn't really survivable. Well, anyway, you've got a good point with the bullets. They must've gone really fast.
The thing is, the bullets got caught before the new speed limit, and the old speed limit is 3-4 times faster than the earth's current fastest bullet. Holden should have still been shot.

Only thing I'm not really sure on, is if you get stuck going "too fast", does the limit bring you down to a "stop" and then pull you in at an even slower speed than the limit. Then maybe that could explain why Holden didn't get perforated.
 

Irminsul

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,034
The thing is, the bullets got caught before the new speed limit, and the old speed limit is 3-4 times faster than the earth's current fastest bullet. Holden should have still been shot.

Only thing I'm not really sure on, is if you get stuck going "too fast", does the limit bring you down to a "stop" and then pull you in at an even slower speed than the limit. Then maybe that could explain why Holden didn't get perforated.
Ah yes, you're right. But I think the second paragraph is the answer, because the slingshotter went through the ring rather slowly. If he would have went through at 18,000 km/h, you wouldn't have seen it going through.
 

Einchy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
42,659
The whole healing thing at zero G blew my mind, I never realized that was a thing.

Also, deceleration causing a huge catastrophe is another really cool event that would never be possible in another pieces of media. They always find really interesting story developments that revolve around the science.
 

Deleted member 22490

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 28, 2017
9,237
The whole healing thing at zero G blew my mind, I never realized that was a thing.

Also, deceleration causing a huge catastrophe is another really cool event that would never be possible in another pieces of media. They always find really interesting story developments that revolve around the science.
It can also be hard to get an erection too
 

Lonestar

Roll Tahd, Pawl
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
3,558
Holden got that Earther dong.
Makes me think, maybe Holden (back in Episode 1) had timed the "rendezvous" to take place during the flip portion of the Canterbury trip (the halfway point where the ship goes from accelerating towards the location, and flipping to decelerate to the location, meaning a small moment of Zero G time). Just to get in some Zero-G action.


Ah! I totally didn't catch that! Couldn't tell it was her, and had no idea she could've/would've chased her down.
I kind of think it ties into her arc, of not just being a pastor (a role that's basically there to help/care for people), but also tie into whatever form of guilt she has for that officer who killed himself (and maybe for past issues, like her protest work in the past with the UN AG). Maybe she feels like she has the duty to try and get to Melba, to bring her back from the abyss.
 

Chiaroscuro

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,688
Episode was really great, the display of the havoc of the sudden stop plus the lack of gravity.

But I am not really a fan the way they portrait the Hub Station. I don't know, feel cheap.
 

Nooblet

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,624
Episode was really great, the display of the havoc of the sudden stop plus the lack of gravity.

But I am not really a fan the way they portrait the Hub Station. I don't know, feel cheap.
Episode was really great, the display of the havoc of the sudden stop plus the lack of gravity.

But I am not really a fan the way they portrait the Hub Station. I don't know, feel cheap.
Yep I feel the same, it kind of feels tiny and low budget unlike post protomolecule Eros station. Infact I feel the same for the entire slow zone. The light blue glow just looks cheap, in the books it's a completely black starless void.

I think they wanted to differentiate it a bit from normal space and hence the blue edges, but they could have used a higher budget. Ah well atleast they'll have that next season with Amazon.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.