Hunter x Hunter - Yorknew City Arc (1999 2002 Edition)
I burned through all of this faster than I expected. Damn. Quality was just oozing from every crevice throughout this arc. This arc was a perfect match with the vision and tone that Kazuhiro Furuhashi was striving for. I'm a little surprised that Furuhashi was capable of putting out something this good as I'm more familiar with his work on Gundam Unicorn. Going through his background I see now that he was the Rurouni Kenshin director so I guess at one point he really was good. Everything for the most part seems to be clicking in this arc and results in the best adaptation of the material I've seen and judging of what I've read of the manga in relation to this arc, the best version overall.
The most immediate and striking change early on was the creation of a new OP that stands in sharp contrast to the first OP. The first OP contains tons of
bright colors, a cheery pop song, characters smiling and bouncing around. The second OP starts with a picture of an
eclipse(of sorts), an extremely dark color palette, a rock song, and the characters generally posing and looking serious. If that doesn't tell you that the happy times are over, I'm not sure what else they need to do. I should note though that the arc does have
some comedy in it and isn't just constantly 'dead serious' all the time.
I'm not really going to talk much about the overall writing as Yorknew's arc is regarded highly enough by almost everybody so that would be a waste. What I will talk about briefly are some of the minor changes that help with characterization. One of these would be in the immediate aftermath of when Kurapika kills Uvogin. The show visually emphasizes Kurapika's emotional turmoil at the gravity of his actions as he looks
thinner and
downcast. Changes like that give additional depth to Kurapika's revenge quest and later when Gon/Killua are going along with the hostage situation to avoid Kurapika having to kill again.
Another two changes/tweaks that I was impressed by were in the final episode of the OVA. The first one is when the hostage exchange is occurring, Kurapika runs to meet Gon/Killua. Melody thinks Kurapika has lost control again and is going to try and kill Chrollo but he looks back and his eyes are normal again, signifying that he's happy to see his friends. That was a really powerful moment that isn't in the manga as Kurapika had been on the edge of losing emotional control for multiple episodes and seeing that his friends were safe again was enough to completely calm him down. Another is when Pakunoda runs into the cat in the alleyway and plays with it a bit before it rejoins its friends. It works on two levels. The first is the obvious symbolism of the cat pack representing the Phantom Troupe and the second is that it shows a softer side of Pakunoda right before she commits suicide for her friends. Small alterations but they have big emotional impacts.
The background and art direction, as always, was outstanding. Nobuto Sakamoto did a
great job and Shigeru Morimoto was able to
fill in well enough for the OVAs. What makes this so impressive is how well Sakamoto was able to handle
the urban environment as that's where a lot of shows falter. Part of this is due to the medium as this was pre-digital and done on cels so there is a grittiness inherent to the art but also the quality of the art team in capturing the beauty of a modern city.
One visual element that felt occasionally forced was the reflection off of a character's eyes. Yes that was a visual trademark for the TV series, so much so that I noticed how much the OVAs were lacking it, but at times it was a bit too much and distracting. That was less of a problem with Heaven's Arena as the tone of the arc wasn't so serious. The more grounded character designs
really worked beautifully in conjunction with the darker art direction and grave material. From an animation standpoint, it didn't feel as flashy as previous arcs. The obvious standout was the
Kurapika/Uvogin duel by Akira Matsushima.
The Zoldyck/Chrollo fight was also pretty stellar. So they nailed the major moments and I never felt any of the major action setpieces were lacking in any way.
The storyboarding throughout the arc was great but two episodes in particular stand out, 45 and 59.
Episode 45 for throwing spiders and webs everywhere so as to capture Kurapika's mindset. Episode 59 for capturing the tension during the kidnapping and when Nobunaga is 'babysitting' Gon and Killua. There's a good emphasis on physical space in the room and both how far and close the entrance feels to Killua. On the subject of direction, I expected a much bigger drop-off from the TV series to the first OVA set due to the change in direction. While you can still tell there's a different director as the color palette is a little darker and the storyboarding doesn't have as many flourishes as the TV series does, it's close enough. I think a lot of that has to do with many aspects still being in place from the TV series such as the character designs, art direction, and composer.
I wasn't really impressed with the Yorknew arc in the 2011 adaptation but was pretty blown back with it here. It's amazing what quality direction will do. Oh and where the fuck are the blu-rays? Why am I stuck watching peasant DVD quality for a popular TV series that was made on cels?