• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Something that i noticed on a local site today. The Cannes Festival is happening and this debut movie by Lukas Dhont is getting some wild reviews for its portrayal on Transgender people. Dhont has given a Belgian interview, sadly there is no English substitute so you have to bare with me for making a translation. EDIT: I found a English link, not exactly the same but still. (As there is no summary, i had to lift a synopsis of the Belgian site and rephrase it a little bit.)

Summary:
Girl is about a confronting and touching story on identity and gender. The movie gives the viewer a look into the life of the 15 year old Lara, who wants to make a carreer as a ballerina. To reach her goal, she has to face the world, but also her own resisting body. Girl sees Lara struggling with the reality of her male biology, and her female identity.
Trailer (Clips from Cannes, there is no official trailer yet):




The director on his movie:

Dhont was an 18-year-old student, still in the closet with his own homosexuality, when he read a newspaper article about a girl in Belgium who had been born in a boy's body, but wanted to become a ballerina. "This story struck me so much. This 15 year old has the courage not only to say, 'I was born in the wrong body,' but also to strive for this high form of femininity, to be a ballerina. She was a hero. I was 18 and up until that point I had hidden a big point of myself. I said, 'If I make a feature, I want it to be about this!'"

Obviously Dhont had been interested in the topic before stories about transgender people became fashionable in mainstream film and TV. He and Tijssens wanted to take a very careful approach. "A lot of the media I've seen focuses on the reaction of the outside world and I really wanted it to be about the feelings and decisions in side of her," he explains. The filmmakers spoke to a lot of transgender people and their families, as well as psychologists and doctors who have expertise in gender transitioning.

"I wanted the audience to understand what it's like to be born in a body that's not yours. A lot of people have a body they don't feel fully connected to. I wanted to talk about the relationship with the body, and next to that, I really wanted to show the father-child relationship. The conflict is not between them, there is no question at all from the father's point of view whether the child should do this, this is a supportive character who shows a lot of love."

More on this: https://www.screendaily.com/feature...-cannes-transgender-film-girl/5129218.article

Interview (Translated): Source:
https://www.ditjesendatjes.nl/vlaamse-hit-haalt-transgender-uit-taboesfeer/

CANNES - The Belgian director Lukas Dhont ended up being the next big thing this weekend on the Cannes Film Festival. The 26 year old debuts at Cannes with Girl, a dramapic about a young transgender person who wants to become a ballerina. The movie is getting lauded with lyrical reviews.

Days after the premiere, Dhont is still flabbergasted on the response. ''I have not read any reviews yet'', he says apologetically. ''I just want to remain a little longer in the bubble that was the premiere. People are saying things to me, and i allow them to say this. I have heard signs that the reaction is positive, but i just want to keep on enjoying that amazing feeling of that first showing.''

The movie was recieved with a more than 10 minute during ovation, a rare phenomenon in Cannes. ''It is a very fragile moment to share something that for so long has been a part of you to the world'', Dhont explains. ''You worked so long on this, you know that you did everything to it that was within in your power. And you know that its possible that people will get touched by your story. But if that actually is going to happen, you never can be sure. To be present in the room and see that effect roll out, is such a huge thing.''

Focus

Dhont was reading a newspaper story back in 2009 about a 15 year old transgender who wanted to become a ballerina. It was this message that helped Dhont come out of the closet regarding his own homosexuality and he made a truce with himself that his first feature length movie was going to be about this Nora. ''With this film i didn't wanted to focus on the outside world, on the negative response that transgender people experience. I wanted to focus on herself and her relationship with her body.''

The time is there for more transgender people in movie, thinks Dhont. ''We want to see characters that for so long were part of the background. The highest goal for me is that we arrive at a point where it does not matter anymore that Lara is a transgender, and that we just see a human being. Just like how Call Me By Your Name was a movie about love, and not specifically a movie that was about the love between two guys.''


Review (by Variety. Contains SPOILERS):
http://variety.com/2018/film/reviews/girl-review-lukas-dhont-1202808113/

Given that this is such a hot topic and given that ERA has a strong presence of people who identify as Trans, i felt it would be good to give this some specific attention. These movies deserve the spotlight for highlighting that what is still largely unknown the mass crowd.
 
Last edited:

Rei Toei

Member
Nov 8, 2017
1,519
I heard him on the radio (Studio Brussels) this morning. Dude was still completely blown away by the reception. Geeked out over Benicio del Toro losing his shit in the audience. Good for him, young dude too pulling this off. Suposedly the lead actor did an incredible job. Movie won't be in theatres here till fall, unfortunately.
 

Lady Murasaki

Scary Shiny Glasses
Member
Oct 25, 2017
680
I'm so happy these movies are getting more visibility. We also had Una Mujer Fantastica and the Japanese movie Close-Knit (which is directed by a woman). I will check this out for sure.

https://www.japantimes.co.jp/culture/2017/02/22/films/film-reviews/close-knit/#.Wvl-DlX5jcs

They are still possible of critique, especially the ones who use cisgender actors in trans roles (which is something that should be corrected since a long time), but I see it as a step forward, especially when it comes to mainstream. I have friends who grew up with a pretty close-minded culture and changed their mind completely after watching The Danish Girl, when they might not be in touch with the subject otherwise.
 

Ketkat

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
4,727
Thanks for sharing this and putting in the work to translate this for us Rednecker! Its always great to see more stories like this get attention!
 
OP
OP
Redneckerz
Thanks for sharing this and putting in the work to translate this for us Rednecker! Its always great to see more stories like this get attention!
No problem :) I am actually quite shocked how little attention this has had so far however. But perhaps the topic itself backs people off, as they don't really know how to comment on this? I don't know though :(
 

Deleted member 14089

Oct 27, 2017
6,264
Thanks for sharing!
 
Last edited:

Osahi

Member
Oct 27, 2017
5,929
Read the first screenplay draft of this in 2015. (The director is a friend of a director 've worked with) Was already powerful stuff. Looking forward seeing this.
 

Geirskogul

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
1,022
I have doubts this will end up being a positive portrayal at all (because they flat-out don't exist in western media), but at least the trans character isn't a drag queen or a prostitute for once.

That first clip portraying her therapist as positive and affirming made me shake my head though considering that in reality the professional mental and medical health communities are absolutely horrible to trans people, especially in Europe with its incredibly damaging and outdated gatekeeping model.
 

Ketkat

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
4,727
I have doubts this will end up being a positive portrayal at all (because they flat-out don't exist in western media), but at least the trans character isn't a drag queen or a prostitute for once.

That first clip portraying her therapist as positive and affirming made me shake my head though considering that in reality the professional mental and medical health communities are absolutely horrible to trans people, especially in Europe with its incredibly damaging and outdated gatekeeping model.

It really depends on your location and who your therapist is. I wasn't able to find any near me that would be supportive in the slightest, but I did find a therapist that was really nice and helpful through online therapy. It's not something that a lot of professionals are trained in, which really makes it a little luck-based. We have a long way to go, but the way we're treated is slowly improving.
 

FeistyBoots

Member
Oct 27, 2017
3,506
Southern California
It really depends on your location and who your therapist is. I wasn't able to find any near me that would be supportive in the slightest, but I did find a therapist that was really nice and helpful through online therapy. It's not something that a lot of professionals are trained in, which really makes it a little luck-based. We have a long way to go, but the way we're treated is slowly improving.

My therapist had been remarkably supportive and affirming, I dearly love working with her. My doctors have all been the same, as has my family, friends, work and online.

I realize that my good fortune is atypical of our experience. Still, it shows that it's possible. :)

I'm so glad positive portrayals are becoming more common. We've been around forever, we deserve a voice in the chorus too!
 

Geirskogul

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
1,022
It really depends on your location and who your therapist is. I wasn't able to find any near me that would be supportive in the slightest, but I did find a therapist that was really nice and helpful through online therapy. It's not something that a lot of professionals are trained in, which really makes it a little luck-based. We have a long way to go, but the way we're treated is slowly improving.

I just have a problem with the "we're here to confirm and support you" line, when in reality its more like "were here to gaslight you, withhold treatment, give you an endless amount of barriers and hoops to jump through, and refuse to treat you while also blaming any and all unrelated health issues on your trans status!"

There's a reason I self-med, and its because the vast majority of doctors are outright malicious or completely clueless. I'm sure there are good therapists and doctors out there, but they are a rarity, and I take issue with any media trying to paint a rosy picture of the state of trans healthcare, because it is an absolute disgrace.
 
Oct 27, 2017
3,826
I just have a problem with the "we're here to confirm and support you" line, when in reality its more like "were here to gaslight you, withhold treatment, give you an endless amount of barriers and hoops to jump through, and refuse to treat you while also blaming any and all unrelated health issues on your trans status!"

There's a reason I self-med, and its because the vast majority of doctors are outright malicious or completely clueless. I'm sure there are good therapists and doctors out there, but they are a rarity, and I take issue with any media trying to paint a rosy picture of the state of trans healthcare, because it is an absolute disgrace.
Where do you live? I'm in souther Indiana and my fiance has had good experiences with her doctors and her old therapist. Even when they were (self admittedly) not too familiar with the process they were still kind, supportive, and professional.

Edit: I just wrote all that to a banned user who posted in May. :/
 
Last edited: