• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.

Andres

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,661
It's pretty fucked that they continue to charge 60 bucks after the long delay AND even now as the game still has problems.
 
OP
OP
Tonton

Tonton

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,387
If anyone has any other kind of temporary workaround to the game's PC issues they'd like for more people to see, quote this post with it so I can add it to the opening post
 

Marukoban

Self-requested ban
Banned
Oct 29, 2017
2,298
Oh my ... I'm really disappointed with NISA.
I will see if the Switch release is any good or if the PC version will be fixed later.
Otherwise might really have to skip this even though I've always double dipped on Ys. :/
 

Synohan

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,959


Praise be to Adol Christian!
Da8ffYGU0AA9011.jpg:orig
 

gdt

Member
Oct 26, 2017
9,468
So this all sounds like a major bummer. I just don't want to play multi plats on console. I wanna crank the hell out of this game. I've been enjoying the hell out of Falcom games recently. Here's hoping this all gets fixed.
 
Oct 26, 2017
413
So this all sounds like a major bummer. I just don't want to play multi plats on console. I wanna crank the hell out of this game. I've been enjoying the hell out of Falcom games recently. Here's hoping this all gets fixed.
Better pray the community can pull some miracles off with this game, cause I have zero faith in NISA at this point.
 

Crevox

Member
Nov 2, 2017
38
60fps and silky smooth

Has 4k support

It's silky smooth on a Pro, but there's a fair sum of framerate drops on the regular PS4. Nothing terrible, seems to happen most in Castaway Village (thankfully there's no action there)

This isn't really true.

I'm playing the game on a PS4 Pro and it definitely does not seem to be running in 4k on my 4k monitor. My XMB and everything is in 4k, the game is not. I can't pixel count, but honestly I didn't notice any difference from when I was playing it on a 1080p monitor. It might be higher than 1080p, or at least some UI elements might be, but there's no way the game is at 4k.

Also, the game has tons of FPS drops; I would say a lot of the time it's at 60 FPS, but it also drops below a lot of times. Heck, if I open and look at one of the party member's equipment screens:

Ricotta

...the game can't hold 60. You're right that Castaway village lags, but many skills alone will cause FPS drops, and there are many situations with multiple enemies where it can't hold 60.

I'd say it does a good job, but it definitely is not "silky smooth." It's the first Ys game I've played where it just can't maintain a locked 60. I know it's the big thing right now to hate on the PC version, but at least keep the facts straight.
 
Oct 27, 2017
1,152
Very disappointing news—especially considering what it could portend. Hopefully Falcom has some sense and works with competent companies that understand what makes Falcom products special (high quality writing, snappy—if not system-pushing—performance, etc.) from here on out. Falcom fans are not typically the type of people to overlook and forgive such quality issues.

The past games that have been effed up by localizers/porters have basically doomed those games—at least on certain platforms. Imagine having quality translations for the Gagharv games on PSP (or at all for that matter), or a PSP port of Ys VI that is as good as Falcom's own Oath in Felgana PSP port performance-wise.
Thankfully, performance patches are now a possibility, so maybe this version of Ys VIII can ultimately rise up off the B team, but that shouldn't be what we have to resort to hoping for.
 

Wein Cruz

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
5,772
NISA rapidly approaching Shitgnition Entertainment levels of worst case scenario when it comes to localization options.
 

Eila

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,941
I think they were worse during the early PS3 era. They are infamous for really screwing up games. Even console games, adding crashes that weren't present in the japanese version.
So I guess this is return to form. But why did it have to be this game? Why not screw up Tokyo Tatoo Girls or some other shit game nobody cared about?
 

Talus

Banned
Dec 9, 2017
1,386
Will be getting this... only when the issues are fixed and not a second before.

Cmon NISA, you guys can do better than this.
 

QFNS

The Fallen
Oct 26, 2017
935
I just really can't be surprised by any of this. NISA's initial handling showed you everything you needed to know. They undercut XSEED to get this game and it shows. I can't put my faith in anything they produce to be up to the usual level that XSEED produces ever again. I'm even going to be wondering if their usual titles like Disgaea will be clusterfucks or if this is reserved for Falcom stuff.

I know Falcom supposedly doesn't care about their Western fans, but I would hope their care about their own products being made to look like trash.
 

duckroll

Member
Oct 25, 2017
11,161
Singapore
Guess I'll go ahead and ask but why was this released at full price after the delay and now with all these problems?
I don't see what the price has anything to do with it. A product doesn't get cheaper because it is delayed. The question is why they are unable to just get a proper PC port out without major issues even after a long delay. Or, an even better question would be why the game wasn't delayed further, when I know for a fact that testers already knew about a bunch of these problems weeks ago and still encountered them this week. Why release a turd product and embarrass yourself further?
 
Oct 25, 2017
485
Thanks. We're just trying to make sure people can enjoy this incredible game on their platform of choice without major incident.

Also, I was the head of social media at Konami during the Kojima stuff. My skin is titanium at this point.

I'm looking forward to the progress. I'd also love to hear all of the juicy details about what happened with this game and why it was released like it was, but that's probably best saved for after things are fixed and the dust settles.
 

dark494

Avenger
Oct 29, 2017
4,549
Seattle
I'm a bit unnerved that they would put out a statement at this stage, with all these delays, with all the volunteer beta testers they had from the start, and they have the audacity to say
With your help, we will address issues with the title
Are they honestly expecting people to shell out $60 for a game that's 8 months late and this broken on arrival, and now widely panned, to help test and debug it for them? How about, you do your job instead, and get it right the first time.
Cmon NISA, you guys can do better than this.
No, they can't. They never have. We're way past the point of what by common standards is widely accepted as a pattern.
 

Chance Hale

Member
Oct 26, 2017
11,831
Colorado
"With your help, we will address issues with the title, starting with critical fixes first such as client crashes, and proceeding from there. We would like to apologize for issues encountered, and reconfirm our commitment to fixing these issues in upcoming patches."

Bahahaha, spend 60 dollars to help us help you play the game without crashing every 30 minutes. Never mind the delay and continued betas.
 

Jolkien

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,758
Anchorage/Alaska
Really disheartening to hear he quality of the PC port. I had a ton of fun platinuming this game. I thought about going back on the PC release but I'll stay clear or it.

What a mess how every thing was handled. Hopefully it'll show Falcom to prioritize Xseed. Their game deserves a better treatment.
 

Shengar

Member
Oct 26, 2017
1,052
To being fair to Falcom, they probably didn't know much about NISA reputation in the west because even theirs bad track record isn't that well known unless someone brought up about it. They are just as trustworthy as Xseed to Falcom when bidding for Ys VIII happened, not to mention NIS president personal connection to Kondo. With all of that in mind and the (now broken) promises of localization deal, Falcom gave the right to NISA on an understandable ground. At this point of writing I wouldn't accuse Falcom for not caring about their overseas fans just because they happened to wrongly chose NISA for Ys VIII. Considering that Kondo gave interview to western news outlet quite often in comparison to niche developers of similar size, at the very least he's aware of us.

With all of that said, if you (also me) are afraid of Falcom giving localization right to NIS(A) just because of Kondo, starting sending out email is probably the best option to prevent that from happening.
 

Toadofsky

User requested ban
Banned
Mar 8, 2018
303
Well this puts my reservation of Ys VIII for switch into question. I'm hearing rumors the videos for that version has been footage of the PS4/Vita version and not the actual Switch version. Are we in WWE 2017 Switch levels of bad here?

This really sucks because I've never played an Ys game and wanted to try this one out. Maybe I should hold off?

EDIT: Mispelled Ys
 
Last edited:

preta

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,491
Well this puts my reservation of Y's VIII for switch into question. I'm hearing rumors the videos for that version has been footage of the PS4/Vita version and not the actual Switch version. Are we in WWE 2017 Switch levels of bad here?

This really sucks because I've never played an Y's game and wanted to try this one out. Maybe I should hold off?
First off, it's Ys. No apostrophe.

The underlying game is wonderful, and you should definitely play it one way or another. We still don't really know how the Switch version is going to run, or even whether it will be 30 or 60 fps.

All I can say for sure is that the PS4 version is excellent if that's an option for you.
 

shadowhaxor

EIC of Theouterhaven
Verified
Oct 27, 2017
1,728
Claymont, Delaware
First off, it's Ys. No apostrophe.

The underlying game is wonderful, and you should definitely play it one way or another. We still don't really know how the Switch version is going to run, or even whether it will be 30 or 60 fps.

All I can say for sure is that the PS4 version is excellent if that's an option for you.
This. The PS4 version is really good. It was good even before the localization issues, better afterward. This PC port is crap. I uninstalled the game and they even provided me a copy for review. This port is crap and I feel bad for everyone who waited this long for this turd. I don't have any faith in this being fixed and playable anytime soon. And even if it is, would anyone care?
 

Thuddert

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,298
Netherlands
Thanks. We're just trying to make sure people can enjoy this incredible game on their platform of choice without major incident.

Also, I was the head of social media at Konami during the Kojima stuff. My skin is titanium at this point.

Damn, that's rough.

It would be nice if NISA can release a statement on what happened here down the line. Previous builds in the beta had a more positive reception than the launch version.
 

duckroll

Member
Oct 25, 2017
11,161
Singapore
To being fair to Falcom, they probably didn't know much about NISA reputation in the west because even theirs bad track record isn't that well known unless someone brought up about it. They are just as trustworthy as Xseed to Falcom when bidding for Ys VIII happened, not to mention NIS president personal connection to Kondo. With all of that in mind and the (now broken) promises of localization deal, Falcom gave the right to NISA on an understandable ground. At this point of writing I wouldn't accuse Falcom for not caring about their overseas fans just because they happened to wrongly chose NISA for Ys VIII. Considering that Kondo gave interview to western news outlet quite often in comparison to niche developers of similar size, at the very least he's aware of us.

With all of that said, if you (also me) are afraid of Falcom giving localization right to NIS(A) just because of Kondo, starting sending out email is probably the best option to prevent that from happening.
Falcom doesn't give a shit about what their overseas fans want. They only care that the fans exist and are buying their games regardless of publisher. It will be clear soon enough, but all Falcom really cares about is who can pay them the highest licensing fee for their titles, regardless of prior partnerships, established localization standards, or whatever. Of course Falcom is aware that overseas fans exist, they know because that's why other companies are willing to bid more for their licenses. Because the fans exist. But that's all Falcom cares about, overseas fans are a means to make companies fight over license fees. Money money money money money.