Depends on the size of the population. I was part of a very small fan site where we were always on the forums. We started a Discord and before long the vast majority of the conversations were happening there and the forums died.
-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
-
We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Is Discord killing the internet message board?
- Thread starter cj_iwakura
- Start date
It really depends.
For active discussion about a fast-moving topic, Discord is better.
For longer form discussion and archiving, Message Boards are better.
The Canadian Gaming Deals thread/community has done well to balance both its discord server and its thread here on Era, as have many others that I've seen since the migration began.
For active discussion about a fast-moving topic, Discord is better.
For longer form discussion and archiving, Message Boards are better.
The Canadian Gaming Deals thread/community has done well to balance both its discord server and its thread here on Era, as have many others that I've seen since the migration began.
Did you read my post? As I said, I'm perfectly happy here in Dinosaurland, lol. Not a big fan of Discord.
Ah, mis-read what you meant by "not that I mind that", thought you meant you didn't mind that internet boards are dead.
It killed a long running forum/archive (2006-2017) of a very small community that originated from the Xbox.com forums that I'm still a part of, and we lost more than we gained from moving to Discord I felt (including a member), all for a short-term increase in activity. :\
Gotta agree with this. I ran a fairly active IRC channel with about 40 daily chatters and one day someone suggested we make a Discord and bam! That was it! The IRC chat is full of nothing but lurkers now, everyone who actually posted moved to the Discord and never looked back. I miss it dearly, and they'll have to pry my IRC from my cold dead hands.
As for message boards, a good number of those chatters had abandoned message boards in favor of real-time chat long ago, many of them having given up on them once they found the IRC.
Its both text and voice chat, with emojis and can play media inside the chat.
I don't know what it is exactly but I don't play hardly any multi games consistently. It's comfy here, I'll stay.
Ah, ok.
Seems pretty good if people are into the whole real-time chat thing.
I got hooked on Discord by my Destiny 2 clan.
It was a pleasant surprise, and I wouldn't go back...but it's definitely not a substitute for forum discussions.
It was a pleasant surprise, and I wouldn't go back...but it's definitely not a substitute for forum discussions.
I prefer forums because I'm busy now I'm an adult, and what with work, chores, family, relationships etc it's hard to find time to sit down and mess around on a chat room for a few hours
I can post on a forum and go away for hours and then come back and pick up the discussion where I left it
My only experience with discord was in the transitioning phase from gaf to here... I actually liked it but I haven't gone there for months now, it was only in that transitioning phase. I don't really understand why these things are more popular than message boards, I guess they work better on phones or something. Aside from that, I have no idea!
Message boards peaked in early 00s. Back then you could find a forum for absolutely anything, but they've pretty much all died years ago. For niche topics, a more instant form of communication like Discord is probably better because the number of people contributing is so small.
That doesn't mean there wouldn't be need for a forum like ResetEra anymore. It offers more in-depth discussion about gaming for a large community, and I don't see the need for it going away anytime soon.
That doesn't mean there wouldn't be need for a forum like ResetEra anymore. It offers more in-depth discussion about gaming for a large community, and I don't see the need for it going away anytime soon.
Different media. It's like IM vs. E-Mail. Transient and unstructured vs. something persistent and more orderly. They serve different purposes.
Reading this topic I'm sort of glad I'm not the only one who feels that Discord is too fast and hard to follow.
Your post made me wonder about something, I don't use Facebook at all because I have no need for it and only made an account there to transfer my Final Fantasy Brave Exvius account data to a new phone but with the format being as popular as it is I wonder if eventually a "Facebook for Gamers" type of thing will crop up. Discord specifically targeted gamers (at first?) and it worked pretty well for them so I'm curious how that one would work out. On a much smaller scale MyAnimeList is something like a Facebook / Message Board mix for anime and manga fans and that seems to fare pretty well too.
Your post made me wonder about something, I don't use Facebook at all because I have no need for it and only made an account there to transfer my Final Fantasy Brave Exvius account data to a new phone but with the format being as popular as it is I wonder if eventually a "Facebook for Gamers" type of thing will crop up. Discord specifically targeted gamers (at first?) and it worked pretty well for them so I'm curious how that one would work out. On a much smaller scale MyAnimeList is something like a Facebook / Message Board mix for anime and manga fans and that seems to fare pretty well too.
I see it and have no fucking idea how it works. I just log here, write stupid shit and read more stuff from other people. I'm keeping the forums, thanks.
I remember joining a room for Destiny and Diablo, because "GEE YOU CAN PLAY WITH ERA USERS, THE BEST OF THE INTERNET!"
Then I got ignored every time I tried to ask something or join a game, which maybe it's my fault, because I don't get how the fuck it works.
I remember joining a room for Destiny and Diablo, because "GEE YOU CAN PLAY WITH ERA USERS, THE BEST OF THE INTERNET!"
Then I got ignored every time I tried to ask something or join a game, which maybe it's my fault, because I don't get how the fuck it works.
That was my experience in a few servers I'm in aswell and it really left me headscratching, atleast for some communities I feel they expect you to be a regular and know everything right from the get go.
And Something Awful,wich considering it's a paid membership forum makes it very impressive how big and active it is.
Discord is realtime, it replaces the LFG posts on our OT's but does not replace the topics in general.
There are a lot of super active forums out there funny enough. Communities that most people don't even think of have huge boards to this day. I think Discord is a very good supplement to forums tho. Even small communities might be better off in a Discord server. There's no cost and super simple to setup.
I use both, of course. Discord mainly discussions with some buddies of mine and a couple ERA communities.
I use both, of course. Discord mainly discussions with some buddies of mine and a couple ERA communities.
I find it hard to believe you've ever searched for videogame stuff and not got GameFAQs hits, they're pretty much always in the first page (if not the first hit) whenever I google something I want to know about a game.
Whether these hits are of any use is another matter...
I tend to just pop on discussion forums once a day or every couple days to see what the latest news is, and I don't see how something that is close to a chat room could replace that. I like the ability to backtrack through a thread to see how the conversation progresses, and I like that a forum is indexed and easily searchable whether through its built in search feature or Google.
I haven't used Discord but I can't imagine how it is a message board replacement. Seems like it serves a purpose of its own, which I guess in turn could result in less people frequenting message boards. I imagine there are plenty who would prefer this slower, check at your leisure format though.
I haven't used Discord but I can't imagine how it is a message board replacement. Seems like it serves a purpose of its own, which I guess in turn could result in less people frequenting message boards. I imagine there are plenty who would prefer this slower, check at your leisure format though.
Surely Discord isnt comfortable for keeping and organizing information, because discord group is basically a pack of several chats, and they didnt even had search function for a long time before they added.
Facebook groups lack functionality too, and /r/eddit is against discussing old stuff (old threads aut-locked forever, so you need to make new thread and perhaps loose what was already written before never learn about that).
Classic forums are the best, with subforums/categories, threads-for-each-topic, advanced useful search engine etc.
edit:
vanilla forums engine is not your friend, they strip down forum functions (tags instead of subforums, cant really search etc.)
they cant even search comments, it only searches opening post, not mentioning stuff like "by user name.."
Doesn't count due to anti-usage simplifications. Though thankfully it has threads, unlike imageboards they are not deleted etc. *pain of scrolling the whole discord chat dealing with like 8 subdiscussions at once which could have been several different threads instead*
Facebook groups lack functionality too, and /r/eddit is against discussing old stuff (old threads aut-locked forever, so you need to make new thread and perhaps loose what was already written before never learn about that).
Classic forums are the best, with subforums/categories, threads-for-each-topic, advanced useful search engine etc.
edit:
vanilla forums engine is not your friend, they strip down forum functions (tags instead of subforums, cant really search etc.)
they cant even search comments, it only searches opening post, not mentioning stuff like "by user name.."
Doesn't count due to anti-usage simplifications. Though thankfully it has threads, unlike imageboards they are not deleted etc. *pain of scrolling the whole discord chat dealing with like 8 subdiscussions at once which could have been several different threads instead*
Last edited:
I think it's killing everything. Everybody is slowly starting to use it. You'll still have big places like Reddit but they are moderated where as in Discord the person creating the channel sets the rules.
In contrast to Era or gamefaqs - sure. Yet pretty much more alive than many forums i know.
Than why new stuff is mostly inferior to it?
Eh I'm not a fan of Discord or chat in general. I prefer this more laid-back setting. Less pressure to type quickly.
