• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Zippo

Banned
Dec 8, 2017
8,256
Best Selling: Animal Crossing and Super Mario Bros. 4
Highest rated: Fire Emblem and SMB4

14624_front.jpg

???
 

LordHuffnPuff

Doctor Videogames at Allfather Productions
Verified
Oct 25, 2017
2,311
webernet
That was more Camelot than Nintendo to be honest. Dark Dawn was basically the same GBA game with none of the updates that were required for a JRPG at the time.

I think this is a bit misleading - I and plenty of others would have been plenty satisfied with what you described. Dark Dawn took a bunch of blundering steps backwards from the GBA games on things ranging from swapping the highly-praised sprites for ho-hum 3D models to points of no return that made djinn missable to a complete gutting of the puzzle dungeon difficulty the games were known for to trying to cram eight new characters into one game instead of four and four like in the prior two - you could barely get to know anybody since they all competed for basic characterization time.
 

Deleted member 6730

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
11,526
Why is Pokemon releasing this Fall such an urgent issue? The sales are healthy and the release catalog is healthy. Where is the code red that we are imposing a Pokemon game by 1.7 years into a hardware's life time? (They usually arrive 2-3 at earliest)
It's not urgent but the sales expectations seem super high without a game like this. Maybe 2D Mario but the only game that can top Zelda and Mario is Pokemon.
 

jdstorm

Member
Jan 6, 2018
7,561
I think people are massively underestimating Nintendo's 1st half 2018 lineup (assuming everything that was announced will come out before E3).

Keep in mind that a huge portion of the Switch's install base didn't own a WiiU, So most of these games are essentially new games to a solid portion of Switch owners. In the first half Nintendo have announced a new Mario game, a new Kirby game, a new DK game, a new Bayonetta game and the definitive edition of a Zelda game which will likely sell extremely well given the success of Mario Kart 8D. Throw in known evergreen games like Mario, Zelda, Mario Kart, and Splatoon and the Switch is still looking like an incredible value proposition. especially with solid 3rd part support starting to arrive
 

Deleted member 33

Account closed at user request
Banned
Oct 24, 2017
1,457
I should clarify that anything I post here is just educated speculation - not insider knowledge. Because this is a speculation thread about first party titles.
 

Plankton2

Member
Dec 12, 2017
2,670
It's true that a good chunk of Nintendo's big releases are coming in 2019. But I don't remember implying anything about Pokemon missing this year.

Honestly, I don't know a lot about Pokemon.

My impression right now is that Metroid Prime 4 and Animal Crossing are still very early in development.

Edit:

This is only educated speculation since is a speculation thread. I'm not posting any insider knowledge. I don't know when Animal Crossing or Metroid are releasing.

Appreciate the insight, I'm a little late to this whole thing so I just wanna add my 2 cents...I can totally see Prime, Bayo and even Pokemon being 2019 titles.

But I kind of have a hard time seeing Animal Crossing getting pushed to 19 or later, if as your saying it's early in development. The last mainline game was 5+ years ago, and the last 2 spinoffs were both released in 2015. Considering the sales history of AC on portable devices, (10M+ on each) you would have to imagine Nintendo knows full well the market impact the game can have. And considering what they want to do with paid online, AC can easily be one of the big ticket names to get people to purchase that service.

I think it's very possible the Wii U got a spinoff game and not a mainline game (the only Nintendo console to not get one), because by 2014 Nintendo knew the NX was going to be their future and potentially shifted the production of that project. I imagine Animal Crossing is always planning for their next game, and I doubt Nintendo would let huge a potential cash cow like that to be an after thought for the switch.

But my thought process is also based on me thinking Pokemon will be 2019 and not 18.
 

Ethifury

Member
Dec 4, 2017
1,802
After City Folk was released in 2008, it took Nintendo four years to release New Leaf (2012). And New Leaf didn't get released in the west until 2013.

Also back in October, Nintendo released Animal Crossing: Pocket Camp -- which took over two years to develop -- and it was delayed several times due to development issues.




There is no code red yet.

But Nintendo is expecting to sell close to 20 million Switch consoles by end of April 2019. That would bring the console's worldwide install base up to 37 million units.

Having health sales + healthy catalog is fine, but that doesn't mean you should be blinded by success and grow complacent.

They will need a big title in Holiday 2018 to keep momentum going.

When you say 20 million, are you 20 million units total or 20 in a year?
 

Meelow

Member
Oct 31, 2017
9,193
Anyway, as a big online game, I still hope Nintendo will make a "Nintendo MOBA" for the Switch. Would be so much fun to play.



I sure hope they take some notes from Stardew Valley, without changing the formula too much obviously.

Relationships and an actual job system would be awesome!
 

Deleted member 1839

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
11,625
Realistic do m you guys think that Aonuma's comment about a thief game will ever come into fruition or might it just serve as the basis for the next Zelda?
 

Yoshimitsu126

The Fallen
Nov 11, 2017
14,661
United States
If the current line up for the first six months of 2018 for Switch stays the same, I don't see it reaching the 20 million forecast Nintendo wants for Switch's second fiscal year unless they are saving some big hitters the latter half of this year and early 2019.
 
Oct 26, 2017
9,827
Realistic do m you guys think that Aonuma's comment about a thief game will ever come into fruition or might it just serve as the basis for the next Zelda?
Personally, I'd sooner expect it to be a major element in the next Zelda or spin-off as opposed to a new IP but I'd much prefer the latter. I wanna see some BIG new IPs out of Nintendo, like on the level of Mario, Zelda, Smash, and Pokemon, and it being a new IP means they don't have to deal with any expectations or baggage from any previous franchise and can have a bit more freedom for how they make their game
 

ILikeFeet

DF Deet Master
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
61,987
Realistic do m you guys think that Aonuma's comment about a thief game will ever come into fruition or might it just serve as the basis for the next Zelda?
New IP. I doubt Nintendo would have kept pushing Aonuma to make something new only to just turn it into another Zelda. And it wouldn't fit in with their current trend:
  • Animal Crossing peeps > Splatoon
  • Mario Kart peeps > ARMS
 

ze_

Member
Oct 28, 2017
5,926
Realistic do m you guys think that Aonuma's comment about a thief game will ever come into fruition or might it just serve as the basis for the next Zelda?
I'd love to see a new IP from Aonuma, as I think he's brilliant, but he actually followed those comments up by saying he'd prefer to continue working on Zelda.

"As I get closer to the retirement age, people ask me if I'm ever going to make anything other than a Zelda game. And so sometimes I think maybe I should. But Zelda games really have everything in them that I would want to make in a game. The way the main character grows and develops. The puzzles and the minigames. I don't think there's much point in me making something other than Zelda, if I did it would only end up being something just like it. It's a problem. So I think I'll just keep making Zelda games!"

With that said, Aonuma has a tendency of answering questions like a politician. There's a chance this is BS, though it does sound definite. Edit: If it's true, then he's probably planning to implement his ideas into a new Zelda, like you said.
 

ITSMILNER

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
490
I feel Pokemon, MP4 and Bayo 3 are all 2019 titles, let them all have adequate time to cook. 2018 could easily be filled with deluxe ports of Smash 4 and Mario Maker alongside a Pikmin 4 and even the latest projects from Retro and Next Level Games.

That would be a solid year in my eyes, add to that 3rd parties, Indies and whatever form the VC takes and that's a stacked year
 

Phendrana

Member
Oct 26, 2017
7,042
Melbourne, Australia
In the first half Nintendo have announced a new Mario game, a new Kirby game, a new DK game, a new Bayonetta game and the definitive edition of a Zelda game which will likely sell extremely well given the success of Mario Kart 8D.
Mario Kart sold extremely well because it's Mario Kart. Pokken has seemingly sold worse than it did on the Wii U, and I wouldn't be surprised if Hyrule Warriors goes that way as well. It might overtake the Wii U version sales eventually, but musous are pretty niche and I don't think Fire Emblem Warriors has done especially well either.
 

jdstorm

Member
Jan 6, 2018
7,561
Mario Kart sold extremely well because it's Mario Kart. Pokken seemingly hasn't sold much better on the Switch than it did the Wii U (if at all?), and I think Hyrule Warriors will probably go that way as well.

Mario Kart is definitely its own thing. I was just using it as an example of a successful deluxe edition. Obviously selling well is a statement that has different expectations depending on the game it is describing. I just think that the current infatuation with the Zelda IP combined with an extremely accessible game should see good results.
 

Deleted member 10737

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
49,774
Pokken has seemingly sold worse than it did on the Wii U
i think it has already oversold the wiiu version in japan, i would be very surprised if if doesn't pass the wiiu version's worldwide LTD pretty soon.
edit: as of this week, famitsu numbers
[WIIU] Pokken Tournament (Pokemon Co.) {2016.03.18} - 72.502 / 164.852 (173.494 with digital +8.642)
[NSW] Pokken Tournament DX (Pokemon Co.) {2017.09.22} - 51.960 / 191.761 (207.794 with digital +16.033)
 

Kcannon

Member
Oct 30, 2017
5,659
Mario Kart sold extremely well because it's Mario Kart. Pokken has seemingly sold worse than it did on the Wii U, and I wouldn't be surprised if Hyrule Warriors goes that way as well. It might overtake the Wii U version sales eventually, but musous are pretty niche and I don't think Fire Emblem Warriors has done especially well either.

I think Pokken is actually selling better in the Switch, at least going by Japan sales.

Edit: ^ Yeah, like the above poster says.
 

Glio

Member
Oct 27, 2017
24,469
Spain
With Yoshi, Kirby and Donkey Kong the same year, I do not see the sense of a 2D Mario so soon. A Luigi's Mansion 3 can easily sell 4 million and gives more variety

Regarding Game Freak Have you seen that they are hiring a lot of people?

And about Golden Sun: It's literally a game that they split into 2 because it didn't fit in a cartridge
You have to take that into account when talking about budget
 
Oct 27, 2017
9,792
Peru
I think this is a bit misleading - I and plenty of others would have been plenty satisfied with what you described. Dark Dawn took a bunch of blundering steps backwards from the GBA games on things ranging from swapping the highly-praised sprites for ho-hum 3D models to points of no return that made djinn missable to a complete gutting of the puzzle dungeon difficulty the games were known for to trying to cram eight new characters into one game instead of four and four like in the prior two - you could barely get to know anybody since they all competed for basic characterization time.

Not really. 3D models were expected from the DS at that point and in fact that's the only thing that Camelot was willing to update since everything else stayed basically the same. In the original GBA games there were also points of no return (I remember quite clearly that I missed a few Djinns because of it). The puzzles in DD were fine, there were hardly the biggest problem with the game. About the characters, let's be honest, GS never had the most complex cast, they were fine and likable enough but not really deep so there wasn't much of a downgrade in that regard.

And that's without mentioning things that Camelot SHOULD have updated like visible encounters and avoid points of no return at all cost.
 
Last edited:

TheMoon

|OT|
Member
Oct 25, 2017
18,774
Video Games
Honestly. I'd Rather they revive Endless Ocean as an open air game and include riding/racing Jet Ski's as a side activity
endless ocean ...open air .......... oO :D

just say open world. "open air" is not nintendo-speak for open world, it was a specific term for botw that also addressed its look. no need to force it on other nintendo games.
 

Xun

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,314
London
Personally, I'd sooner expect it to be a major element in the next Zelda or spin-off as opposed to a new IP but I'd much prefer the latter. I wanna see some BIG new IPs out of Nintendo, like on the level of Mario, Zelda, Smash, and Pokemon, and it being a new IP means they don't have to deal with any expectations or baggage from any previous franchise and can have a bit more freedom for how they make their game
This is where I stand.

I'd love to see a new IP from him, but I just doubt it.
 

TheMoon

|OT|
Member
Oct 25, 2017
18,774
Video Games
Do you have an example of a mini which was not followed up to support that? Or preferably more than one? Keep in mind that this does count instances where one market gets a mini and then another market gets a full direct.
like, all of them. it's completely missing the context since all of these mini directs were single-game focused and were followed up by a normal direct shortly after. which is completely not the case with this scenario here where we had a fully-packed first and thirt party mini-direct that essentially contained as much announcements as many regular ones in the old days. people hanging their hat on that theory are just desperate to ride the hype train again without actually spending a second to think about the whole thing.
 

jdstorm

Member
Jan 6, 2018
7,561
endless ocean ...open air .......... oO :D

just say open world. "open air" is not nintendo-speak for open world, it was a specific term for botw that also addressed its look. no need to force it on other nintendo games.

OK, An open world Endless Ocean game that includes Jetski's and other context appropriate vehicles would be great.

Edit: Though if whoever makes it could borrow BotW's weather simulation tech that would be cool
 
Oct 30, 2017
3,005
So Retro doing the Tropical Freeze port. Also is this team actually as big. I noticed on Wikipedia Monster Games co developed Tropical Freeze on Wii U.

With Mario Tennis Aces coming out, I guess Camelot is busy with that. It should be a easy game to develop as they are likely to be using Ultra Smash Tennis from Wii U as a base. I guess my prediction of Mario Strikers sequel by Next Level games to coincide with the Word Cup won't happen as I doubt Nintendo will release 2 Mario Sports games in the same year. This leaves me to believe Next Level Games is working on Luigi's Mansion 3 for Switch and I'm expecting a early 2019 release date for that.

Alot of people expected a ton of games to be released by first party on Switch consistently as portable Devs and console Devs are working on 1 system. But people need to realise 3DS games are easier and much faster to make than a HD game. All the number of 3DS games won't translate to the same number of Switch games. HD development will always take longer. Remember we 3 mainline Final Fantasy games on NES, SNES and PS1. Then 2 on PS2. And one of PS3.
 

TheMoon

|OT|
Member
Oct 25, 2017
18,774
Video Games
OK, An open world Endless Ocean game that includes Jetski's and other context appropriate vehicles would be great.

Edit: Though if whoever makes it could borrow BotW's weather simulation tech that would be cool
so you want Endless Wave Race, basically. Might as well complete the triforce and throw Steel Diver into the mix :D
 

TheMoon

|OT|
Member
Oct 25, 2017
18,774
Video Games
Alot of people expected a ton of games to be released by first party on Switch consistently as portable Devs and console Devs are working on 1 system. But people need to realise 3DS games are easier and much faster to make than a HD game. All the number of 3DS games won't translate to the same number of Switch games. HD development will always take longer. Remember we 3 mainline Final Fantasy games on NES, SNES and PS1. Then 2 on PS2. And one of PS3.

PS3 had three full-scale mainline FFs. And one MMO. PS2 had the same. Random numbers at the end are irrelevant here for the argument you're trying to make about dev resources.

Aren't they also a support studio. They helped out with Mario Kart etc.
They're not. They helped with the DK course in MK7 because it was based on their game and that's literally it.
 

New Fang

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
5,542
Keep in mind that a huge portion of the Switch's install base didn't own a WiiU, So most of these games are essentially new games to a solid portion of Switch owners.
I see people say this a lot, but every bit of evidence I can see suggests it's not true. The vast majority of Switch owners I know in my personal life, as well as the ones I see posting on forums, previously owned a Wii U.

Now I will say as time goes on and Switch continues to sell well that is obviously going to change, as the Switch has already matched the Wii U install base. I'm just saying that in year one, I think the percentage of Switch owners who never owned a Wii U is pretty low.
 

Deleted member 10737

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
49,774
I see people say this a lot, but every bit of evidence I can see suggests it's not true. The vast majority of Switch owners I know in my personal life, as well as the ones I see posting on forums, previously owned a Wii U.
switch has or will in a few months pass lifetime wii u sales. so even if everyone up to now has been wii u owners (which is ridiculous) from now on they all will be those who haven't played any wii u games.
 

MatrixMan.exe

Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,498
If the current line up for the first six months of 2018 for Switch stays the same, I don't see it reaching the 20 million forecast Nintendo wants for Switch's second fiscal year unless they are saving some big hitters the latter half of this year and early 2019.

Yeah. If neither Pokémon nor Animal Crossing drop then it's not happening. Smash alone isn't going to make it happen.
 

New Fang

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
5,542
switch has or will in a few months pass lifetime wii u sales. so even if everyone up to now has been wii u owners (which is ridiculous) from now on they all will be those who haven't played any wii u games.
Well the bar in this discussion isn't "everyone". The person I was responding too said the percentage of Switch owners who never owned a Wii U was "huge". I know "huge" is an undefined percentage, but I think it's still overstating things.
 

ILikeFeet

DF Deet Master
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
61,987
I see people say this a lot, but every bit of evidence I can see suggests it's not true. The vast majority of Switch owners I know in my personal life, as well as the ones I see posting on forums, previously owned a Wii U.
That...is not good evidence of anything other that you hang around people who buy/discuss Nintendo systems. Anecdotal evidence is not good evidence, especially when we are talking about millions of units
 

Deleted member 8791

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 26, 2017
6,383
Here's some more anecdotal evidence: I'm the only one who bought a Wii U that I know, and same goes for Switch. Switch won't sell a single more unit when it hits Wii U ltd. :)
 
Nov 11, 2017
296
Italy
Super Mario Bros
Super Mario Bros 2
Super Mario Bros 3
Super Mario Bros 4: Super Mario World
New Super Mario Bros (5)
New Super Mario Bros Wii (6)
New Super Mario Bros 2 (7)
New Super Mario Bros U (8)

so you mean 9

Super Mario Bros = 2D Mario

I don't agree here :)
New SMB can be considered a spin off to the main 2d Saga for a lot of reasons.

I think Super Mario Bros 5 would work well as a title.
Obviously it should be justified (new engine, new graphics and music).

I want so bad a well done, brave and big budget 2d mario :(
 

TheMoon

|OT|
Member
Oct 25, 2017
18,774
Video Games
I don't agree here :)
New SMB can be considered a spin off to the main 2d Saga for a lot of reasons.

I think Super Mario Bros 5 would work well as a title.
Obviously it should be justified (new engine, new graphics and music).

I want so bad a well done, brave and big budget 2d mario :(
they can't use 5 anyway since 4 was only forced onto the JP release and used nowhere else.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.