Time to look over our card ratings and see what we have collectively decided for this set!
Highest Rated Cards
- Duskbreaker
- Psychic Scream
- Kobold Librarian
- Twilight Acolyte
- Leyline Manipulator
- Dire Mole
- Vulgar Homunculus
- Reckless Flurry
- Hooked Reaver
- Carnivorous Cube
Duskbreaker ties Dragonfire Potion as the highest rated card ever (which seems very fitting). Psychic Scream is not too far behind either. Priest getting a huge buff this expansion, as if they needed it. Dire Mole is a surprising inclusion to this list, I would say. A 1/3 Beast seems pretty unassuming, but it has apparently been very well received by all the Hunters and Beast Druid players amongst us.
Worst Rated Cards
- Rin, the First Disciple
- To My Side!
- The Runespear
- Feral Gibberer
- Grand Archivist
- Toothy Chest
- Gravelscout Knight
- Silver Vanguard
- Crushing Walls
- King Togwaggle
The Purify of this set, To My Side!, makes its appearance on the bottom 10 list. But it is (deservedly) edged out by Rin, the First Disciple for "Worst Card in the Expansion" status. There is a good chance one of these cards will surprise everyone and become playable, if not a meta-defining card. The past two sets have seen both Prince Keleseth and Sherazin, the Corpse Flower hit the bottom 10 list, yet go on to become powerful cards.
Most Controversial Cards
- Arcane Tyrant
- Temporus
- Lynessa Sunsorrow
- Master Oakheart
- Psionic Probe
- Crushing Hand
- Murmuring Elemental
- Call to Arms
- Windshear Stormcaller
- Dragon's Fury
These cards have the highest variance in their ratings, meaning the community is very split on how good or bad they may be. Lynessa is one we've discussed in here quite a bit already. Others are probably just plain hard to evaluate such as Temporus. Some that didn't quite make the cut for this list, but have generated discussion here, are Potion of Heroism (#12), Kingsbane (#14) and The Darkness (#15). Some of us are going to be right about these cards, while others will be eating some serious crow.
Average Class Card Ratings
- Priest (3.28)
- Rogue (3.23)
- Warlock (3.11)
- Mage (3.06)
- Druid (2.90)
- Paladin (2.86)
- Shaman (2.76)
- Hunter (2.71)
- Warrior (2.62)
Here we have the average scores for each class's class cards. Priest, unsurprisingly, is tops thanks to having the top 2 cards in the set. Rogue is not too far behind though. Warlock and Mage also seem to be getting above average class cards this expansion. Druid and Paladin are in that middle tier, with Shaman and Hunter a step below. Warrior is in the dumpster. This doesn't tell the whole story though, as certain neutrals work better in some classes than others, bolstering those class's decks outside of their class cards.