• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

Are they hitting 20 million?

  • Yes

    Votes: 1,060 26.1%
  • No

    Votes: 1,400 34.4%
  • No, but it will be close

    Votes: 1,351 33.2%
  • Yes, and they will sell more than that

    Votes: 255 6.3%

  • Total voters
    4,066
Status
Not open for further replies.

Skittzo

Member
Oct 25, 2017
41,037
As I said earlier though the hardware forecast is getting a disproportionate amount of attention compared to the software forecast, which is equally important. It could actually be more important as the hardware is there to facilitate the sale of software and they make more money on software.

At least for me this is because I never once questioned that they'd smash that software forecast. That's a lot less interesting to me since it seemed basically guaranteed.
 

Instro

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,038
Here I'll do your math again:

From what I remember Japan's shipments are roughly equivalent to 25% of global shipments. If we're assuming they want somewhere between 10M and 12M for Q3 to give them a manageable 3-5M for Q4, then they would need to ship 2.5-3M to Japan.

If shipments are 10% higher than sell through (which is a big assumption) then they'll need to sell through 2.25M units at the very least, or ~1.78M more. Over 6 weeks that averages to be ~297k per week, which is basically the 300k you mentioned.

If we assume shipments are 20% higher (considering stock is a lot more plentiful than last year this might be more accurate) then we're looking at 2M units at least, or 1.53M more. Which averages to be ~250k per week. Still very high but much more manageable if they have a couple 400k weeks.

So it really all depends on how shipments correlate to stock this time (I have no idea if it'll be closer to 10% or 20%). And whether or not that 25% global ratio for Japan holds true.

Yep this is how I'm seeing it. Obviously the overall shipments could vary, presumably if they are "close enough", in sell through they can ship extra to make the goal.
 

Nocturnal

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
1,321
Just a reminder - this is Switch Sales in Japan during the holiday period 2017:

Week 46 2017: 86.999(+9%)
Week 47 2017: 145.200(+67%)
Week 48 2017: 124.770(-14%)
Week 49 2017: 164.908(+32%)
Week 50 2017: 221.210(+34%)
Week 51 2017: 269.684(+21%)
Week 52 2017:134.519(-50%)
Week 1 2018: 146.006(+9%)
TOTAL: 1.293.296
AVERAGE PER WEEK: 161.662

Now last year the only notable game release around this 8 weeks was Super Mario Odyssey which launched Week 43.
This year Week 46 coincided with the launch of Pokemon Lets Go, you have Smash Ultimate launching, Minecraft bundle launching, Super Mario Party JoyCon bundle launching, Dragon Quest Builders 2 launching... yeah 300K per week is a 100% increase YoY, so it would be difficult to envision those type of sales but in Japan I think momentum heading into 2019 will be much stronger. Games I outlined should help push the console and you have a bunch more games launching early 2019. Compare that to last year where you had Mario+Rabbids and Kirby as the only two games that launched during Q1 that sold well. There was certainly a drought of games up until March 2018 - when third party efforts started to ramp up a bit.
 

Skittzo

Member
Oct 25, 2017
41,037
That's fair. I would say that a lot of other people's fervent interest is a lot less academic though.

That could be very true, yeah.

Yep this is how I'm seeing it. Obviously the overall shipments could vary, presumably if they are "close enough", in sell through they can ship extra to make the goal.

Yeah it's very hard to pin down how the shipments will relate to sell through. I mean, some of the bigger shipments likely come in early January when stores need to restock from the holiday rush, but while these shipments happen specifically due to Q3 sales they will show up as Q4 shipments.

So without knowing Nintendo's distribution schedule all we can do is make rough estimates.

And if they are a bit shy of their goal I'd imagine they will ship extra towards the end of Q4, which they seemingly did last year (since Q1 2018 shipments were down but sell through was up in the US and Japan).
 

Zedark

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,719
The Netherlands
To be fair we don't actually know the hardware sales caused by the game.

I think the great word of mouth heading into black Friday and December is actually a better indicator for hardware sales than the 3M units of the game sold in its opening week.
Well, we do know that Benji said that hardware sales were "insane" during the week in which pokémon launched, and that definitely wasn't caused by the Smash bundle or by any other reason. Considering he knows what Pokémon typically does for hardware, I think him saying that Switch hardware sales were insane is a very positive indicator for Let's Go's hardware selling capability.
 

K Samedi

Member
Oct 27, 2017
4,990
For everyone's information, the US accounts for most of the holiday season game purchases. I believe Reggie said it sas around 60% so we should expect more shipments to US and less to Japan. The 25% percent Japan share does not hold for november and december. The forecast is really dependant on how the performance goes in the US.
 

KodiakOak

Member
Oct 27, 2017
168
There seems to be a lot of buzz around Switch deals on the main UK deals website as of late. Hopefully that's a good sign for Nintendo in a country I was under the impression had relatively poor Switch sales (compared to US/Japan).
 

Zedark

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,719
The Netherlands
For everyone's information, the US accounts for most of the holiday season game purchases. I believe Reggie said it sas around 60% so we should expect more shipments to US and less to Japan. The 25% percent Japan share does not hold for november and december. The forecast is really dependant on how the performance goes in the US.
Not sure that's the case for hardware, though. Last year the Americas' share of hardware shipments rose only 0.4% from September 2017 to December 2017. And that's despite total hardware shipments doubling in that period. There's a slight increase in share there, but it's largely negligible.
 

K Samedi

Member
Oct 27, 2017
4,990
Not sure that's the case for hardware, though. Last year the Americas' share of hardware shipments rose only 0.4% from September 2017 to December 2017. And that's despite total hardware shipments doubling in that period. There's a slight increase in share there, but it's largely negligible.
Yeah that may be true, but Im expecting a 15 to 20% share from Japan in Q3 to be honest.
 

Skittzo

Member
Oct 25, 2017
41,037
Well, we do know that Benji said that hardware sales were "insane" during the week in which pokémon launched, and that definitely wasn't caused by the Smash bundle or by any other reason. Considering he knows what Pokémon typically does for hardware, I think him saying that Switch hardware sales were insane is a very positive indicator for Let's Go's hardware selling capability.

True, I just assumed Phantom Theif was referring to the 3M sold announcement.
 

Zedark

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,719
The Netherlands
Yeah that may be true, but Im expecting a 15 to 20% share from Japan in Q3 to be honest.
Hmm, Japan would need to ship 3M to maintain its 25% share in Q3 (assuming Q3 aims to be 12 million shipped). Sell-through so far is about 450k, and it's hard to see the next 6 weeks put it above 2.5M, but shipments could be 3M I think. But yeah, 20% seems more reasonable at the moment, unless Smash blows apart even my lofty expectations.
 
OP
OP

Deleted member 249

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
28,828

Kouriozan

Member
Oct 25, 2017
21,132
Seems a bit prematuee to run a "The Switch lost its steam" story right before the holiday, where Nintendo make at least half of their yearly results there.
Even more weird from supposed expert analysts.
 

Deleted member 32018

User requested account closure
Banned
Nov 8, 2017
7,628


so they think it may be missed by 2 million.
Talk about Nintendoom, like seriously!!


The article in that tweet is absolute trash, spun about as negatively as it can. Including Pachter's "prediction", not mentioning Let's Go or the hype behind Smash or how well it looks like the Switch has sold in November, especially in countries such as the US.
 

Deleted member 32018

User requested account closure
Banned
Nov 8, 2017
7,628
All I can think of is that they want to bring Nintendo shares down even lower so they can buy and then sell after the next quarterly report if Nintendo looks like they will meet their goals?
 
Last edited:
Oct 26, 2017
6,315
Nashville
Jeffries thinks the switch won't be significantly up in quarter 3? That's similar to last year's numbers....And we already know te console is gonna blow out its November sales last year judging by US insiders, Japan Pokemon week and U.K. Black Friday estimates ....hmm
 

Bob Beat

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,916
I'd be curious about Nintendo's track record of predicting when they are having a good year. Sure, they missed on the Wii u.

But their successes usually mean they are conservative with their predictions and will do better than their predictions. Like, what is their track record for a successful console, early in it's life cycle?

That's the only reason I give them the benefit of the doubt. This feels like the early days of the Wii.

'Omg, no way they can keep this up.'

Next month: 'they did it again'
 
Oct 31, 2017
2,304
All I can think of is that they want to bring Nintendo shares down even lower so they can buy and then sell after the next quarterly report if Nintendo looks like they will meet their goals?
Everytime I see these churlish titles like "The Switch story has been exhausted" it always feels like these people are just colluding to hope those shares slip.
 

Aleh

Member
Oct 27, 2017
16,300
Read the article, everyone. It's even crazier than the tweet makes it sound. Nothing but bullshit like "After cramming its best franchises — Super Mario, Zelda and Splatoon — into the first 12 months, the Kyoto-based company was left with fewer games to show off in the second year, hurting hardware sales" completely avoiding mentioning Pokémon and Smash.
And it doesn't even stop there lol
 

Poimandres

Member
Oct 26, 2017
6,876
I'd be curious about Nintendo's track record of predicting when they are having a good year. Sure, they missed on the Wii u.

But their successes usually mean they are conservative with their predictions and will do better than their predictions. Like, what is their track record for a successful console, early in it's life cycle?

That's the only reason I give them the benefit of the doubt. This feels like the early days of the Wii.

'Omg, no way they can keep this up.'

Next month: 'they did it again'

Not sure about their history of high balling or low balling, but Nintendo have been very upfront that their 20 million is a hard target to hit. I don't think they've been low balling on this estimate at least!
 

Titik

Member
Oct 25, 2017
7,490
Seems a bit prematuee to run a "The Switch lost its steam" story right before the holiday, where Nintendo make at least half of their yearly results there.
Even more weird from supposed expert analysts.
It's possible some of them are trying to depress the market cap of certain companies or they are simply following the herd. You don't want to be That Guy when it comes to big money consultation firms.

Also remember that the average financial analyst actually do worse than the actual stock market performance as a whole. These are paid professionals too.
 

julian

Member
Oct 27, 2017
16,788
Read the article, everyone. It's even crazier than the tweet makes it sound. Nothing but bullshit like "After cramming its best franchises — Super Mario, Zelda and Splatoon — into the first 12 months, the Kyoto-based company was left with fewer games to show off in the second year, hurting hardware sales" completely avoiding mentioning Pokémon and Smash.
And it doesn't even stop there lol

Oh my god you're not kidding. That's one of the worst hit pieces I've ever seen. Practically everything is wrong in it. It's fucking nuts!

doubts are growing whether Nintendo Co.'s Switch can ever become a mass-market product.

Seriously?! It's already a mass market product. What is this nonsense? And they emphasize Labo as though that's where they put their money this year and don't mention Smash or Pokémon. Crazy!

Can't wait to buy some shares this week if idiots gobble this up.
 

Skittzo

Member
Oct 25, 2017
41,037
If nothing else this is gonna give my stock a nice big boost when they release their Q3 results and investors realize that it's still doing better than last year.
 
Oct 27, 2017
42,700
Yeah Reggie said 60%

Did they already sold 40% of what they need?

Q1+Q2 were 5 million. If Q4 sells at a similar rate, it will do 2.5 million. That would leave 12.5 million for Q3. That's 62.5% of the 20 million goal

That user misquoted. Reggie said NOA makes 60% of their yearly sales during the holiday season, where he specified October to December. Also, there is a 0% chance Q4 sales are at the same rate as Q1 or Q2. In fact, that's an absurd assumption to make
 
Status
Not open for further replies.