• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

Should Bayo 3 get rid of this feature?

  • Yes

    Votes: 589 15.5%
  • No

    Votes: 3,213 84.5%

  • Total voters
    3,802

NinjaDBL

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,093
As a cis man, my opinion might be ass (it is!), but a lot of Bayonetta's character comes from her teasing (and never conceding). Her losing her clothes while beating the hell out of you just makes too much sense. She's totally a sadomasochist, as her torture attacks suggest.

and btw I'm gay, I don't get off watching her. It's just hilarious and it's good to have such a funny character that simply loves to toy with and then destroy men's asses.

Same feeling here. I see it as her enjoying herself and having fun. I'm not at all aroused by it.
 

RestEerie

Banned
Aug 20, 2018
13,618
No..instead i want Kamiya to remove the 'cover up'.

#LadyGagaApproves

Also, why should bayo cover up herself if she's enjoying it (and she does seems so).

If men can flaunt their macho masculinity by having naked upper body and flexing their muscles, then bayo has all the rights to do so too.
 
Last edited:

Inugami

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,995
Would definitely make me more likely to play it. The pubescent boy fever-dream version of sexuality is not my style and regardless I agree with OP that it just looks bad in execution.

Again, her character isn't played for titillation or fan service. Yes, she's very sexual, but she's not necessarily sexy if that makes sense. But even assuming the worst of her character and creator, I'd say it's still several tiers beneath other AAA gaming and how it treats sexuality (say, God of War before the latest one as an example)
 
Oct 27, 2017
3,257
No.

And for why she loses her heair, its based in European medieaval beliefs that witches used their long hair for their magic. The more powerful/bigger summons need more hair to pull them in and control them. More hair for hear summons, less to cover her body. She has a finite amount of hair.
 
OP
OP
Cryptosporidium
Oct 25, 2017
7,624
canada
It's less about having an opinion and more about trying to dictate to Kamiya what his OC donut steel waifu has to look like.

Let the poor man bring his daki to life. It's the least we can do.

He didnt design her moreso just asked for certain things. I cant remember what her name is but another person did and Kamiya gave it the Ok

Theres a good documentary on it
 

Inugami

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,995
I wonder how different this thread would be if we had a male character using sex appeal as his power and getting naked for his moves.
But it's not, because it's not a 1:1 trade... Media isn't kind to women when it comes to sexual themes, being the victim in often extreme ways or at best the fem fatal/black widow at the best of times.

In effect, just changing the sexes around would make this Dude version of Bayonetta a more extreme, but still in line with a lot of other media.

(edit) I feel like your post got edited and it changed the meaning, or maybe it didn't and I just completely misread it. You can disregard what I said, but I'll leave it up for posterity.
 
Apr 21, 2018
6,969
I don't care for the clothes-losing, but I also don't care enough to want it gone if it will piss of fans. I guess I kind of like how weird she is as a character.
 

Kaz Mk II

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
1,635
Why would they get rid of a primary aspect of her design.

Not sure what you're smoking. If anything they haven't gone far enough.
 

Khezu

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,947
No, the fuck dude, no.

Ya she is sexualized to hell and back, that's kinda the point, but even past that, the gimmick and design is just cool.
All of her cloths and magic being made out of her own hair and then transforming is neat.

She is a disgusting horrorfying monster though, you are right about that.
Kamiya is into some shit.
 

Laconik

Banned
Nov 3, 2017
217
Voted No, because it just works. There is still a place for cheesecake and fan service. The games are rated M. So blood is ok but fan service isn't.

Ya thread seems to have flopped, OP according to the poll.
 

Deleted member 4093

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
7,671
Lmao I love you

I just feel like, yeah it's a dumb gimmick that reminds me of Quiet from MGSV. It's just a convenient way to show skin. She makes these huge creatures and items with her hair that can be gargantuan in size but can't keep any on her body? Just seems silly.

But at this point idk how you just change it. It's part of the character.

With that said I vote yes.
Had to they literally cant keep getting away with it. And Love you too!
You should actually make a good argument instead of saying that designs should not be judged, especially when women suffers directly from sexualized designs that only serves for tiltilation. I'm not sure if Bayonetta fits the criteria, but there are insane number of examples that does.
I see where you coming from but it doesnt apply to Bayonetta. Since when should Kamiya feel the need to change his OC to please yall?

IMO many not all but some of the people that think so seem to be way too controlling. Its ok to be sexy. Stop trying to hide it and hide female sexuality when they own it. This isnt a Xenoblade situation. Even though I disagree there too I atleast understand where people coming from. This situation here? Totally different.
 

Zen Hero

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,635
So I still need to play Bayonetta 2, but to give a bit of my take on the character, in the opening cutscene of Bayonetta 1, Bayonetta literally pole dances in a graveyard killing angels coming for the recently departed and stuffs one of the angels between her legs and crushes its head with her thighs, all while sensually licking a lollipop. That's not even the tip of the iceberg, another example is most of her execution attacks are like extremely brutal murderous BDSM stuff (using very brutal looking execution tools, but as she murders the enemies in these brutal ways she plays it off like it's in kinky fun as they lose limbs and the like), and she says a lot of innuendos and part of her character is she gets most of her thrills through murder.

Now, we can talk about if this is stupid or not, but I do think they defined Bayonetta to be a person who acts very much in her own interests and is overtly brutal seeking her own thrills and likes. I think it's helped a bit that Bayonetta doesn't have what is often portrayed as the ideal figure, IE she is very tall (taller than almost any character in the game even), looks older (like in her 30s or 40s), and in the first game always keeps her hair in that cone-type shape and her glasses on even when she goes naked. Though personally I kinda' wish they'd go further with some things, like have her body have body hair (which would make a lot of sense with her character actually), and visual imperfections like scars or something (she is fighting all the time), but at the very least the hair effects when she does special moves do look really cool visually. Like even in the OP here, a lot of people complain they don't find Bayonetta attractive and get nothing out of seeing her go naked and list that as a negative, which I think kinda' shows not getting the point (I'd prefer if they went further with it, actually). This is probably going to be a terrible way to word this, but she's like a stripper who chose to be a stripper for herself (rather than against her choice), and is confident with herself and her body, except instead of stripper she murders things very brutally and over-the-top with her hair for what she finds fun.

Hope that makes some kinda' sense.
That's a pretty thorough explanation, thanks.

I can see how it kind of makes sense in that context. Though I'm still not sure how to feel about the character, myself.
 

Marossi

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
3,997
But it's not, because it's not a 1:1 trade... Media isn't kind to women when it comes to sexual themes, being the victim in often extreme ways or at best the fem fatal/black widow at the best of times.

In effect, just changing the sexes around would make this Dude version of Bayonetta a more extreme, but still in line with a lot of other media.

(edit) I feel like your post got edited and it changed the meaning, or maybe it didn't and I just completely misread it. You can disregard what I said, but I'll leave it up for posterity.
I did only edit it because I mispelled, but the meaning has not changed at all.

I say this because I honestly believe some of the answers to the poll and here in the thread is not because Bayonetta is character who uses sex appeal as her power, and more because these people like seeing this woman almost naked making these moves on their screen. That's why I wonder how different this would be the other way around because I can bet it you that the percentage would of "No" would be much lower.

But yeah, I don't have a answer to this pool after thinking for a bit, this is not the camera situation that Bayonetta has, this is actually Bayonetta herself and her moves, I can see why people choose No but at the same time I'm not sure if it's correct.
 

Laserbeam

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,451
Canada
I honestly wouldn't care either way.

It's not something I even really noticed or think about when I remember the games.
 

Brodo Baggins

Member
Oct 27, 2017
3,949
I vote no. I always felt the way they covered her up during these moves was super fun and that the animations added a lot more of her personality to the gameplay. Taking it away for modesty reasons seems very against her character imo.

Besides I think this aspect is far from the sketchiest part of the game. Some of the extra costumes made me much more uncomfortable, and those don't even disappear during these animations.
 

bill crystals

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
1,079
Again, her character isn't played for titillation or fan service. Yes, she's very sexual, but she's not necessarily sexy if that makes sense. But even assuming the worst of her character and creator, I'd say it's still several tiers beneath other AAA gaming and how it treats sexuality (say, God of War before the latest one as an example)
The character design and game direction are often at odds in Bayonetta. The camera angles/framing can seem very male gaze-y in ways that I think undermine what they're going for with the design. Bayonetta is fuckin weird, I don't think it's the Feminist gamer slam dunk that it often seems to get hand waved away as, there is plenty to discuss and criticize (and praise of course). Overall something about it feels a little juvenile, which isn't surprising considering Kamiya. I get that plenty of people like that style but I'd be down for an attempt to "mature" it up, like they did with GoW this year.
 

Sub Boss

Banned
Nov 14, 2017
13,441
I would be ok if she only 'loses' her suit when summoning demons, no weird bathsuit in normal gameplay she looks cool clothed
 

Jeffrey Guang

Member
Nov 4, 2017
724
Taiwn
That will never go well with YouTubers and Redditors. Bayonetta is not a big name anyway. So if they want to make a game without ridiculous sexualized characters, they should just start a new franchise. It'll be much easier compared with navigating the toxic online feedback if they change anything of Bayonetta.
 

Anteo

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,099
The character design and game direction are often at odds in Bayonetta. The camera angles/framing can seem very male gaze-y in ways that I think undermine what they're going for with the design. Bayonetta is fuckin weird, I don't think it's the Feminist gamer slam dunk that it often seems to get hand waved away as, there is plenty to discuss and criticize (and praise of course). Overall something about it feels a little juvenile, which isn't surprising considering Kamiya. I get that plenty of people like that style but I'd be down for an attempt to "mature" it up, like they did with GoW this year.

True, but also she often looks at the camear and even winks at it, so (at least to me) it gives the impression that the character is aware of the camera and is playing along with it.
 

VZ_Blade

One Winged Slayer
Avenger
Oct 27, 2017
1,338
I don't care enough either way, but if I have to take a position it would be no. Although she is designed to be hypersexualize, it isn't done in a titillating way, and it fits her taunting character.
 
OP
OP
Cryptosporidium
Oct 25, 2017
7,624
canada
Voted No, because it just works. There is still a place for cheesecake and fan service. The games are rated M. So blood is ok but fan service isn't.

Ya thread seems to have flopped, OP according to the poll.

Id rather be proven wrong than live in ignorance

The character design and game direction are often at odds in Bayonetta. The camera angles/framing can seem very male gaze-y in ways that I think undermine what they're going for with the design. Bayonetta is fuckin weird, I don't think it's the Feminist gamer slam dunk that it often seems to get hand waved away as, there is plenty to discuss and criticize (and praise of course). Overall something about it feels a little juvenile, which isn't surprising considering Kamiya. I get that plenty of people like that style but I'd be down for an attempt to "mature" it up, like they did with GoW this year.

I feel, despite whatever Kamiyas intentions were, that the male gaze is subverted. Bayo herself recognizes the male gaze camera and takes control of it for herself. She takes something generally meant to dehumanize and reclaims it for herself similar to how derogatory terms have been reclaimed by their victims over the ladt several decades as a means of taking back power for themselves.
 

deimosmasque

Ugly, Queer, Gender-Fluid, Drive-In Mutant, yes?
Moderator
Apr 22, 2018
14,207
Tampa, Fl
As a huge fan of Bayonetts framchise. To the point it was my game of the year when it came out. And I currently own 3 versions of Bayonetta 1 and 2 versions of 2. I can say....

It doesn't make a difference to me. If she went the more Smash Brothers way or even lost the gimmick entirely it would not change my love for her and the Franchise.

She's more than an untextured "naked" body. Her personality doesn't require it for her to be dominating and powerful. Hell I am to the point now where I usually play Bayo2 with her in the opening cinematic dress so I don't even get the "naked" anymore.
 

Deleted member 4093

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
7,671
I did only edit it because I mispelled, but the meaning has not changed at all.

I say this because I honestly believe some of the answers to the poll and here in the thread is not because Bayonetta is character who uses sex appeal as her power, and more because these people like seeing this woman almost naked making these moves on their screen. That's why I wonder how different this would be the other way around because I can bet it you that the percentage would of "No" would be much lower.

But yeah, I don't have a answer to this pool after thinking for a bit, this is not the camera situation that Bayonetta has, this is actually Bayonetta herself and her moves, I can see why people choose No but at the same time I'm not sure if it's correct.
Well you're wrong. Secondly, how come no one ever looks at it from a woman point of view? I got introduced to Bayonetta from a girlfriend.

Men, you have to lose this controlling atitude about women. That shit aint healthy. Yes Kamiya made this specifically but theres plenty characters women designed and yall say the same thing. Nobody owes you comfortability and peace of mind by designing their characters to please you.
 

Inugami

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,995
As a huge fan of Bayonetts framchise. To the point it was my game of the year when it came out. And I currently own 3 versions of Bayonetta 1 and 2 versions of 2. I can say....

It doesn't make a difference to me. If she went the more Smash Brothers way or even lost the gimmick entirely it would not change my love for her and the Franchise.

She's more than an untextured "naked" body. Her personality doesn't require it for her to be dominating and powerful. Hell I am to the point now where I usually play Bayo2 with her in the opening cinematic dress so I don't even get the "naked" anymore.

While I do have a bit of a preference, overall this is me as well. I wouldn't even be disappointed by such a change... it's still a minor miracle we got 2 with 3 on the way at all.
 
OP
OP
Cryptosporidium
Oct 25, 2017
7,624
canada
To add to this

Bayonetta is one of my top 5 favourite franchises. Having bought both games twice I have something like 60-70hrs in Bayo 2 alone. 4 or so complete playthroughs with a dozen or so hours in Tag Climax destroying casuals who dont know how to dodge offset

#gAmER
 

Marossi

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
3,997
Well you're wrong. Secondly, how come no one ever looks at it from a woman point of view? I got introduced to Bayonetta from a girlfriend.

Men, you have to lose this controlling atitude about women. That shit aint healthy. Yes Kamiya made this specifically but theres plenty characters women designed and yall say the same thing. Nobody owes you comfortability and peace of mind by designing their characters to please you.
I would welcome you to join the discussion of this in the Women Sexualization designs OT. There are good number of women over here who are not fine with Bayonetta's game design. They get the same people everyday there "I have a girlfriend and she's completely fine with this design". Well she doesn't speak for the rest of the women who are not fine in the slightest.
 

Tuck

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,583
Bayonetta as a whole is so wonderfully over the top in its sexualization. This is just a part of it.
 

Musubi

Unshakable Resolve - Prophet of Truth
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
23,611
The entire thing about her personality is that bayo is in direct control of her sexuality and often wields it as a weapon. Removing this would just be undermining the character writing they've been doing for years with her and also lets not forget a woman designed Bayonetta.
 

Prolepro

Ghostwire: BooShock
Banned
Nov 6, 2017
7,310
Its as bad looking as Street Fighter IV nude mods.
giphy.gif
 

Deleted member 4093

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
7,671
User Banned (2 days): Dismissing Concerns on Representation and History of Antagonistic Behavior
I would welcome you to join the discussion of this in the Women Sexualization designs OT. There are good number of womens over here who are not fine with Bayonetta's design. They get the same people everyday there "I have a girlfriend and she's completely fine with this design". Well she doesn't speak for the rest of the women who are not fine in the slightest.
I'll pass. They dont speak for all the women that are fine with it. Those are completely fine excuses especially if the girlfriend likes it as well. Some women prefer to express themselves some dont some in between. I know my current girlfriend goes to the club sometimes and I be giving her the eye I but dont say nothing. Shes free to think, wear and feel how she wants.
 
Last edited:

Terraforce

One Winged Slayer
The Fallen
Oct 27, 2017
18,917
Glad era chose right in this poll. Should be more on the No side, but this is better than I expected tbh