Giant Panda Day 1
Vote: Faddy
Only Yanks have the right to betray the UK.
Prod vote, I suppose.
Scum nin would do that because it doesn't make you that much more likely to be lynched, while still letting you make posts like yours.
I didn't consider your claim alignment indicative, but now I have doubts.
Fair comment about Nin's claim, although it doesn't mean much. OK observation.
Nin's "why would scum even do what I did" post was also very defensive sounding.
Not much to say here.
That seems like some overly cautious thinking that seems more likely to come from scum than town.
Vote: Stuart444
I still think Nin's a good option, and ET isn't bad either.
Bit weak vote, but it's early D1 still. First mention of ET, doesn't clarify why he thinks ET isn't bad.
The B-Dubs slip is interesting and something to keep and mind, but I didn't get any scummy vibes from his reaction to it. I could buy that he was frustrated that he might get lynched so soon.
Maybe I should re-read Grizzly's posts, but I didn't get anything scummy from him either at the time. He played down the importance of some the reads people were discussing, but they were day 1 reads so I can understand that too.
Post with some stances, but nothing that really tries to solve the game - pretty sure he never went back to reading my D1 posts, or at least didn't comment on them later.
It almost feels like Zeke is trying to slide into a Blargonaut role where people give him a pass for everything because they've been silly all game. Though, often people eventually snap and suddenly decide to lynch Blarg from what I remember. So that wouldn't be a good long-term game plan for a scum Zeke.
I don't get that from Zeke, he is not Blarg-like at all. Coolest fits that spot much better. This is basically a filler post - nothing that really tries to solve the game, just some busywork.
I'm feeling better about Zeke now, I think his explanations and reads were satisfying.
Still trying to catch up, just woke up a few minutes ago.
This is kind of weird, since Panda didn't comment much about Zeke earlier except for that "he is kinda like Blarg" type of comment.
Yur lazy
Some days are busy for me IRL, and it's been a talkative D1, which is why I'm having to spend a lot of time catching up on reading.
Not much to comment - just explanation for being inactive.
I've never played with Coolest before, so I don't know his style, but the nonchalant role claim is straight weird, maybe it'sa gambit. If I take it at face value though, it's a role that discourages voting, which seems scummy to me. And to be town with that role I feel that you'd want to keep it a surprise.
New top scum for me:
Stuart
Coolest
nin
His Stuart read earlier was pretty lazy (it was early D1, but this post is late D1), so having him on top of scum reads is eh.
Bad gambit is bad. Let's just vote him off the island and make this easier on ourselves.
Vote: CoolestSpot
Lazy lazy vote. Possible vote to try to save ET.
I've made it clear that CS is only one option I'm looking at. I've been pushing Stuart and nin too, but most people haven't been too interested.
His push for Stuart are nin have been weak to say the least, yet he posts here like they are very likely to be scum.
This right here people is what we call an OMGUS vote.
It's not OMGUS.
I did not like his post where he pulled out "Why would scum me do what I just did" line. First, that line always seems a bit scummy to me, and second, his move wasn't even endangering him, so he was giving himself way too much townie cred.
Nothing nin has done since has stood out in a good way to reverse these feelings either.
Again, this push on nin is weak.
As for ET, he's not a bad lynch per se, but the case against him is just the usual Day1 bad vibes and/or busywork case instead of specific scummy post cases on Nin, Stuart, and Coolest.
Wishy-washy stance on ET. Again with the weak-sauce chases on nin and Stuart
Yeah, I can see the comparison to GoT ET. But that's why I agree he's not a bad lynch. It's still day 1 though, so it's not surprising that a number of players kind of look bad/are under the radar. If he's the same on day 2 or 3, then ET will rapidly move up my scum list.
Trying to defend ET with weak arguments. "Well I guess he could become more towny later."
Jesus man it's day 1. Nothing you've posted today will end up mattering in all likelihood either.
This post is dumb.
