I've been seeing a crazy amount of misinformation on Twitter, and downright ridiculous stuff being said about various people in the industry, so I thought I'd make a post to clarify what has been said publicly by most folks on the subject of Smash and its leaks. I'm pretty sure I've covered my own opinion enough here, but I'll start there:
What Steve Has Said:
The banner leak is fake. I've heard this from multiple sources but cannot confirm if the content of it is fake. I believe the contents are at least partially fake for reasons I can't divulge.
What GX Has Said:
The banner leak is fake. "Another example of an extremely blurry leak."
AndreGX tweeted the following:
What Imran Has Said:
"There's also the fact that, well, the roster seems woefully incomplete. Every single Super Smash Bros. game has added a new Pokemon character. Pikachu and Jigglypuff headlined the first game, Mewtwo came in at Melee, Brawl introduced Lucario, and the 3DS/Wii U game brought in Greninja. Since the last game's release, a new Pokemon generation has had two mainline games, and Pokemon itself has seen a resurgence in sales and popularity that had more or less taken over the world again, however temporarily. The presumption of a new Pokemon fighter in each game is so concrete that Greninja was originally just listed as "New Pokemon" on the game's design document, according to director Masahiro Sakurai, to be decided at a later date. This would be a strange time to suddenly decide the series does not need a new Pokemon character." -
Source Link
GX in particular seems to be getting the brunt of the craziness on Twitter for the time being, seemingly because they haven't dissected the leak enough. I can't speak for them, but if I had to guess the discourse around this whole topic is enough for them, and if they all agree its fake, a lengthy discussion video without a counterpoint would be a bit boring, IMO. I've seen tweets aimed at people all over the industry that don't support the leak claiming they've said all manor of stuff, or are in Nintendo's pocket, or are dismissing the leak because Incineroar wasn't in it, when in reality, I don't think anybody has said that. Saying it's weird more people aren't expecting another Pokemon isn't the same thing as saying, "this one very specific Pokemon is in the game and I believe it wholeheartedly."