• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.

Which team are you in, hooman? (NOTE: Vote-changing disabled!)

  • #TeamReal

    Votes: 2,046 67.7%
  • #TeamFake

    Votes: 978 32.3%

  • Total voters
    3,024
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

Thatguy

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
6,207
Seattle WA
More weight for #teamfake:

The leak is supposedly on a promotional paper wristband. OK lets go with that for a moment. It's safe to assume these wristbands are to be actually used for a public event. What events are there between now and Dec 7? Actually for this to be real it would have to be between the Direct that reveals all these characters and Dec 7. So we still have all of November and a tiny bit of October and December. The only major event left according to Nintendos official website (https://smashbros.nintendo.com/events/) are:

1. Wendys college tailgate tour - ongoing right now with E3 build
2. Enthusiast Gaming Live Expo - done, E3 build
3. TBS Event Smash Invitational to be aired in November....could this be the event where these wristbands would be used?

NOPE:
https://www.shacknews.com/article/1...bros-ultimate-invitational-in-november-update
"ELEAGUE has clarified what exactly November's Nintendo tie-in will entail. The Super Smash Bros. Invitational 2018 will be a three-part series airing footage of the E3 2018 Smash Invitational, starting on November 16. While there is no new tournament being held, ELEAGUE will air previously-unseen footage from E3's tournament exclusively on TBS."

OK so if these were indeed wristbands commissioned by Bamco and Bamco went out of their way to provide this company with the final banner not an existing banner, they would need to be used when exactly? The Nintendo site says 'more events' so are we to believe there will be another event that isn't announced that takes place between final reveal and release date and THAT is when these arm bands would be used? Seems incredibly unlikely to me. Are they for midnight launches? MAAAAYYYBEEE, but I think thats a stretch. Paper wristbands are almost always used in some sort of admission scenario.
 

Deleted member 176

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
37,160
long story short there's a pattern in how the blog handles the blogposts by highlighting a certain number of characters every week and people are calculating this weekly to determinate that if the pattern keep its way there should be 6-8 characters left to announce
oh damn, I completely forgot. Blog theory redeemed.
 

Deleted member 2791

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
19,054
More weight for #teamfake:

The leak is supposedly on a promotional paper wristband. OK lets go with that for a moment. It's safe to assume these wristbands are to be actually used for a public event. What events are there between now and Dec 7? Actually for this to be real it would have to be between the Direct that reveals all these characters and Dec 7. So we still have all of November and a tiny bit of October and December. The only major event left according to Nintendos official website (https://smashbros.nintendo.com/events/) are:

1. Wendys college tailgate tour - ongoing right now with E3 build
2. Enthusiast Gaming Live Expo - done, E3 build
3. TBS Event Smash Invitational to be aired in November....could this be the event where these wristbands would be used?

NOPE:
https://www.shacknews.com/article/1...bros-ultimate-invitational-in-november-update
"ELEAGUE has clarified what exactly November's Nintendo tie-in will entail. The Super Smash Bros. Invitational 2018 will be a three-part series airing footage of the E3 2018 Smash Invitational, starting on November 16. While there is no new tournament being held, ELEAGUE will air previously-unseen footage from E3's tournament exclusively on TBS."

OK so if these were indeed wristbands commissioned by Bamco and Bamco went out of their way to provide this company with the final banner not an existing banner, they would need to be used when exactly? The Nintendo site says 'more events' so are we to believe there will be another event that isn't announced that takes place between final reveal and release date and THAT is when these arm bands would be used? Seems incredibly unlikely to me. Are they for midnight launches? MAAAAYYYBEEE, but I think thats a stretch. Paper wristbands are almost always used in some sort of admission scenario.

press event
why did you write this entire thing lmao
 

Deleted member 176

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
37,160
More weight for #teamfake:

The leak is supposedly on a promotional paper wristband. OK lets go with that for a moment. It's safe to assume these wristbands are to be actually used for a public event. What events are there between now and Dec 7? Actually for this to be real it would have to be between the Direct that reveals all these characters and Dec 7. So we still have all of November and a tiny bit of October and December. The only major event left according to Nintendos official website (https://smashbros.nintendo.com/events/) are:

1. Wendys college tailgate tour - ongoing right now with E3 build
2. Enthusiast Gaming Live Expo - done, E3 build
3. TBS Event Smash Invitational to be aired in November....could this be the event where these wristbands would be used?

NOPE:
https://www.shacknews.com/article/1...bros-ultimate-invitational-in-november-update
"ELEAGUE has clarified what exactly November's Nintendo tie-in will entail. The Super Smash Bros. Invitational 2018 will be a three-part series airing footage of the E3 2018 Smash Invitational, starting on November 16. While there is no new tournament being held, ELEAGUE will air previously-unseen footage from E3's tournament exclusively on TBS."

OK so if these were indeed wristbands commissioned by Bamco and Bamco went out of their way to provide this company with the final banner not an existing banner, they would need to be used when exactly? The Nintendo site says 'more events' so are we to believe there will be another event that isn't announced that takes place between final reveal and release date and THAT is when these arm bands would be used? Seems incredibly unlikely to me. Are they for midnight launches? MAAAAYYYBEEE, but I think thats a stretch. Paper wristbands are almost always used in some sort of admission scenario.
Does Nintendo have any kind of unique presence at the Game Awards?
 

Kewlmyc

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
26,685
Person A: "That leak is fake, I have proof."
Person B: "Oh okay, what's the proof?"
Person A: "I can't say, teehee."

Can anyone who is person A kindly fuck off forever? Thank you.
 

nintendoman58

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,109
Consider me a member of #TeamFake.

I don't think we'll get a direct where we'll get more than two newcomers and two echoes.
 

Aaronrules380

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
22,429
More weight for #teamfake:

The leak is supposedly on a promotional paper wristband. OK lets go with that for a moment. It's safe to assume these wristbands are to be actually used for a public event. What events are there between now and Dec 7? Actually for this to be real it would have to be between the Direct that reveals all these characters and Dec 7. So we still have all of November and a tiny bit of October and December. The only major event left according to Nintendos official website (https://smashbros.nintendo.com/events/) are:

1. Wendys college tailgate tour - ongoing right now with E3 build
2. Enthusiast Gaming Live Expo - done, E3 build
3. TBS Event Smash Invitational to be aired in November....could this be the event where these wristbands would be used?

NOPE:
https://www.shacknews.com/article/1...bros-ultimate-invitational-in-november-update
"ELEAGUE has clarified what exactly November's Nintendo tie-in will entail. The Super Smash Bros. Invitational 2018 will be a three-part series airing footage of the E3 2018 Smash Invitational, starting on November 16. While there is no new tournament being held, ELEAGUE will air previously-unseen footage from E3's tournament exclusively on TBS."

OK so if these were indeed wristbands commissioned by Bamco and Bamco went out of their way to provide this company with the final banner not an existing banner, they would need to be used when exactly? The Nintendo site says 'more events' so are we to believe there will be another event that isn't announced that takes place between final reveal and release date and THAT is when these arm bands would be used? Seems incredibly unlikely to me. Are they for midnight launches? MAAAAYYYBEEE, but I think thats a stretch. Paper wristbands are almost always used in some sort of admission scenario.
Why would the event need to be before launch
 

Mik317

Member
Oct 25, 2017
8,775
More weight for #teamfake:

The leak is supposedly on a promotional paper wristband. OK lets go with that for a moment. It's safe to assume these wristbands are to be actually used for a public event. What events are there between now and Dec 7? Actually for this to be real it would have to be between the Direct that reveals all these characters and Dec 7. So we still have all of November and a tiny bit of October and December. The only major event left according to Nintendos official website (https://smashbros.nintendo.com/events/) are:

1. Wendys college tailgate tour - ongoing right now with E3 build
2. Enthusiast Gaming Live Expo - done, E3 build
3. TBS Event Smash Invitational to be aired in November....could this be the event where these wristbands would be used?

NOPE:
https://www.shacknews.com/article/1...bros-ultimate-invitational-in-november-update
"ELEAGUE has clarified what exactly November's Nintendo tie-in will entail. The Super Smash Bros. Invitational 2018 will be a three-part series airing footage of the E3 2018 Smash Invitational, starting on November 16. While there is no new tournament being held, ELEAGUE will air previously-unseen footage from E3's tournament exclusively on TBS."

OK so if these were indeed wristbands commissioned by Bamco and Bamco went out of their way to provide this company with the final banner not an existing banner, they would need to be used when exactly? The Nintendo site says 'more events' so are we to believe there will be another event that isn't announced that takes place between final reveal and release date and THAT is when these arm bands would be used? Seems incredibly unlikely to me. Are they for midnight launches? MAAAAYYYBEEE, but I think thats a stretch. Paper wristbands are almost always used in some sort of admission scenario.

could be an event for the press to preview the game. They do those for directs some times IIRC
 

Xwing

Unshakable Resolve - One Winged Slayer
Member
Nov 11, 2017
9,876
More weight for #teamfake:

The leak is supposedly on a promotional paper wristband. OK lets go with that for a moment. It's safe to assume these wristbands are to be actually used for a public event. What events are there between now and Dec 7? Actually for this to be real it would have to be between the Direct that reveals all these characters and Dec 7. So we still have all of November and a tiny bit of October and December. The only major event left according to Nintendos official website (https://smashbros.nintendo.com/events/) are:

1. Wendys college tailgate tour - ongoing right now with E3 build
2. Enthusiast Gaming Live Expo - done, E3 build
3. TBS Event Smash Invitational to be aired in November....could this be the event where these wristbands would be used?

NOPE:
https://www.shacknews.com/article/1...bros-ultimate-invitational-in-november-update
"ELEAGUE has clarified what exactly November's Nintendo tie-in will entail. The Super Smash Bros. Invitational 2018 will be a three-part series airing footage of the E3 2018 Smash Invitational, starting on November 16. While there is no new tournament being held, ELEAGUE will air previously-unseen footage from E3's tournament exclusively on TBS."

OK so if these were indeed wristbands commissioned by Bamco and Bamco went out of their way to provide this company with the final banner not an existing banner, they would need to be used when exactly? The Nintendo site says 'more events' so are we to believe there will be another event that isn't announced that takes place between final reveal and release date and THAT is when these arm bands would be used? Seems incredibly unlikely to me. Are they for midnight launches? MAAAAYYYBEEE, but I think thats a stretch. Paper wristbands are almost always used in some sort of admission scenario.

It's clearly not a wristband. It's a mockup for a circular cardboard store display designed to placed on top of a high center display or hang from a ceiling.
 

Deleted member 5764

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
6,574
More weight for #teamfake:

The leak is supposedly on a promotional paper wristband. OK lets go with that for a moment. It's safe to assume these wristbands are to be actually used for a public event. What events are there between now and Dec 7? Actually for this to be real it would have to be between the Direct that reveals all these characters and Dec 7. So we still have all of November and a tiny bit of October and December. The only major event left according to Nintendos official website (https://smashbros.nintendo.com/events/) are:

1. Wendys college tailgate tour - ongoing right now with E3 build
2. Enthusiast Gaming Live Expo - done, E3 build
3. TBS Event Smash Invitational to be aired in November....could this be the event where these wristbands would be used?

NOPE:
https://www.shacknews.com/article/1...bros-ultimate-invitational-in-november-update
"ELEAGUE has clarified what exactly November's Nintendo tie-in will entail. The Super Smash Bros. Invitational 2018 will be a three-part series airing footage of the E3 2018 Smash Invitational, starting on November 16. While there is no new tournament being held, ELEAGUE will air previously-unseen footage from E3's tournament exclusively on TBS."

OK so if these were indeed wristbands commissioned by Bamco and Bamco went out of their way to provide this company with the final banner not an existing banner, they would need to be used when exactly? The Nintendo site says 'more events' so are we to believe there will be another event that isn't announced that takes place between final reveal and release date and THAT is when these arm bands would be used? Seems incredibly unlikely to me. Are they for midnight launches? MAAAAYYYBEEE, but I think thats a stretch. Paper wristbands are almost always used in some sort of admission scenario.

Who says the wristbands would be for a pre-launch event? Plenty of stores still do midnight releases.
 

Trey

Member
Oct 25, 2017
17,957
I like this leak and want to believe it purely because it would me Incineroar isn't in.

What a waste of time such a character would be.
 

Marmoka

Member
Oct 27, 2017
5,013
Honestly I don't know what to think. I don't find Shadow or Banjo-Kazooie credible.
There could be some chances for Banjo, considering the weird decisions Microsoft usually takes, like releasing their games also on PC, or releasing Minecraft even on digital clocks, I feel more neutral with this.
But Shadow does not make any sense, it would be just a Sonic clone, and it's not a popular or relevant character like Sonic, Pacman or Megaman. I would say he's just popular for those whose SA2 was their first Sonic game, outside of that game it's just meh. I just don't get it. If it's real, then it's a weird decision.
Meanwhile, other characters seem to fit, and are credible, they make sense.

I voted #teamFake because there was no #teamNeutral on the pole.
 

Anteo

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,099
The problem is that Sakurai said explicitly that every characters would be revealed before the release

So basically, this banner would have to appear on the wild a month before release to give them time to reveal the last remaining characters.

Now, lets go back to the grinch thing. it is there on the leak and they are working at the same time as the smash banner. when does that grinch movie comes out? google tells me: November 8, 2018. But smash comes out on december? why is it there along that grinch stuff which will release a month before smash? maybe the banner itself will appear on the wild a month early as well?
 

Deleted member 176

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
37,160
It goes beyond fun project on the side when it implicates an entire marketing firm and a specific employee.
It also wasn't revealed in a way that would make it seem like it's supposed to be a fun project, or even that it's supposed to be a leak. It was incidental.

If it's a fake the person who made and leaked it is The Riddler.
 

Phendrift

Member
Oct 25, 2017
32,293
I wouldn't call this a leak. It's a rumor. For all we know they did this as a fun project and saw the 4chan character list.
I suppose so. But the company, the employee being legit, having to rearrange the entire newcomer poster and draw a blank version of it, come up with entirely new poses/renders for the seven characters - this would be a legendary fake.

I'm happy with the game's roster regardless, and if the leak is fake at least it made me excited to speculate again but still.... it hasn't added up so perfectly like this in a while
 

Plasmid

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
686
it's real. So much work for it not to be, the linkedin leak is career ending as well which makes me more likely to believe it's real.

Isaac is a v interesting choice.
 

Dark Cloud

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
61,087
I wished the insiders here would discuss the marketing part. I don't see what's fun in using real companies to do a fake and probably screwing your career or someone else's career.
 

Lady Bow

Member
Nov 30, 2017
11,283
More weight for #teamfake:

The leak is supposedly on a promotional paper wristband. OK lets go with that for a moment. It's safe to assume these wristbands are to be actually used for a public event. What events are there between now and Dec 7? Actually for this to be real it would have to be between the Direct that reveals all these characters and Dec 7. So we still have all of November and a tiny bit of October and December. The only major event left according to Nintendos official website (https://smashbros.nintendo.com/events/) are:

1. Wendys college tailgate tour - ongoing right now with E3 build
2. Enthusiast Gaming Live Expo - done, E3 build
3. TBS Event Smash Invitational to be aired in November....could this be the event where these wristbands would be used?

NOPE:
https://www.shacknews.com/article/1...bros-ultimate-invitational-in-november-update
"ELEAGUE has clarified what exactly November's Nintendo tie-in will entail. The Super Smash Bros. Invitational 2018 will be a three-part series airing footage of the E3 2018 Smash Invitational, starting on November 16. While there is no new tournament being held, ELEAGUE will air previously-unseen footage from E3's tournament exclusively on TBS."

OK so if these were indeed wristbands commissioned by Bamco and Bamco went out of their way to provide this company with the final banner not an existing banner, they would need to be used when exactly? The Nintendo site says 'more events' so are we to believe there will be another event that isn't announced that takes place between final reveal and release date and THAT is when these arm bands would be used? Seems incredibly unlikely to me. Are they for midnight launches? MAAAAYYYBEEE, but I think thats a stretch. Paper wristbands are almost always used in some sort of admission scenario.
You missed one tweeted by Sakurai himself.

 
Oct 26, 2017
912
I suppose so. But the company, the employee being legit, having to rearrange the entire newcomer poster and draw a blank version of it, come up with entirely new poses/renders for the seven characters - this would be a legendary fake.

I'm happy with the game's roster regardless, and if the leak is fake at least it made me excited to speculate again but still.... it hasn't added up so perfectly like this in a while

Smash Bros is THE game series known for legendary fakes. Rayman fooled a bunch of people.

But yeah, it's leaning true. But I won't believe until I see it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.