• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

Which team are you in, hooman? (NOTE: Vote-changing disabled!)

  • #TeamReal

    Votes: 2,046 67.7%
  • #TeamFake

    Votes: 978 32.3%

  • Total voters
    3,024
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

Deleted member 32561

User requested account closure
Banned
Nov 11, 2017
3,831
It's in line with the Music Theory.
Mach Rider seems to fit the weapon toy Sakurai was using for references.
I believe.
 

Luke_wal

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,255
I'll put my hat into the ring and say that the other Square rep is Zack Fair. Very easy echo, he's basically an outfit change. He requires no music and stage either. Plus it lines up with the other 3rd parties with 2 unique and 1 echo (Cloud, Geno and Zack).

Who's the other unique rep from Sega?

Also: Sora's moveset seems impossible to do well without Disney characters, or at least references, and I truly can't imagine that's happening in Smash Bros.
 

Xtortion

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,650
United States
There's always the possibility that Incineroar was in the original design doc but got scrapped at some point during development. He could also be a Spirits boss. Just saying "Incineroar is in the game" doesn't necessariy guarantee it unless he was identified relatively recently as playable.
 

L Thammy

Spacenoid
Member
Oct 25, 2017
50,046
The number of characters is hard to believe, but with Mach Rider, Chorus Kids, Banjo, Geno and Isaac, this would finally bring in the sort of picks that I actually want to see. I hope it's true, or at least something similar.
 

Deleted member 2791

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
19,054
Well, I'm the VG247 guy, and I'll say this outright, like -- somebody I trust who was right in the past (IE not Verge, but somebody else who told me about Simon and Isabelle before I think he'd mentioned them - though I don't follow him closely so not 100% on that) said Incineroar would be on the roster, and given they nailed Simon and Isabelle months in advance I'd feel inclined to trust their word for Incineroar - who obviously has been out there in the rumor world for ages. So that character not being on this list suggests to me the list is either wrong or incomplete, but as I also said over on Twitter - in the end, it could just as well be that I'm misinformed. That's the problem with back-room whispers and information, and why I'd never post that on the site in a news story - for something to be reported, I'd need multiple concrete sources, and I don't have them.

I quoted a poster earlier and said they were probably spot on when they said people are probably unsure on this really convincing leak because they have contradicting information from equally convincing places, because that's definitely where I stand. If I hadn't heard about Isabelle and Simon from the same person who told me about Incineroar, I'd just write the Incineroar claim off as wrong, but when somebody gets two right like that, obviously you're then inclined to trust them on the third go around.

I really hope this is true, though, it'd be cool as hell, especially Banjo - and I'd hope that'd mean Nintendo & MS were talking to potentially look at doing some Minecraft content as DLC.

Props to you for your super professionnal stance on this.
 

Wil Grieve

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,079
There is no evidence suggesting this is fake, but a number of people who typically have access to inside info (Imran, GameXplain guys, Liam Robertson) are expressing some doubt about this being real, which suggests they might have heard some contradictory info. Nobody has outright come and said anything contradicting this but them doubting it is enough to cast a bit of doubt for me at least.



This is the same thing that happened for Mario + Rabbids though. And that turned out to be quite real.

Liam "Shovel Knight is without a doubt in Smash 4" Robertson
 

FleenerW

Member
Oct 25, 2017
130
Tinfoil hat theory: Incineroar has been Nintendo & Microsoft's internal codename for Banjo-Kazooie as a red herring.
 

Phendrift

Member
Oct 25, 2017
32,303
Incineroar could truly be the Chrom of this cycle.

Also this is the first time since verg we actually had someone reliable come out and say Incineroar so thank you APZonerunner ! This helps a lot with trying to put the bigger picture together.
 

RochHoch

One Winged Slayer
Member
May 22, 2018
18,918
People joked about Inceniroar being the new Chrom, but the likelihood of that happening basically just skyrocketed.
 
OP
OP
ResetGreyWolf

ResetGreyWolf

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,428

giphy.gif
 

Renfran

Alt Account
Banned
Aug 28, 2018
3,325
There's always the possibility that Incineroar was in the original design doc but got scrapped at some point during development. He could also be a Spirits boss. Just saying "Incineroar is in the game" doesn't necessariy guarantee it unless he was identified relatively recently as playable.

Definitely but you have to respect the other side too. It's a possibility Incineror is an actual character on the roster and that's why insiders know this leak is fake. There's no way to prove otherwise and both sides are equally compelling. People need to chill out and take it easy. Seeing a lot of arguments here for no reason.
 

Platy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
27,703
Brazil
Remember the fake NX ? People could put lots of energy and time in those things. Personally I don't find this credible, the characters just make much sense to me.

Banjo and Geno seem like fanboys requests

Ken and Shadow seem odd, there are better candidate in the respective franchises.

Chorus Kid ? Isaac ? Mach Rider ? Come one now.

#teamfakenews

Geno fits the mii skin pattern
Chorus Kid was cut from smash 4
Ken and Shadow are literall pallete swaps. Easiest 5 minutes they got.

Isaac has the rathalos screen and how he is nowhere to be seen as an AT so far

Banjo has the

 

ShinobiBk

One Winged Slayer
Member
Dec 28, 2017
10,121
Who's the other unique rep from Sega?

Also: Sora's moveset seems impossible to do well without Disney characters, or at least references, and I truly can't imagine that's happening in Smash Bros.
Bayonetta is the other SEGA character


Hopefully Sakurai can get over himself and properly implement the Disney characters into Sora's moveset. Not having them there would be a disservice to the character and franchise. Also Roxas echo of course
 

Deleted member 8791

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 26, 2017
6,383
Well, I'm the VG247 guy, and I'll say this outright, like -- somebody I trust who was right in the past (IE not Verge, but somebody else who told me about Simon and Isabelle before I think he'd mentioned them - though I don't follow him closely so not 100% on that) said Incineroar would be on the roster, and given they nailed Simon and Isabelle months in advance I'd feel inclined to trust their word for Incineroar - who obviously has been out there in the rumor world for ages. So that character not being on this list suggests to me the list is either wrong or incomplete, but as I also said over on Twitter - in the end, it could just as well be that I'm misinformed. That's the problem with back-room whispers and information, and why I'd never post that on the site in a news story - for something to be reported, I'd need multiple concrete sources, and I don't have them.

I quoted a poster earlier and said they were probably spot on when they said people are probably unsure on this really convincing leak because they have contradicting information from equally convincing places, because that's definitely where I stand. If I hadn't heard about Isabelle and Simon from the same person who told me about Incineroar, I'd just write the Incineroar claim off as wrong, but when somebody gets two right like that, obviously you're then inclined to trust them on the third go around.

I really hope this is true, though, it'd be cool as hell, especially Banjo - and I'd hope that'd mean Nintendo & MS were talking to potentially look at doing some Minecraft content as DLC.
I was just going to talk about Incineroar in this context. Like, the problem with some insiders not playing ball with why they think certain things is that we have to guess the info. What if they've heard the same info as Vergeben, but they got it from same source, that turn up to be wrong? Then they're not adding any credibility to Incineroar being in, so to say.

Basically, just want to talk a bit about why insiders being vague means little to me. I still don't believe this leak (hard to believe any leak until info starts getting confirmed) at this stage and if they're not gonna bother deconfirming it then it's pretty meaningless.
 

Lord Azrael

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,976
Because someone has clearly risked their career doing it. Regardless of if it's real, this dude's gonna have a really hard time working on ad campaigns after this.
You pretty much made an argument for the opposing side. The fact that it's so risky makes it less likely that someone would do it, and if it's fake they have nothing to lose.
 

Chaosblade

Resettlement Advisor
Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,596
So no ARMS or Xeno 2 characters? :(

Xenoblade 2 didn't even exist in any meaningful capacity when the characters were decided for Ultimate. It was never going to be represented unless it came via DLC.

Only thing about this leak that seems off to me is the lack of any new Pokemon. Pokemon is clearly Nintendo's biggest or second biggest franchise, not getting a new character would be genuinely surprising.
 
Jul 20, 2018
2,684
I'm sure this was already pointed out but Isaac's position on the poster doesn't make any sense. He shifts everyone else on his plane to the left, whereas everyone else is being patched into holes(like how they did it the last two smash directs). It wouldn't make sense to alter the art that much to give him such importance.

The previous characters weren't placed in existing holes. Other characters were moved to make room for them.

The way the art is being done here makes it easy to move them around. It's not all hand drawn as one piece, they just treat the characters as stickers and put them wherever they like.
 
Nov 1, 2017
655
Having this many characters left would actually make sense if that ridiculous rumour of having 2 directs next month ended up true.

Banjo being announced after a hypothetical N64 mini reveal in a general direct just makes sense
 

APZonerunner

Features Editor at VG247.com
Verified
Oct 28, 2017
1,726
England
I was just going to talk about Incineroar in this context. Like, the problem with some insiders not playing ball with why they think certain things is that we have to guess the info. What if they've heard the same info as Vergeben, but they got it from same source, that turn up to be wrong? Then they're not adding any credibility to Incineroar being in, so to say.

Basically, just want to talk a bit about why insiders being vague means little to me. I still don't believe this leak (hard to believe any leak until info starts getting confirmed) at this stage and if they're not gonna bother deconfirming it then it's pretty meaningless.

You're dead right to think if somebody is being vague it's probably best just to take it as slightly informed speculation rather than any confirmation, because at the end of the day with a lot of leaks like this you've got people skating on super thin ice rumors from super shaky sources, and that's why a lot of people won't put up and put it down in writing or video in a more formal manner. I firmly believe out there in the 'insider space' or whatever the full roster is out there, but it's mixed in with a bunch of BS as well.

This is why none of this roster stuff has ever been reported on big sites, too, because nobody can actually verify anything, so anywhere with a high editorial standard on leaks and rumors can't get it off the ground. Somebody mentioned Pokemon Stars in this thread, mind, and that's a different sort of scenario - you know when a site like Eurogamer writes a quality report like that it has been double or triple-sourced and checked over multiple times. Nobody can do that with this Smash stuff, I don't think, so it's a bit of a crapshoot.
 

Lunar15

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,647
I'd almost say not having incineroar would make this more credible. It otherwise has a lot of rumored/requested characters, why would you leave Incineroar out intentionally if your goal was to line up with expectations?
 

ZeldaGalaxy94

The Fallen
Nov 6, 2017
2,577
Sweden
Mach Rider, I remember his trophy in Melee as if it were from yesterday.

His trophy was one of coolest ones with his motorcycle with weapons.
Almost wanted him as a figure when I played Melee in my childhood.

But I NEVER thought he would have a comeback in Smash as a vehicle-based(?) fighter!

Now I may understand the love for Geno, BUT Geno IS still a side-character from ONE game, while Mach Rider is the MAIN-character from ONE game and that is a BIG different.

Between Mach Rider or Exicte Bike (Rider), MR does sound cooler and the fighter possiblity are greater with him for he had not only a motorcycle but weapons too and being from the "future" helps a lot too with weirder stuff like jumping or his Final Smash
 
Aug 29, 2018
1,089
If people act mad at some insiders it's because they refuse to give any kind of reasoning why they believe what they do. I understand you have sources to protect but if you can't even indicate even 1% why you think something then it's probably best to stay quiet.

Or not? I mean I am glad he said something so that the more logical of us can temper our expectations. You are right though going forward maybe he shouldn't if he doesn't want a lot of unwarranted abuse. He doesn't work at Nintendo, he isn't going to be 100% positive, but clearly has heard whispers indicating this is unlikely. He also isn't some random on the internet who might be looking for 10 minutes of fame, he works in the gaming industry and is just saying this as a heads up, has a career to protect so of course he is going to say as little as possible as to the reasons which might be actual information Nintendo doesn't want getting out

People just shouldn't get upset with him, no excuses.
 

DNAbro

Member
Oct 25, 2017
25,928
Kind of weird but annoying that multiple people are saying this is wrong/incomplete but all refuse to say what they heard. Like do you all have the same source or something?
 

Deleted member 8791

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 26, 2017
6,383
You're dead right to think if somebody is being vague it's probably best just to take it as slightly informed speculation rather than any confirmation, because at the end of the day with a lot of leaks like this you've got people skating on super thin ice rumors from super shaky sources, and that's why a lot of people won't put up and put it down in writing or video in a more formal manner. I firmly believe out there in the 'insider space' or whatever the full roster is out there, but it's mixed in with a bunch of BS as well.

This is why none of this roster stuff has ever been reported on big sites, too, because nobody can actually verify anything, so anywhere with a high editorial standard on leaks and rumors can't get it off the ground. Somebody mentioned Pokemon Stars in this thread, mind, and that's a different sort of scenario - you know when a site like Eurogamer writes a quality report like that it has been double or triple-sourced and checked over multiple times. Nobody can do that with this Smash stuff, I don't think, so it's a bit of a crapshoot.
Thanks for the reply :) appreciate to hear your take on this.

Kind of weird but annoying that multiple people are saying this is wrong/incomplete but all refuse to say what they heard. Like do you all have the same source or something?

Honestly without knowing any details at all they might as well be on the Vergeben train with maybe some source of their own who also says Incineroar which might be because they're on that train too, like who knows? Not us at least since we're just told how things are.
 

Wil Grieve

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,079
There's always the possibility that Incineroar was in the original design doc but got scrapped at some point during development. He could also be a Spirits boss. Just saying "Incineroar is in the game" doesn't necessariy guarantee it unless he was identified relatively recently as playable.

I actually have no problem with Incineroar as a Spirits boss. He is a heel wrestler
 
Status
Not open for further replies.