• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

Which team are you in, hooman? (NOTE: Vote-changing disabled!)

  • #TeamReal

    Votes: 2,046 67.7%
  • #TeamFake

    Votes: 978 32.3%

  • Total voters
    3,024
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

night814

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 29, 2017
15,039
Pennsylvania
Im not sure if the VG247 editor (i guess he was an editor?) has leaked something before. But suddenly theres numerous people saying, more or less, that this leak its probably a fake indeed, but without any sort of prove that at least as convincing as the leak itself. More noticeably, the crew of GameXplain, VG247 guy, the ERA user whos nickname i don't remember right now, Liam Robertson, now this tech guy whos tweets are in this thread, and etc. Kinda weird. All this people knew this was fake the whole time? Then why is the leak so freakin convincing?
This is where I'm at, the insiders are all using second hand info from nameless sources that can be very accurate to dubious at best. This leak actually has pics and very detailed info.
 

Starphanluke

▲ Legend ▲
Member
Nov 15, 2017
7,333
God damn, I'm torn. It'd be really easy to say "yeah, it's fake" and move on with my life, but something in the way this all has gone down has me believing in my gut that it's real.

And I honestly, truly think most of the supposed insiders don't really know. That's why we're not getting any definitive answers.
 
Nov 18, 2017
1,273
oh, sakurai doing a mach rider reboot, cool

I hope sakurai takes the next five years off, preferably surrounded by his nearest and dearest. Hopping from fancy island resort to fancy island resort, and as word gets out that this man is responsible for Super Smash Bros, all him & his families meals & drinks are free. Anything except the utmost care & attention paid to this man during this time is completely unnaceptable.

And then once the island lifestyle of rest & relaxation has finally work thin, then I want him to come back & reboot Mach Rider. And only if it's announced when it's basically already finished so that he never has to stress to hit a deadline again!
 
Oct 27, 2017
5,364
I really do hope we get a Direct announcement soon though, feels like there's still so much to still know about the game and yet it releases in about a month.
 

boontobias

Avenger
Apr 14, 2018
9,538
At this point, these leakers need to stop messing around and say what they know. LOL guy has picture proof, you dont so stop being mysterious
 

Comet

Member
Oct 27, 2017
1,532
uniqueness of moveset. Knuckles glide and tails fly. Shadow is a better skin for sonic

I mean it's not really that hard to understand. He blows, but he's also super easy to create. Same reason we got Dark Pit over somebody much more interesting like Hades.

We still haven't seen Tails at least. Maybe he'll make it in as DLC some day.

Shadow is an easier echo/clone to make than Knuckles or Tails

It's evil Sonic, echo's don't get much easier than that.


You guys are right, I wasn't even thinking about the quick dev turnaround of a clone vs. a unique moveset. I lost sight of the fact that we're at 60 characters and expecting unique movesets at this point is wishful thinking (for characters that can be easily cloned).
 

Jawmuncher

Crisis Dino
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
38,473
Ibis Island
Have we reached a point where we're expecting 9 more characters

I think people are missing that things shift in dev. Between this and other rumors/leaks/insiders.
Other characters thought to be a lock could now be DLC instead. I'd say the current image would make for a good final reveal. However more than that would be pushing it.

However there's also Sakurai just being Humble to consider. Dude gives us the world and still thinks it isn't enough.
 

RailWays

One Winged Slayer
Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
15,673
Much of this is really smart, I think. I don't think any one given 'insider' knows the whole roster, but different people know different bits and pieces, but because they all contradict each other, they all think the others are wrong. Much of this leak is really convincing, in particular how it appears to have emerged, but people are hedging their bets. The attitude often taken to that is "well, say what you know or get fucked, coward!!" but honestly speaking out is imo even more frightening just because of how people react if you're wrong. It drives people away from revealing much of anything beyond hints. Well, that and worries about exposing their source.
This is a good assessment
 

APZonerunner

Features Editor at VG247.com
Verified
Oct 28, 2017
1,725
England
Im not sure if the VG247 editor (i guess he was an editor?) has leaked something before. But suddenly theres numerous people saying, more or less, that this leak its probably a fake indeed, but without any sort of prove that at least as convincing as the leak itself. More noticeably, the crew of GameXplain, VG247 guy, the ERA user whos nickname i don't remember right now, Liam Robertson, now this tech guy whos tweets are in this thread, and etc. Kinda weird. All this people knew this was fake the whole time? Then why is the leak so freakin convincing?

Well, I'm the VG247 guy, and I'll say this outright, like -- somebody I trust who was right in the past (IE not Verge, but somebody else who told me about Simon and Isabelle before I think he'd mentioned them - though I don't follow him closely so not 100% on that) said Incineroar would be on the roster, and given they nailed Simon and Isabelle months in advance I'd feel inclined to trust their word for Incineroar - who obviously has been out there in the rumor world for ages. So that character not being on this list suggests to me the list is either wrong or incomplete, but as I also said over on Twitter - in the end, it could just as well be that I'm misinformed. That's the problem with back-room whispers and information, and why I'd never post that on the site in a news story - for something to be reported, I'd need multiple concrete sources, and I don't have them.

I quoted a poster earlier and said they were probably spot on when they said people are probably unsure on this really convincing leak because they have contradicting information from equally convincing places, because that's definitely where I stand. If I hadn't heard about Isabelle and Simon from the same person who told me about Incineroar, I'd just write the Incineroar claim off as wrong, but when somebody gets two right like that, obviously you're then inclined to trust them on the third go around.

I really hope this is true, though, it'd be cool as hell, especially Banjo - and I'd hope that'd mean Nintendo & MS were talking to potentially look at doing some Minecraft content as DLC.
 

ShinobiBk

One Winged Slayer
Member
Dec 28, 2017
10,121
I don't think Imran is fucking with us, and I think he gives a very full idea of what's happening here:
-Insiders do not know the full roster
-Insiders either know a character missing from this list, or someone on this list who is not in the game
-Insiders don't want to comment, because this leak doesn't scream fake-it just doesn't line up completely with info they trust

If I had to guess what info the insiders have that we don't, it's either:
-A Pokemon is supposed to be in the game, and it's not on this list
-Geno isn't in the game, and he's on this list
-A Square, Namco or Capcom rep is supposed to be in the game, it's not on this list
Geno is in, not sure why you singled him out, he's very likely if they're willing to get Banjo
I'll put my hat into the ring and say that the other Square rep is Zack Fair. Very easy echo, he's basically an outfit change. He requires no music and stage either. Plus it lines up with the other 3rd parties with 2 unique and 1 echo (Cloud, Geno and Zack).
Bandai left in the cold though. Poor guys developing the game and they can't even get their own characters in
 

Deleted member 24540

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 29, 2017
1,599
Those characters sound too good to be true... so it probably is true? lol

A serious attempt at a fake leak would have tried to make the newcomers seem more "realistic" perhaps.

Isaac is an odd choice, since there is nothing suggesting Camelot being capable of making a Switch-tier Golden Sun sequel. On the other hand, the franchise would bring good music, stage themes, etc. so from that perspective it makes sense.
 

Luke_wal

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,255
I want the record to show that I very much believe this leak, but it also looks like they've added more space between Greninja and Snake, in addition to the Isaac space. It's not a crazy amount of space, and I think pointing at any extra space as evidence of a fake seems arbitrary to me.
 

Kirbivore

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,925
Wasnt there talk of Dixie not making the cut in Brawl and to this day, still hasnt shown up?
 

Phendrift

Member
Oct 25, 2017
32,297
The other 3 had popped up numerous times in the past. Richter was definitely the one that caught people for a surprise though.
Really? I mean I knew we ALL thought DS was in because it was so obvious but I don't remember anyone chiming in about any of them. I do remember Ridley hints though.

Vergeben in particular didn't at least, and he's the most noteable smash leaker currently
 

Splendy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
105
So "insiders" that been wrong or constantly always give 50/50 responses should be taken credible for what reason? Yall tripping. Their job is not "insider"

Thats exactly what Im saying, this isn't their job and they certainly arent perfect and if they are wrong thats a fine thing to call out but if you don't look at this thread and see people showing their ass when it comes to video game leaks I dunno what to tell you.

Keep in mind I think Imran and most of the leakers are probably wrong here but that doesn't mean I have to be a dick about it and it's not like he hasn't been right in the past. We probably agree on the factuals here when it comes to the game itself
 

APZonerunner

Features Editor at VG247.com
Verified
Oct 28, 2017
1,725
England
Wasnt there talk of Dixie not making the cut in Brawl and to this day, still hasnt shown up?

Originally, Dixie was intended to be part of Diddie's move set as a tag character, like Ice Climbers but with an actual tag mechanic like in DKC. Not sure why they cut this - if it was a design problem, or tech, or just if they decided against it. But we know this as Sakurai revealed this after Brawl's release in a magazine column. The issue now is the question of if Dixie is actually relevant enough to be a whole original character, and if not if she'd really be convincing/correct as a Diddy echo, as they're clearly now not gonna change the Diddy move set they eventually went with.
 

rpm

Into the Woods
The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
12,356
Parts Unknown
Those characters sound too good to be true... so it probably is true? lol

A serious attempt at a fake leak would have tried to make the newcomers seem more "realistic" perhaps.

Isaac is an odd choice, since there is nothing suggesting Camelot being capable of making a Switch-tier Golden Sun sequel. On the other hand, the franchise would bring good music, stage themes, etc. so from that perspective it makes sense.
I'm not sure what newcomers you think are unrealistic
Not every newcomer has to be promoting a game. There probably isn't a new Golden Sun coming anytime soon.
 
OP
OP
ResetGreyWolf

ResetGreyWolf

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,427
No insider hinted at Richter, Dark Samus, Chrom OR K.Rool from what I recall.

tumblr_lesewbCi2J1qaqaiy.gif


Yep

Another reason why we shouldn't believe leakers/insiders have the full picture of what characters are in
 

Starphanluke

▲ Legend ▲
Member
Nov 15, 2017
7,333
Anybody mind naming an insider who knew Richter was in?

Maybe I'm crazy, but I feel like there haven't really been many insiders for Smash Ultimate? Certainly not with the same credibility there was for Smash 4. I feel like most of the newcomers thus far have been complete surprises, save for Isabelle, who we only got hints towards just before the direct. And Simon was leaked by Nintendo themselves.

There really haven't been reliable insiders this go-around.
 

Zen Hero

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,633
I find this leak hard to believe, personally.

Would we really get 7 more characters in under 2 months? That seems absurdly high. There's not even enough time to advertise them all, some would just be immediately forgotten about.
 

Deleted member 8791

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 26, 2017
6,383
People are setting themselves up to disappointment, actively getting mad about gaming journalists doubting this leak just shows how emotionally invested they are already in it when it is probably fake
If people act mad at some insiders it's because they refuse to give any kind of reasoning why they believe what they do. I understand you have sources to protect but if you can't even indicate even 1% why you think something then it's probably best to stay quiet.
 

PSqueak

Member
Oct 25, 2017
12,464
Wasnt there talk of Dixie not making the cut in Brawl and to this day, still hasnt shown up?

Legend is, Dixie in brawl was going to be partnered with Diddy in an Ice-climber style, but she was cut due to time constraints.

Then 3DS and Wii U had to cut transforming characters and the Iceclimbers, so it wouldn't make sense to add the Dixie elements to Diddy.

By Ultimate Diddy was established enough that it wouldnt make sense to turn him into a team character.
 

ned_ballad

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
48,232
Rochester, New York
Well, I'm the VG247 guy, and I'll say this outright, like -- somebody I trust who was right in the past (IE not Verge, but somebody else who told me about Simon and Isabelle before I think he'd mentioned them - though I don't follow him closely so not 100% on that) said Incineroar would be on the roster, and given they nailed Simon and Isabelle months in advance I'd feel inclined to trust their word for Incineroar - who obviously has been out there in the rumor world for ages. So that character not being on this list suggests to me the list is either wrong or incomplete, but as I also said over on Twitter - in the end, it could just as well be that I'm misinformed. That's the problem with back-room whispers and information, and why I'd never post that on the site in a news story - for something to be reported, I'd need multiple concrete sources, and I don't have them.

I quoted a poster earlier and said they were probably spot on when they said people are probably unsure on this really convincing leak because they have contradicting information from equally convincing places, because that's definitely where I stand. If I hadn't heard about Isabelle and Simon from the same person who told me about Incineroar, I'd just write the Incineroar claim off as wrong, but when somebody gets two right like that, obviously you're then inclined to trust them on the third go around.

I really hope this is true, though, it'd be cool as hell, especially Banjo - and I'd hope that'd mean Nintendo & MS were talking to potentially look at doing some Minecraft content as DLC.
I appreciate this post.

I think Incineroar is likely messing up a bunch of insiders who have reliable info on him being in, making this leak really strange since it lacks him.
 

Maple

Member
Oct 27, 2017
11,729
Why do people believe this rumor is credible ?

- Detailed artwork, which is quite different and much harder than loading up Photoshop and Aftereffects and faking a leak.
- Name associated with the leak.
- That name is a confirmed individual working with a company that has been confirmed to work for Bandai Namco on promotional/advertising/marketing material.
- 4Chan rumor from a month ago called all 7 characters in this leak.

Like I said, if it's fake, you have to believe that this person working at an advertising company working for Bandai Namco decided to go through 4chan Smash leaks to find one to make detailed art for. Or you have to believe that it's the same guy, and he's been planning this leak and working this leak for over a month.

But again...there's a name here. Anyone doing this to cause an uproar and troll people wouldn't have linked their name, company, or something as irrelevant to the topic at hand as Grinch art.
 
OP
OP
ResetGreyWolf

ResetGreyWolf

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,427
Maybe I'm crazy, but I feel like there haven't really been many insiders for Smash Ultimate? Certainly not with the same credibility there was for Smash 4. I feel like most of the newcomers thus far have been complete surprises, save for Isabelle, who we only got hints towards just before the direct. And Simon was leaked by Nintendo themselves.

There really haven't been reliable insiders this go-around.

There's a crapton of alleged insiders but not that many proven ones. Verg is the most popular, I think. Loz was another infamous one but I think he's dead and buried now
 

Deleted member 35598

User requested account closure
Banned
Dec 7, 2017
6,350
Spain
The "sweet goodness man, why would you go these lengths for the sake of a fake?!" factor.

Remember the fake NX ? People could put lots of energy and time in those things. Personally I don't find this credible, the characters just make much sense to me.

Banjo and Geno seem like fanboys requests

Ken and Shadow seem odd, there are better candidate in the respective franchises.

Chorus Kid ? Isaac ? Mach Rider ? Come one now.

#teamfakenews
 
Status
Not open for further replies.