• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

gcwy

Member
Oct 27, 2017
8,685
Houston, TX
People are talking about just the month of September. Unit wise Xbox was down form Sep 2017.

I'm pretty sure we all know that Xbox has been up this year compared to 2017.
Xbox is down in September and Xbox overall is only increase in comparison to last year (2017 which is the worst xbox one performance ever) if I'm not mistaken.
Thanks for the clarification, guys. I'll admit, I was wrong. But I still think it's impressive for what is, essentially, a premium console doing so well this generation. And that goes for Pro too. There were a lot of naysayers when the first rumors of these mid-gen upgrades started spreading around. I'm just glad they were proven wrong.
 

Deleted member 9746

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 26, 2017
5,406
Dragon Quest XI at #11. Best JRPG released this year. I'll dance to that!

5FrLwsI.gif
 

Deleted member 5535

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
13,656
Nintendo has people conditioned with their boneheaded practices for many years. It's not quite as easy on the other platforms when there's a crap load of competition. If say spiderman was $60 a year from now people would simply buy other stuff.

There's a quite big paradox on this post. Nintendo conditioned the users but they're bonehead because of that when it's clear the contrary as the masses accepted it.

Is it safe to assume that Octopath Traveler outsold DQXI in the US? If it did, is that down to stiffer competition or marketing?

Yes, probably is. Not WW tho, since japanese sales of DQ11 are above 3 million and Octopath have 1 million WW (which includes japan in that case).
 

travisbickle

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
2,953
Wow when you think about it, PlayStations best game was not even developed by a first party. Is this a first for a platform?

What do you mean? FIFA, Fortnite, Minecraft, COD? I don't know which is the best out of those but I'm sure third parties have been the best sellers for years on PlayStation.

Or do you mean exclusive game not developed internally? GTA 3 maybe.
 
Mar 17, 2018
2,927
Good decision Matt I don't blame in the slightest. As a liberal and a Sony fan you would think this site would be my dream site but it's gotten so bad I don't bother coming here anymore.

I mean nothing to the site but hopefully with more people like you leaving it clean up some. Anyway, good luck!

As a liberal and a Sony fan what are you alluding to? I don't post everyday so no idea. I know these threads about sales get really weird though.
 

Derrick01

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
7,289
There is nothing "boneheaded" about it.

I guess since it works it's not. It's a really shitty practice though, one I refuse to go along with if I don't think the game is worth $60. It's why I'm still waiting on mario kart, DK, bayo 2, octopath and probably a few others that escape my memory at the moment.
 

goldenpp73

Banned
Dec 5, 2017
2,144
Ah so the X is selling well, good it's the best console ever made. And that's coming from a man who owns all consoles.

If you're talking purely hardware, I'd say the Gamecube takes the cake there as you certainly can't be talking about its game lineup specifically. Gamecube was a perfectly balanced system at an amazing price, though the X is a nice piece of kit and well rounded, it's just expensive.
 

rhandino

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,613
I am so glad Odyssey did so well after people said that it was going to crash and burn because it looked too similar to Origins, that it released a year after it and becuase the release date being in the middle of RDR2 and Spider-Man

Talent always win
uWy1o.gif


Cant wait to finish the game and then the Season Pass content~
 

Deleted member 5535

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
13,656
The Pokemon games are developed by Game Freak.

As are Kirby, Smash Bros, Mario Tennis, Fire Emblem and other titles which are made by third party developers.

And as far as Pokémon, Nintendo is the publisher of the series on consoles along side TPC (which do everything on other media, including mobile). Beyond that, Nintendo have the copyright of it along Gamefreak and Creatures and also are the owners of the trademark.
 

Paxton25

Member
May 9, 2018
1,899
I am so glad Odyssey did so well after people said that it was going to crash and burn because it looked too similar to Origins, that it released a year after it and becuase the release date being in the middle of RDR2 and Spider-Man

Talent always win
uWy1o.gif


Cant wait to finish the game and then the Season Pass content~
Worth a buy then ? I'm half way thro origins and I'm in two minds whether to buy this...
 

Jom

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,490
I guess since it works it's not. It's a really shitty practice though, one I refuse to go along with if I don't think the game is worth $60. It's why I'm still waiting on mario kart, DK, bayo 2, octopath and probably a few others that escape my memory at the moment.
Eh they have a fiduciary duty to make as much profit as possible. They literally are obligated to sell those games at $60 if the market will bear it.

You need to direct your anger at people who buy those games at $60 even after the games are a year old. I mean, I would love to buy Nintendo games at $19.99 3 months after release as well, but as long as loads of people are happy paying $59.99, that's not gonna happen.
 

Memento

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
8,129
Was Halo 3 a top selling game? Wowsers

Nintendo at least had a stake in TPC, are they still considered third party?

Halo 3 is their most sucessfull exclusive game ever IIRC. Maybe Kinect Sports sold more? I am not sure. In any case that one was heavily bundled in the kinect craze era.
 

Skeeter49

I wish Jim Ryan would eat me
Member
Oct 25, 2017
17,297
Can we all agree that Venom Jane better be a thing in Spiderman 2?

Note: I have not played Spiderman 1, so if there is any spoilers alluding to Venom Jane, I had no clue, and just want her to be a thing.
 
Mar 17, 2018
2,927
Eh they have a fiduciary duty to make as much profit as possible. They literally are obligated to sell those games at $60 if the market will bear it.

You need to direct your anger at people who buy those games at $60 even after the games are a year old. I mean, I would love to buy Nintendo games at $19.99 3 months after release as well, but as long as loads of people are happy paying $59.99, that's not gonna happen.
Still, if Nintendo wants to hit the masses and stay there things will have to change at some point even if only a little. They are selling to a 20m audience right now. It's nothing compared to Sony, who has to accommodate people of all economic backgrounds. The easiest way to do that is sales because there are just too many games.
 

Deleted member 43

Account closed at user request
Banned
Oct 24, 2017
9,271
I guess since it works it's not. It's a really shitty practice though, one I refuse to go along with if I don't think the game is worth $60. It's why I'm still waiting on mario kart, DK, bayo 2, octopath and probably a few others that escape my memory at the moment.
You are absolutely doing the absolute right thing not paying more for a product than you think it's worth.
 

rhandino

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,613
Worth a buy then ? I'm half way thro origins and I'm in two minds whether to buy this...
Is a more refined Origins.

There are a lot of elements in common but the story is better told, a system that evokes the AC1 feeling of hunting a target by gathering info in the world and better sidequests (from a design to writing)

80 hours in and still having tons of fun so far...
 

Keikaku

Member
Oct 27, 2017
4,770
Halo 3 is their most sucessfull exclusive game ever IIRC. Maybe Kinect Sports sold more? I am not sure. In any case that one was heavily bundled in the kinect craze era.
Yeah IIRC it was "the biggest entertainment launch ever" or something. I even got that $150 cat helmet edition because all other versions were sold out lol.
 

Memento

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
8,129
On a side note, I hope Forza Horizon 4 sucess makes Sony aware of the audience for arcadeish open world racing games. Maybe they can greenlight a Gran Turismo Open World at Japan, please?
 

Deleted member 873

User requested account closure
Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,463
I wish I could be happy about my favorite RPG series being at number 11, but I'm just thinking that it didn't get enough flack for Sugiyama's (already known for years) politics.
 

Poimandres

Member
Oct 26, 2017
6,872
Thanks for the clarification, guys. I'll admit, I was wrong. But I still think it's impressive for what is, essentially, a premium console doing so well this generation. And that goes for Pro too. There were a lot of naysayers when the first rumors of these mid-gen upgrades started spreading around. I'm just glad they were proven wrong.

I'm not sure how I feel about mid-gen console updates selling well to be honest. I guess the PS3 and 360 were starting to get very haggard by the end of their run with many 2013ish releases struggling to hit/maintain 30fps, so these refreshes give a bit more gas in the tank. But on the other hand, if something like the X becomes fairly dominant are dev's going to start phoning it in on the base console? I'm really in two minds about the whole thing.
 

El Pescado

Member
Oct 26, 2017
1,922
I'm so thankful that this made the list. More dragon quest for the west makes me teary eyed!

I mean, do we even know what Square-Enix expected? I'm reminded of times in the past where Capcom games would sell millions of copies and then we'd find out they expected to sell like 3x as much from financial reports. :/
 

SweetNicole

The Old Guard
Member
Oct 24, 2017
6,542
Harassment in any way, shape or form is not acceptable on ResetEra. The conduct exhibited by many in this thread is shameful and appalling.

We will be reining in NPD threads with harsher moderation going forward. If you cannot engage in the bare modicum of decency when discussing sales in the gaming industry, you will be removed.



This thread is temporarily locked so everyone can read and understand this mod post before discussion continues. We are also cleaning up outstanding reports and issuing bans where appropriate. The thread will be
unlocked once that has been resolved.
 
Last edited: