Stanton is fine. He had a poor series, but he was never going to be the dependable Jeter like player in the postseason. He is going to be Arod. Which means he is going to be terrible in most postseasons but will get hot at least once and will win you a world series that year. He pretty much carried the yankees for a good 5 weeks while Judge was out only to fall into a slump after those 5 weeks. My brother pointed out how he played like 150 or so games straight. he is a big guy and needs some rest days. DHing isnt enough. you need to give him the entire day off.
I have to agree with michael kay here. how you dont take out CC and Severino early on is beyond me. this is not your average season game. And bringing in Lance fucking Lynn instead of betances or other relief pitchers? Come on. Look at Alex Cora, brought in Chris Sale to get to his closer because he knows his bullpen is shit. Boone's bullpen is amazing.
Also, and Kay didnt talk about this, but i have been saying this the whole year, the lineup is all wrong. You cant have Judge hitting at second. He needs to be hitting 3rd or cleanup. It's crazy how often Judge came up with no one on. And I get it, Torres and Gardner were basically his leadoff guys in the 9th hole but then why did Judge always appear to be starting an inning? i would love to get some numbers here.
Not starting Andujar was weird. He was your best hitter all year. his defense is shoddy but he won you dozens of games with his offense. Torres was the most clutch hitter in their lineup and he was hitting 9th. I get the idea that you need your entire lineup to be potent from top to bottom, but you cant have your Judges and Stantons hit with no one on.
I say start Torres, then Andujar at 2nd then judge and Stanton. screw the lefty righty balance. Stanton, Judge and Sanchez need to hit back to back to back to make sure pitchers dont pitch around them. Stanton isnt as selective as Judge so have him hit in front of judge to make sure he gets more pitches to hit. dont have freaking didi or hicks following them. they are decent hitters at best.
As good as Voit was, it was pretty obvious they had found him out by the end of the series. He is a great hitter and will be a great asset but he should be hitting behind proven guys like Judge, Stanton and Sanchez.
I am not asking for Boone to get fired or Stanton to get traded. Boone did put his faith in Andujar and Torres early on in the season and deserves to be commended for that. Going with Luke voit when he got hot instead of wasting at bats on Bird was also a good decision.