• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.

Do you think Incineroar still have a shot at making in Smash Bros as playable character?

  • Yes

    Votes: 375 55.7%
  • No

    Votes: 298 44.3%

  • Total voters
    673
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

Phizax

Member
Jul 11, 2018
877
United States
Hopping off of the Steve Train for a bit:

Has anyone noticed this bit in the AT section of the site?

FKIzbu6.png


None of the other AT's specify which series they're from. Just Zero.

Seeing as Zero is a pretty common name for video game characters, I wonder if there will be another Zero as an AT.
It's just because of the Zero enemy from Metroid, but in an ideal universe, it's because it's Dark Matter's Final Smash.
 

Pause

Member
Feb 22, 2018
1,278
Game and Watch is a bunch of random games. No one would have asked for it to be represented as a playable character. Sakurai, having far more talent then you guys seem to give him credit for, decided to combine them and thus make a character.

Same with WFT. No one asked for her and yet he made a character with what he had a created something great from it.

Captain Falcon appeared for 5 pages, acts a little cocky,and shot a guy. Maybe the transition from that to "Kamen Rider with flaming punches" is obvious to you but it sure isn't to me.
No one's saying Sakurai isn't talented, can we please stop pretending that anyone's saying this?

I'm saying Steve is a gigantically different issue than absolutely everything that is present in Smash, and that it simply isn't worth the effort anyway.

Game & Watch worked because he displays emotion through his actions, and he doesn't need full animation to work, because he only needs to snap from one from to another. That's not even an issue with hitboxes because of the way frames work. G&W is actually much easier to make than any other character, which is why he was a late addition to Melee. He also fits aesthetically because he is close enough to human to be cute, but not too close as to be uncanny.

Wii Fit Trainer is a character with a voice, and the most literal and exact human proportions imaginable. She was designed to be on screen at all times and is uniquely fun because of her mannerisms and her design idea. Nothing about her is comparable to Steve.

Captain Falcon, again, was a character in an instruction manual and in a comic, and he has a design that influences his character. He screams "brave tough guy." He also has the exact proportions used for prototype characters for Smash, and it's extremely easy to see how he can be a character separate from F-Zero's racing mechanics.

Not a single one of those characters has any meaningful similarity to the problem with making Steve work.
Claus as a unique fighter instead of Kumatora

truly disgusting
please let there still be hope for kumatora, at least as an echo

those are her moves. lucas stole her moves
 

Metto

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 27, 2017
12,108
Okay y'know what how bout this for a compromise. We get Banjo Kazooie first, then Steve.

Would rather have a Capcom situation where they choose the Nintendo centric one first then move on to the more popular franchise
 

Deleted member 46641

User requested account closure
Banned
Aug 12, 2018
3,494
My hospital blocks 4chan (justly so - recovering patients don't need to see that many slurs). Can someone copy paste the original post and put it here (minus any slurs if they're there)
 

ze_

Member
Oct 28, 2017
5,928
My hospital blocks 4chan (justly so - recovering patients don't need to see that many slurs). Can someone copy paste the original post and put it here (minus any slurs if they're there)
Here:
Bandana Waddle Dee (Kirby)
Incineroar (Pokemon) -
Skull Kid (Legend of Zelda)
Elma (Xenoblade)
Isaac (Golden Sun)
Geno (Mario RPG)
Shadow the Hedgehog (Sonic) **NOT AN ECHO FIGHTER**
Banjo Kazooie (Banjo Kazooie)
Sora (Kingdom Hearts) -
Saki (Sin & Punishment)
Klaus (Mother)

I want it all

Those aren't even new screenshots

That's cheating!
A-Exeggutor didn't have new screens either.
 

Gold Arsene

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
30,757
I literally said on the last page that you can make a playable fighter out of anything. That's not what I'm arguing here.

What I'm arguing is that characters like Wii Fit Trainer and Mr. Game & Watch are appealing choices because despite the fact that they aren't franchises you'd think fit into the parameters of being a fighting game, they are characters that have their actions and movesets defined by actual personality and character that is innate to their own games. Mr. Game & Watch embodies an insane level of charisma that come from it's charming and fun minigames that feature exaggerated poses and expressions. That kind of stuff is perfect for a fighting game because keyposes are the most important element a character can have to emphasize their attacks. Wii Fit Trainer is a character that tries to encourage players to be more proactive, and attempts to be encouraging in the process. That makes her a fun character to play with, because it feels like there's something extra to her presence when she's among all these other colorful characters.

That's what makes those characters so fun, not just their unique move sets, but because despite the fact that these are characters people don't necessarily think to add, they are characters that embody personality through their individual in-game actions. Sakurai has already gone into detail about how this is important to character inclusions in Smash - one of the most important things about a Smash character is that they need to evoke a semblance of personality and character, predominantly through their actions.

And with Steve there's just no frame of reference for that. You can make a "fun" moveset for this character, but people don't really play these things just for "fun movesets". If we start ignoring the importance of character, what we're left with is this.



No one's saying Sakurai isn't talented, can we please stop pretending that anyone's saying this?

I'm saying Steve is a gigantically different issue than absolutely everything that is present in Smash, and that it simply isn't worth the effort anyway.

Game & Watch worked because he displays emotion through his actions, and he doesn't need full animation to work, because he only needs to snap from one from to another. That's not even an issue with hitboxes because of the way frames work. G&W is actually much easier to make than any other character, which is why he was a late addition to Melee. He also fits aesthetically because he is close enough to human to be cute, but not too close as to be uncanny.

Wii Fit Trainer is a character with a voice, and the most literal and exact human proportions imaginable. She was designed to be on screen at all times and is uniquely fun because of her mannerisms and her design idea. Nothing about her is comparable to Steve.

Captain Falcon, again, was a character in an instruction manual and in a comic, and he has a design that influences his character. He screams "brave tough guy." He also has the exact proportions used for prototype characters for Smash, and it's extremely easy to see how he can be a character separate from F-Zero's racing mechanics.

Not a single one of those characters has any meaningful similarity to the problem with making Steve work.

please let there still be hope for kumatora, at least as an echo

those are her moves. lucas stole her moves

Whatever you two need to tell yourself to justify your hatred.

I don't want Steve but if anyone can make him interesting it's Sakurai. I'd find him a lot more interesting the Ridley do to move set potential but hey that's me.
 

r_n

Member
Oct 25, 2017
12,534
No it isn't. That screenshot has been around for awhile. It was in a press kit back when Moon was first announced
Wonder how many more of those we'll be seeing then. Maybe the shovel knight photo I thought was new wasfrom there too.

Do you have al ink to the press kit photos by the way. There was a ton of them and it will let use judge more harshly
 

Bard

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
12,413
Bandana Waddle Dee (Kirby)
Incineroar (Pokemon) -
Skull Kid (Legend of Zelda)
Elma (Xenoblade)
Isaac (Golden Sun)
Geno (Mario RPG)
Shadow the Hedgehog (Sonic) **NOT AN ECHO FIGHTER**
Banjo Kazooie (Banjo Kazooie)
Sora (Kingdom Hearts) -
Saki (Sin & Punishment)
Klaus (Mother)

I want it all

I wish this was true. Not happening sadly.
 

Kyzer

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,709
Lol @ mental backflips to attempt to rationalize salt at characters you don't like getting into smash
 

ze_

Member
Oct 28, 2017
5,928
What was that stuff about new assists I've been hearing? Is this that thread or elsewhere?
Yeah, same thread. It's in the second post there. Here's what they wrote:

New Echo Fighters:
Medusa over Palutena
Ken over Ryu
Octoling over Inkling
Dixie Kong over Diddy Kong
Black Shadow over Captain Falcon
Black Knight over Ike

In the upcoming direct, they reveal 4 new fighters, 2 new echo fighters, 2 new stages, 5 brand new assist trophies + 2 Pokemon, 4 brand new items new to smash in-game shop concept + new value of currency, buyable costumes and palettes, and a teaser for spirits.
It'll open with Shulk, Link, and Marth fighting Rathalos in a cinematic cutscene link and marth get destroyed, and shulk was barely holding on until Elma shows up. Midway it transitions to Elma getting beat up, similar to how richter was revealed; isaac comes in and lends a hand before transitioning into his very own gameplay sequence. It also showcases a transitioning stage where it seems to be golden sun based, unsure whether it is Mars Lighthouse or another stage. Sakurai comes in and talks about the 2 new characters and their inclusion into smash brothers, and showcases some brand new assist trophies and 2 new pokemon;
-Drampa (Pokemon)
-Chandelure ( Pokemon)
-Saturos (Golden Sun) Two Volcanoes Appear and it rains exploding meteors for a short period of time.
-King Boo (Mario) Swaps percentages around between fighters.
-Poochy (Yoshi) Digs underground and finds useful items, similar to how isablle used to be
-Urbosa (Legend of Zelda BOTW) Hovers around you, when hit while blocking they're now stunned with a large lightning bolt.
-Creeper (Minecraft) If within range walks up and kamikaze's if you walk out of range before hand, it'll stay and continue to attempt to follow you.
 

Kyzer

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,709
Sakurai could announce a wooden desk with a glass and no coaster for smash and I'd trust him to make it work, I'm comfy af
 
Last edited:

TheDinoman

Member
Oct 25, 2017
17,092
DnbBPM2V4AIzWFJ.jpg


Imagine going back in time and posting this before 2018

Everyone would think Shovel Knight was an actual player character lol
 

Deleted member 23212

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 28, 2017
11,225
OK, so to be honest knowing that I didn't miss much makes me realize just how much time I waste coming here for hours a day, since so little news actually tends to come up :-D
 

r_n

Member
Oct 25, 2017
12,534
Man I think all these stage photos are just goign to be used on the blog. All the New Donk City ones are exactly the ones put on the blog like a week or two later.
 

r_n

Member
Oct 25, 2017
12,534
GePzGCD.jpg
rOr0Sdw.jpg


These two remain my favorite in the whole press kit. Let's create the same exact scenario twice but in different parts of the stage and Pit facing the other way

e: meant to preview, not double post. oops
 

louisacommie

Member
Oct 25, 2017
17,561
New Jersey
Game and Watch is a bunch of random games. No one would have asked for it to be represented as a playable character. Sakurai, having far more talent then you guys seem to give him credit for, decided to combine them and thus make a character.

Same with WFT. No one asked for her and yet he made a character with what he had a created something great from it.

Captain Falcon appeared for 5 pages, acts a little cocky,and shot a guy. Maybe the transition from that to "Kamen Rider with flaming punches" is obvious to you but it sure isn't to me.
Does he have enouph talent for princess ruto
 

ned_ballad

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
48,214
Rochester, New York
When was the last time we had a non fighter as our first post of the week?

Edit: unless I missed one, this is the first time

Am I crazy for thinking this is suspicious? Like they did this to keep it to 3 fighters a week for this week because something is coming?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.