• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.

Edward

▲ Legend ▲
Avenger
Oct 30, 2017
5,108
Anyone doubting Phoenix should see any movie starring Phoenix
I have no quams about Phoenix playing Joker. My issues comes from the fact that Joker isn't Joker Batman and Todd Phillips is writing/directing. People can cite Killing Joke all they want as a Joker "solo" film, but Killing Joke is nothing without Batman, Gordon and Barbra and i don't particuarlycare for his origin from the book.

Joker doesn't need an origin let alone a 90 fucking minute film about his origin.
 

More_Badass

Member
Oct 25, 2017
23,622
I have no quams about Phoenix playing Joker. My issues comes from the fact that Joker isn't Joker Batman and Todd Phillips is writing/directing. People can cite Killing Joke all they want as a Joker "solo" film, but Killing Joke is nothing without Batman, Gordon and Barbra and i don't particuarlycare for his origin from the book.

Joker doesn't need an origin let alone a 90 fucking minute film about his origin.
The Joker has already had numerous origins through his history as a character. Having multiple contradicting origins is practically a defining aspect of the character nowadays

I don't get the resistance to the mere notion of a movie? What's the fear? That it will ruin the character?

The Joker doesn't usually have scars
 
Oct 26, 2017
8,992
Anyone doubting Phoenix should see The Master.

15376961552145696.gif

I definitely want to check that movie out. Sadly Netflix and Hulu don't have it. Personally I really enjoyed the movie "Her" and "Walk the line".
 

Window

Member
Oct 27, 2017
8,282
Why do you think it was stupid?
I can buy the idea as far as Martha being mentally scared and losing her sanity but to extend that to her being a criminal mastermind and assuming the role of Joker is bridge too far for me to cross.

Just out of curiosity, what do you think of Breaking Bad?
Tony Soprano, Walter White or any other TV anti-hero have hours and hours of character development to discuss the damage they cause to others and themselves. Even then I do think they are somewhat glorified not only by the audiences but by their creators (Tony maybe less so). I have little faith in this being a good character study which can navigate around the issues of celebrating a serial killer. The Joker works best as a foil to Batman, where the details of his morbid crimes is not the focus but serves as a challenge to Batman's ideals. It's died down quite a bit now but even Ledger's Joker inspired too many "he's right you know" hot takes.
 

THEVOID

Prophet of Regret
Member
Oct 27, 2017
22,841
I definitely want to check that movie out. Sadly Netflix and Hulu don't have it. Personally I really enjoyed the movie "Her" and "Walk the line".

He's never gave a bad performance. If you want him to see him in full gonzo mode look up his "doc" on becoming a rapper I'm Still Here.

He's full on nutso there.

 

More_Badass

Member
Oct 25, 2017
23,622
I can buy the idea as far as Martha being mentally scared and losing her sanity but to extend that to her being a criminal mastermind and assuming the role of Joker is bridge too far for me to cross.


Tony Soprano, Walter White or any other TV anti-hero have hours and hours of character development to discuss the damage they cause to others and themselves. Even then I do think they are somewhat glorified not only by the audiences but by their creators (Tony maybe less so). I have little faith in this being a good character study which can navigate around the issues of celebrating a serial killer. The Joker works best as a foil to Batman, where the details of his morbid crimes is not the focus but serves as a challenge to Batman's ideals. It's died down quite a bit now but even Ledger's Joker inspired too many "he's right you know" hot takes.
Character studies about terrible people have existed long before Breaking Bad and The Sopranos. And why are you assuming the movie would be celebrating the Joker? Nightcrawler wasn't celebrating Louis Bloom
 

Azzazel

Member
Oct 25, 2017
382
What do yall think will happen if this movie does really good? Like 800mill good? What could happen with mexican cartel Joker?.
 

Yossarian

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
13,264
I can buy the idea as far as Martha being mentally scared and losing her sanity but to extend that to her being a criminal mastermind and assuming the role of Joker is bridge too far for me to cross.

I mean, 'logically' speaking, Bruce had to get the traits that make him capable of being Batman from somewhere, and I imagine his parents are probably the source, but fair enough. I thought it was quite an interesting take.

(I put 'logically' in inverted commas because we're talking about a series that asks us to accept a guy nutty enough to dress up as a bat is capable of waging war on crime almost single-handedly.)
 

Window

Member
Oct 27, 2017
8,282
Character studies about terrible people have existed long before Breaking Bad and The Sopranos. And why are you assuming the movie would be celebrating the Joker? Nightcrawler wasn't celebrating Louis Bloom
Thanks for stating the obvious. Of course character studies of terrible people have existed forever. I mentioned Breaking Bad and Sopranos because that's what the poster I was replying to brought up. I'm saying in this instance I am skeptical of this being a good character study because of The Joker's status as an iconic celebrated character, because big budget comic book films are rarely good character studies and because The Joker works better when he's not the subject of a deep character study. Painting a realistic psychological profile of The Joker doesn't work for me because his actions when lifted out from comic book reality into the real world are horrific. It can only be done if you make it appropriately disturbing, repellent - not sympathetic. Happy to be proven wrong though because I like the character and I like Phoenix.
 

More_Badass

Member
Oct 25, 2017
23,622
Thanks for stating the obvious. Of course character studies of terrible people have existed forever. I mentioned Breaking Bad and Sopranos because that's what the poster I was replying to brought up. I'm saying in this instance I am skeptical of this being a good character study because of The Joker's status as an iconic celebrated character, because big budget comic book films are rarely good character studies and because The Joker works better when he's not the subject of a deep character study. Painting a realistic psychological profile of The Joker doesn't work for me because his actions when lifted out from comic book reality into the real world are horrific. It can only be done if you make it appropriately disturbing, repellent - not sympathetic. Happy to be proven wrong though because I like the character and I like Phoenix.
This isnt a big budget comic book movie though. And given the influences, I highly doubt they're going to make him sympathetic
 

Pbae

Member
Oct 26, 2017
3,223
Oh god. This is going to be amazing isn't it.

It's what I always envisioned the Joker. A deeply disturbed man that has overly drastic bipolar tendencies. He can be Mr Rodgers one second and Charles Manson another.

Def got the vibe from Phoenix's interpretation.
 

hotcyder

Member
Oct 28, 2017
2,861
I like it! Different but good. I've always been keen on a Harlequinade inspired Joker design so cool to see them give it a try. Plus it's a step away from the done to death Chemical Vat look.
 

Aselith

Member
Oct 27, 2017
8,350
The Joker has already had numerous origins through his history as a character. Having multiple contradicting origins is practically a defining aspect of the character nowadays

I don't get the resistance to the mere notion of a movie? What's the fear? That it will ruin character?

I feel like people are afraid the origin whatever it is will get "locked in" but that's kind of irrational since there have been many different Jokers and origins in movies already.
 

Deleted member 33

Account closed at user request
Banned
Oct 24, 2017
1,457
One thing that makes me optimistic about this movie: Scott Silver's involvement in co-writing the screenplay.

If you look at the last three movies that Silver wrote/co-wrote screenplays for, they all ended up with "Fresh" ratings on Rottentomatoes.

(2016) The Finest Hours - Rottentomatoes: 64%

(2010) The Fighter - Rottentomatoes: 90% (nominated by the Academy Awards for Best Original Screenplay)

(2002) 8 Mile - Rottentomatoes: 76%

So when Joaquin Phoenix or Marc Maron say that the script is good, I can honestly believe it.
 

Tetra-Grammaton-Cleric

user requested ban
Banned
Oct 28, 2017
8,958
It's fucking garbage. (For me anyways)

The movie could still be fantastic and he's a hell of an actor but the make-up is vomit.

The outfit is cool however.
 

RedVejigante

Member
Aug 18, 2018
5,640
So does anyone else feel that the look treads too closely to that of Heath's Joker? 'Cause that's kind of where I'm at right now...
 

Tetra-Grammaton-Cleric

user requested ban
Banned
Oct 28, 2017
8,958
I like it! Different but good. I've always been keen on a Harlequinade inspired Joker design so cool to see them give it a try. Plus it's a step away from the done to death Chemical Vat look.

Well, that is the origin story of the character, at least in the comics.

I do like what Alex Ross said in regards to the Joker where he basically stated that he thinks the Joker has bleached white skin but everything else - the hair, the red lips, etc. - are his own added cosmetic flourishes.
 

RedVejigante

Member
Aug 18, 2018
5,640
Well, that is the origin story of the character, at least in the comics.

I do like what Alex Ross said in regards to the Joker where he basically stated that he thinks the Joker has bleached white skin but everything else - the hair, the red lips, etc. - are his own added cosmetic flourishes.
Eh, I do like that this explanation makes more sense from a practical standpoint, But I think I prefer the idea that the Joker simply looks like the Joker. No makeup, just the clown prince of crime.
 

Jet Jaguar

Member
Dec 3, 2017
2,564
I'm starting to feel sorry, this isn't part of Reeves' Batman. I didn't like the test shot teaser, but those leaked photos + videos all look great.

There's a point where "leaked" is really just a type of actual marketing. That's what this is. Part of their marketing campaign.

For genuine leaks look for those amateur shots of the force awakens set pics etc.