• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

Which character do you predicted that we would get SquareEnix character that isn't from FF and SMRPG

  • Sora from Kingdom Hearts

    Votes: 324 37.7%
  • Crono from Chrono Trigger

    Votes: 271 31.5%
  • Lara Croft from Tomb Raider

    Votes: 97 11.3%
  • Erdrick/Loto from Dragon Quest

    Votes: 168 19.5%

  • Total voters
    860
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

ClickyCal'

Member
Oct 25, 2017
59,687
That's fair, but Dark Samus is a character that, while there were certainly stans, only really gained significant traction in speculation once Echoes were revealed to be a thing. Dixie has had a far longer and larger presence in Smash hype, and I would expect slightly more gravitas to a reveal than "and here's more Echo fighters".
I think richter was an exception because of being simon's echo, and "who is an echo of who?". The other three echoes so far weren't echoes of newcomers. Doesn't have to do with tier of popularity.
 

ClickyCal'

Member
Oct 25, 2017
59,687
I still don't like idea of Isabelle echo because Villager's moveset is bit too weird for her.

And Dixie would have been more ignored if she was revealed at same time as K. Rool. Its smarter to announce her at different time.
Just change her animations to make her look clumsy. So instead of looking evil dropping the bowling ball on someone's head, it looks like an accident.
 

ned_ballad

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
48,247
Rochester, New York
I was watching the old E3 DLC direct for Smash 4 (the one that had Ryu) and I noticed Sakurai said they can't add too many more stages after Dreamland, Peach's Castle, Hyrule Castle and Miiverse

After saying this, he released

- Suzaku Castle
- Pirate Ship
- Super Mario Maker
- Midgar
- Umbra Clock Tower
- Duck Hunt on the 3DS

I don't think Sakurai's idea of "too many more" is really that low when you look at it.
 

ClickyCal'

Member
Oct 25, 2017
59,687
I was watching the old E3 DLC direct for Smash 4 (the one that had Ryu) and I noticed Sakurai said they can't add too many more stages after Dreamland, Peach's Castle, Hyrule Castle and Miiverse

After saying this, he released

- Suzaku Castle
- Pirate Ship
- Super Mario Maker
- Midgar
- Umbra Clock Tower
- Duck Hunt on the 3DS

I don't think Sakurai's idea of "too many more" is really that low when you look at it.
Well, that's 6 more. So maybe that could equate to 6 unique newcomers.
 

Red Arremer

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
12,259
That's fair, but Dark Samus is a character that, while there were certainly stans, only really gained significant traction in speculation once Echoes were revealed to be a thing. Dixie has had a far longer and larger presence in Smash hype, and I would expect slightly more gravitas to a reveal than "and here's more Echo fighters".

Ish?
I've seen Dark Samus being brought up a lot, and I do mean a LOT, as the alternative to Ridley since he had been considered as being too big (ignoring the meme-ification of that argument here).
A lot of people even in pre-Brawl days have argued that Metroid should get a second character, and that the alternative to Ridley would be Dark Samus. That was when the Prime games still were recent, even, and Dark Samus' reputation as "the other character that could be included if Ridley isn't playable" held until even before the E3 presentation of Ultimate.
Dark Samus got a lot of steam on the speculation train once it was revealed that her AT and the Samus palette swap were missing combined with the Echoes concept, but she'd been brought up on the regular even going back to the late 2000s.
 

ClickyCal'

Member
Oct 25, 2017
59,687
Villager kind of does that with its dropping flower pot move. Isabelle doing Balloon Fighter is the move that's just too far for her imo.
That's the one that draws the line? That would look cute with her floating around.

Ish?
I've seen Dark Samus being brought up a lot, and I do mean a LOT, as the alternative to Ridley since he had been considered as being too big (ignoring the meme-ification of that argument here).
A lot of people even in pre-Brawl days have argued that Metroid should get a second character, and the alternative to Ridley would be Dark Samus. That was when the Prime games still were recent, even, and Dark Samus' reputation as "the other character that could be included if Ridley isn't playable" held until even before the E3 presentation of Ultimate.
Dark Samus got a lot of steam on the speculation train once it was revealed that her AT and the Samus palette swap were missing combined with the Echoes concept, but she'd been brought up on the regular even going back to the late 2000s.
And sakurai said she got in just on the ballot.
 

Gartooth

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
8,440
Also just as an aside, saying which characters are "important" won't matter when we're talking about a game deciding characters based on fanservice. The definition of what's important changes when the ballot is in play and it isn't about how many popular games a character starred in.
 

Dark Cloud

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
61,087
Also just as an aside, saying which characters are "important" won't matter when we're talking about a game deciding characters based on fanservice. The definition of what's important changes when the ballot is in play and it isn't about how many popular games a character starred in.
I hope one day we get to see the ballot. Maybe 20 years from now Sakurai can tell us.
 

TMaakkonen

Member
Oct 26, 2017
2,747
That's the one that draws the line? That would look cute with her floating around.
The pose and flapping animation would look more awkward than cute I think.

I guess there is also the axe, but let's face it. If Isabelle gets in as echo, we are so going to get Axe murderer Isabelle fanart with smiling Villager as her partner.
 

ClickyCal'

Member
Oct 25, 2017
59,687
It kind of seems like a lot of people here will be baffled if dixie shows up on screen when sakurai is showing off more echoes.
 

Red Arremer

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
12,259
Yea, Dark Samus has always been brought up as a "well, we can't have Ridley, but we want a new Metroid character, so pick Dark Samus!"

I think that also played into her hand in the ballot. I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of people who would've regularly voted for Ridley went on to go for Dark Samus instead since Ridley was already the focal point of Pyrosphere.
 

ClickyCal'

Member
Oct 25, 2017
59,687
The pose and flapping animation would look more awkward than cute I think.

I guess there is also the axe, but let's face it. If Isabelle gets in as echo, we are so going to get Axe murderer Isabelle fanart with smiling Villager as her partner.
To be fair, there is already cutsey fanart of ridley playing around with pichu, so would kind of be the anti ridley.
 

TheDinoman

Member
Oct 25, 2017
17,098
Also just as an aside, saying which characters are "important" won't matter when we're talking about a game deciding characters based on fanservice. The definition of what's important changes when the ballot is in play and it isn't about how many popular games a character starred in.

Tell that to Waluigi or Ashley
 

Grapezard

Member
Nov 16, 2017
7,787
Remember when Sylux was being brought up in a way that was like "Eh, I guess they'll have to do".

Those were dark times.
 

TheDinoman

Member
Oct 25, 2017
17,098
You know, I don't particurly want any character to be cut...but at this point I honestly wouldn't mind if Zero Suit Samus got dropped.

I mean she kind of fufilled her purpose. Sakurai just threw her in because he was desperate for a second Metroid character and he didn't think Ridley could work at the time. But now that he did get Ridley working and we even got Dark Samus, ZSS feels kind of...pointless to me.

The Zero Suit was never even intended to be used for direct combat purposes in Zero Mission (and even Other M). I feel like it's a good example of why the whole "this random character needs to get in so THIS series can have more reps compared to THAT other series..." is a stupid idea. You should want Ridley and K. Rool in not because "well their series needs more reps ahuh", but because you feel they're actually good choices and deserving to be in Smash Bros.
 

Red Arremer

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
12,259
Remember when Sylux was being brought up in a way that was like "Eh, I guess they'll have to do".

Those were dark times.

I remember Sylux and Rundas being the two characters who usually were brought up, Sylux usually more so because of Tanabe saying he wanted to make the character return in potential future games, and the presumed cameo of Sylux' ship in the ending of Prime 3.
That was the character's main argument for inclusion, lol.

Depending on his role in MP4, Sylux could possibly be a major contender for DLC.

I think Prime 4 may be a bit too far off for that, but who knows.
 

ClickyCal'

Member
Oct 25, 2017
59,687
He could be a character in Smash U. Tanabe pretty much will have him in a big role. I hope his look was completely redesigned though.
Well, hard to tell but this will be somewhat how he probably will look
latest

You know, I don't particurly want any character to be cut...but at this point I honestly wouldn't mind if Zero Suit Samus got dropped.

I mean she kind of fufilled her purpose. Sakurai just threw her in because he was desperate for a second Metroid character and he didn't think Ridley could work at the time. But now that he did get Ridley working and we even got Dark Samus, ZSS feels kind of...pointless to me.

The Zero Suit was never even intended to be used for direct combat purposes in Zero Mission (and even Other M). I feel like it's a good example of why the whole "this random character needs to get in so THIS series can have more reps compared to THAT other series..." is a stupid idea. You should want Ridley and K. Rool in not because "well their series needs more reps ahuh", but because you feel they're actually good choices and deserving to be in Smash Bros.
Yea, I agree zss is only really a negative on samus's legacy unfortunately because of what it brought to the mainstream of how they see her.

Plus her role in zero mission is literally that she has to run and hide even just from normal space pirates and needs to get the varia suit back asap.

Then in smash she comes in and is a total badass and op and stronger than without the suit. She comes out to fight ridley as a badass in the zero suit, but trembled when in the power suit.

At least her design was toned down and looks better. But that caused immature assholes to downvote her trailer.

Samus, dark samus, and ridley is a perfect trio.
 

Kor of Memory

Avenger
Oct 27, 2017
1,669
These might not be "big hitters" to the general public. But I'm sure they would catch a lot of attention if they were announced.

Just a couple I think that have been discussed here even:

Andy/Sami - A Rep from the advance wars series.
Isaac - A Rep from Golden Sun
Lark - A Pilotwings rep (Who also is basically Nester from the old Nintendo comics and a great wtf pick)
ChibiRobo - Little dude might not be in the spotlight now. But he was actually pretty fun back in the day.
Chorus Kids - Or any Rythem Heaven rep really.


As another curve ball charcter. I think it'd be neat to have another Olimar/Alph situation except for these two guys:

 

Regulus Tera

Member
Oct 25, 2017
19,458
So how did you all buy DLC? Did you just get everyone or just who you liked? I got all characters and stages but only select Mii items.
I bought everything for both versions except the Mii stuff.
I hacked my Wii U and got the DLC that way.
That's pretty shitty.
I'm not gonna condone this practice, but it's kind of inevitable when all you were really paying for was an unlock key.
 

wholahay

Member
Dec 18, 2017
708
Can I reopen the Square-Enix discussion after a brief reprieve? People tend to toss out Geno, or a specific Final Fantasy character, or someone from Dragon Quest, or, when feeling particularly lucky, Crono. And I guess also Lara Croft sometimes? HOWEVER:

I've always felt like a generic Black Mage would be a great fit. I think the Black Mage (in the classic design: wizard hat, faceless, glowing eyes) is more iconique than people give it credit for. Barring creatures like Moogles and Cactuars, I think Black Mage is the closest you can get to representing FF as a whole, and a magic-based moveset would be a nice contrast to Cloud. In conclusion, #BlackMage4Smash2k18. Thank you for your time and consideration on this matter.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.