You're right about that, they're worse. One version gets extra content over another that gets nothing. In the end is still under the contention point of a version getting a "free game" and the other not, which is what is causing such outrage in this thread. You either find both fine or both problematic - there's no middle ground here.
I don't think so, if one version is getting a bonus because of a platform feature that doesn't exist elsewhere, that's fine. Whether that's a BC copy of a game, a dynamic theme, Avatar gear, whatever - I don't mind. If you do, that's an issue for you to solve with a platform holder of your choice. If there are platform-exclusive bonuses on each platform, that's also fine, as long as they're of the same type or if everyone agrees they're of roughly the same value. But here they are not, and there are no good reasons why buyers on any platform should feel like they are getting less for their money.
And i'm not making any excuses. Your argument could work if the steam release received a wallpaper or something and only the xbox version got the better value (the game). In this case, the steam version is vastly the better one with the OST and artbooik so why people are upset about the xbox version instead of the steam version i have no idea. Since you shared your selfish viewpoint of "i want more value for my money" i'll share mine and say i want things to stay this way because i'm getting it on steam and i want the OST and artbook instead of yet another copy of a fucking game thats bundled with Last Light for 5 reais
You're straight making shit up now. My stated viewpoint is not "I want more value for my money", it's "I want equal value for my money". What's selfish about that? And yes, games don't always cost the same on each platfom, but that's again due to differences that should best be discussed with your platform holder of choice.
I have no horse in this race, this is a matter of principle. I'm getting this on Xbox, because that's my preferred platform; I don't have a PS4 yet anyway, and I dislike playing games on PC. Furthermore, I already own the Metro Redux bundle, so I don't care about the bonus game. If anything, I could be jealous of the Steam bonuses, but in this case I simply don't care. However, some other people do, and I can understand why, because I was in their shoes a few times in the past. I don't want to be in their shoes ever again, and I don't think that anyone should be.
If you really want the Steam bonuses, how about you buy them as DLC? People pre-ordering games should be treated equally whenever possible. Here it's possible. Saying "fuck that, I want my preferred/better bonuses" - now, that's selfish.