• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.

zoltan

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
167
but sony allows crossplay, it's just more limited than on Xbox and Switch, they should probably say they won't release on platforms(lol at plural) that don't allow crossplay with ALL of the other platforms
 

ghostcrew

The Shrouded Ghost
Administrator
Oct 27, 2017
30,351
but sony allows crossplay, it's just more limited than on Xbox and Switch, they should probably say they won't release on platforms(lol at plural) that don't allow crossplay with ALL of the other platforms

They do say that. If you're just reading the thread title, that's a summary of the interview. A headline. The article says...

"It is both cross-platform play and cross-platform progress."

I cut him off at this point to clarify that the cross-play would only be on "certain systems," since I figured this wouldn't apply on PS4.

Hines replied, "It is our intention in order for the game to come out, it has to be those things on any system. We cannot have a game that works one way across everywhere else except for on this one thing. The way the game works right now on Apple, Google, Steam, and Bethesda.net, it doesn't matter where you buy your stuff, if you play it on another platform that stuff is there. It doesn't matter what platform you play on, you play against everyone else who is playing at that moment.
 

jroc74

Member
Oct 27, 2017
28,992
What FF14 pretty much did. I doubt Sony will care about this game, but it's probably the only thing that could get them to bend.

Though if Bethesda bend after saying this first, Sony win for good and I don't think they'll ever willingly allow other consoles cross-play, even with PS5.

Now that I think about it, maybe that could have been the starting point for MS to change their minds.

I also bought this game up, was told it's apples to oranges in a debate about devs, publishers taking a stand.

I wonder if it's apples to oranges now...
 

jroc74

Member
Oct 27, 2017
28,992
Get back to me when Epic Games say this about Fortnite 2.

Until then this is a non issue about a genre that people don't give a shit about outside blizzard games.

Yeah, Fortnite 2 will be one to watch. Can't wait.

I think he made it as clear as humanly possible that if they don't allow cross play and progrsssion it won't come to the platform. Mobile and Switch are likely their main desired platforms anyway with PC and Xbox as side perks.

He's not going to make these types of statements as a company lead then go "LOL it's out anyway! We could never ignore teh munny!"


If developers don't stand up to Sony no one will. Look at all the posters here trying to take away from what's going on and downplay the game to try and defend Sony's right to deny them the features other platforms have. Such blind loyalty is scary.

There's also this:

Because Fallout 76 will probably sell best on PS4 and if they tried it with something like that, they'll get the majority of the backlash, not Sony, which would just strengthen Sony's position if they decided to call their bluff with that.

Fallout 4 mods is a fairly recent example of this, was pretty much Sony's fault, but Bethesda got all the blame, backtracked on "no mods for PS4" and released it in a gimped form
.

www.vg247.com/2016/09/09/fallout-4-mod-support-nixed-because-sony-wont-approve-user-mods-the-way-they-should-work/amp/

but like was mentioned mod support wasn't as great as it could be, but mods was still released for PS4.

Because at the end off the day....money talks....
 

SolidChamp

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,867
Bethesda barely ever needed a reason to drop Sony. I've never seen a developer be more partial towards a console brand/company than Bethesda is with Xbox/MS.

Not that it bothers me. It's just what I've noticed.
 

khamakazee

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
3,937
We already know why Sony doesn't want crossplay. Why open up your platform to the possibility of your competitor being able to preach to your customer? Business wise it makes sense. However, you have guys like yourself who can't see that. For the record, I never once said I supported the stance that Sony is currently adopting. I just found it interesting that people are choosing to die on this hill for something that is purely a business decision and acting like Sony is personally going into your home and mollywhopping you.

How does it makes sense business wise if you don't get a version of the game because of said policies? This sounds more personal than business. Yes for now they can leverage the 3rd party studios to adhere to their policies because of the large install base but mobile and PC also have large install bases for certain titles and this is one of them, same with Minecraft. Fallout 76 is one they won't use because that game will sell very well on the PS4 but when next generation comes Sony had better be nicer or there may be a real backlash that will hurt them financially.
 

stilgar

Member
Nov 8, 2017
194
This is an embarrassing thread for sure. You are players, right? Then you should indiscriminately applaud this quote instead of being all snarky about it. "A card game lol" is an immature argument. And actually not an argument.
 

thomasmahler

Game Director at Moon Studios
Verified
Oct 27, 2017
1,097
Vienna / Austria
Good on them. Developers shouldn't have to jump through hoops and create per-platform server infrastructures just cause the boys don't wanna play together. On top of that, it's just shit for players. Let me access my data wherever I am. I paid for the game, I wanna access my profile and keep playing.

I'm guessing for a card game it just didn't make sense to Bethesda to create a whole unique server layer just for PS4 players. I hope this stuff will happen more often with bigger titles so that Sony will finally allow cross-platform play. It's 2018, time to break down those walls.
 

Deleted member 1238

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
3,070
This is an embarrassing thread for sure. You are players, right? Then you should indiscriminately applaud this quote instead of being all snarky about it. "A card game lol" is an immature argument. And actually not an argument.
unfortunately people here feel the need to be snarky because they're taking this stance as a personal attack since it's against their "team." It's not a hot take to say that many of the posters care deeply about the branding on their hunk of plastic.
 

Majiebeast

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
2,090
Oh no PS4 might miss out on Bethesda's mediocre version of Hearthstone that is barely relevant. It needs all the userbase it can get at this point.
 
Oct 27, 2017
3,297
unfortunately people here feel the need to be snarky because they're taking this stance as a personal attack since it's against their "team." It's not a hot take to say that many of the posters care deeply about the branding on their hunk of plastic.

Or maybe people are looking at it for what it is: an empty threat. Unless they put up an actual game as a threat, nobody is going to care about a card game being withheld.
 

stilgar

Member
Nov 8, 2017
194
Or maybe people are looking at it for what it is: an empty threat. Unless they put up an actual game as a threat, nobody is going to care about a card game being withheld.

Sure. Post more messages showing how much you don't care.
Anyway, card game or not, they should receive nothing but support from players and game enthusiasts.
 

Deleted member 13645

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
6,052
And miss out on a 80+ million userbase?

Okay, I've seen dumber moves I guess.

How many of those players wouldn't have access to a smart phone, pc (of even low specs) or other console if they wanted to play? Probably a very small number. If it's between that or having to completely undermine your own ecosystem goal of complete cross progression, it doesn't seem like a big deal to skip ps4
 

Lappe

Banned
Nov 1, 2017
1,651
This is an embarrassing thread for sure. You are players, right? Then you should indiscriminately applaud this quote instead of being all snarky about it. "A card game lol" is an immature argument. And actually not an argument.
Very true, but people are not being nice to everybody favourite company Sony so the need to be defensive is clear.
 

Deleted member 1238

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
3,070
And miss out on a 80+ million userbase?

Okay, I've seen dumber moves I guess.
That is also just a dumb argument for this game. That number doesn't mean much to them when their target is mobile and PC. All 80 million of those PS4 users probably have access to one of those platforms. The console is just another option to play on, but bethesda's core philiosophy with this game is that they want your account to carry over no matter where you play. That isn't possible on Sony's platform due to their anti-consumer and convoluted stance on cross play. So Bethesda doesn't want to compromise that vision to launch the game on a console that won't matter much anyways. They are certainly leaving some money on the table by doing this, but it's not nearly as much as you or anyone else making this point seem to think.

It's very funny to see the two main arguements against Bethesda here are "the user base is so big" and also "it's just a dumb card game no one cares." So it's a big user base but no one cares? Bethesda seems to agree with that and as a result they just won't bother with a PS4 port.

The real takeaway here should be "hey Sony maybe change your dumb, anti-consumer stance on crossplay it benefits none of us"
 

khamakazee

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
3,937
That is also just a dumb argument for this game. That number doesn't mean much to them when their target is mobile and PC. All 80 million of those PS4 users probably have access to one of those platforms. The console is just another option to play on, but bethesda's core philiosophy with this game is that they want your account to carry over no matter where you play. That isn't possible on Sony's platform due to their anti-consumer and convoluted stance on cross play. So Bethesda doesn't want to compromise that vision to launch the game on a console that won't matter much anyways. They are certainly leaving some money on the table by doing this, but it's not nearly as much as you or anyone else making this point seem to think.

It's very funny to see the two main arguements against Bethesda here are "the user base is so big" and also "it's just a dumb card game no one cares." So it's a big user base but no one cares? Bethesda seems to agree with that and as a result they just won't bother with a PS4 port.

The real takeaway here should be "hey Sony maybe change your dumb, anti-consumer stance on crossplay it benefits none of us"

Good way of explaining things but you will continue to see the same people trying to defend Sony's policies one way or another.
 

Deleted member 13645

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
6,052
They can totally cut out the largest portion of this generation's console sales with no backlash!

It's interesting you have the perspective of the backlash being aimed at Bethedsa rather than at Sony for their policies causing this. Not really Bethesda's fault that Sony won't allow cross progression for a game that is built around cross progression.
 

Soprano

Banned
Oct 28, 2017
990
This is all talk. If you wanted to make a serious point about crossplay, you would do it with Fallout 76.
 

Doskoi Panda

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 27, 2017
14,942
As expected, this thread is a mind circus. Nothing but mental gymnastics and clown music.

And the same handful of posters doing their best to shit up conversation and muddy the waters, as usual. I love seeing the same avatars in every cross-play thread (with a Spider-Man twist!), people thinking they're slick when they're not. I see you, I'm not the only one, because you're painfully transparent and have been as long as you've been members here.

Huh? What is he talking bout? Sony can do crossplay pc feat ps4 just fine like ff14 does
You could go ahead read the OP before posting a response to it, and then, you would know what's being talked about. Isn't it crazy how that works?
 
Last edited:

ghostcrew

The Shrouded Ghost
Administrator
Oct 27, 2017
30,351
Huh? What is he talking bout? Sony can do crossplay pc feat ps4 just fine like ff14 does

Did you read the OP/article? The game is also coming to Xbox/Switch.

This is all talk. If you wanted to make a serious point about crossplay, you would do it with Fallout 76.

They're not trying 'to make a serious point about crossplay'. They're trying to release a video game that includes full crossplay/cross progression and if a platform can't support that then it won't come out on it. There's only one that doesn't support that so I guess PS4 only players who want to play it will have to play it on their phone or on another platform. It's releasing everywhere else so shouldn't be hard to find somewhere to play it.
 

Dog of Bork

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,988
Texas
Please do it, Bethesda. Sony needs to rethink this policy and they won't do it until it hurts them financially. If enough games skip the PS because of this, there's a (small) chance they'll turn around.
 

Riversands

Banned
Nov 21, 2017
5,669
Did you read the OP/article? The game is also coming to Xbox/Switch.

Well. They said that they prefer having it crossplay across platforms, so i said ps4 also fulfils that criterion since sony enable crossplay on pc too at least for now like ff14 does. Am i wrong? But i dont think sony want to go crossplay across all consoles for now, i think this will be their gimmick for next generation
 

kpaadet

Banned
Oct 30, 2017
1,741
They're not trying to make Sony sweat. They're trying to make the best version of their game possible. Releasing on PS4 with their current policies means the PS4 version would massively suffer. We're already seeing PS4 players suffer limited versions of Minecraft and Fortnite due to Sony's policy. Hines is just saying that if the platform doesn't support one of the core features of the game then it obviously won't release there.

PS4 players have a ton of other platforms they can play it on (including the phone that presumably already own) if they really want to play it.
So we can assume all Bethesda games with a MP mode to skip PS4? If they want the best version possible no?
 

Soprano

Banned
Oct 28, 2017
990
They're not trying 'to make a serious point about crossplay'. They're trying to release a video game that includes full crossplay/cross progression and if a platform can't support that then it won't come out on it. There's only one that doesn't support that so I guess PS4 only players who want to play it will have to play it on their phone or on another platform. It's releasing everywhere else so shouldn't be hard to find somewhere to play it.

If you're going to do that with one game why not another? Crossplay is crossplay. Bethesda was very vocal about Fallout 76 not having it because of "Sony's stance." Yet they didn't seem to not want to release the game there.
 

Doskoi Panda

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 27, 2017
14,942
If you're going to do that with one game why not another? Crossplay is crossplay. Bethesda was very vocal about Fallout 76 not having it because of "Sony's stance." Yet they didn't seem to not want to release the game there.
It's likely that cross-play and cross-platform progression are viewed by Bethesda as being important elements of their vision for Legends, moreso than for 76. Perhaps Bethesda views that functionality as being more vital for the kind of product they intend Legends to be.
 

kpaadet

Banned
Oct 30, 2017
1,741
It's likely that cross-play and cross-platform progression are viewed by Bethesda as being important elements of their vision for Legends, moreso than for 76. Perhaps Bethesda views that functionality as being more vital for the kind of product they intend Legends to be.
Or they know the majority of the audience for a CCG is on PC/mobile and don't really have the balls to make a fuss with a game like the new Fallout.
Did you read the OP? This is specifically about their card game which is built around cross progression.
Why is a card game the only genre where cross progression is important?
 

Arthands

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
8,039
Well. They said that they prefer having it crossplay across platforms, so i said ps4 also fulfils that criterion since sony enable crossplay on pc too at least for now like ff14 does. Am i wrong? But i dont think sony want to go crossplay across all consoles for now, i think this will be their gimmick for next generation

well The Elder Scrolls: Legends is a current gen game so too bad.
 

ghostcrew

The Shrouded Ghost
Administrator
Oct 27, 2017
30,351
Why is a card game the only genre where cross progression is important?

It's not the only genre where it's important but, as a mobile game, it's far more likely to be used by players in this than in something like Fallout 76. You can assume that most Legends players are gonna come from mobile. The game is designed and built so they can also play on their PC/Xbox/Switch and bring across their progression. People are far less likely to buy two copies of a full game like Fallout 76 and need to hop from one console to the other. It'd be awesome if it was there, sure. But it's a game that will get 100% of it's sales and players from PC/PS4/Xbox so probably doesn't make any sense to lose one of those. Legends is a card game that will be mostly played on phones. It doesn't really matter so much if people can't play on their PS4. The important thing for Bethesda, it seems, is that the people playing it on every other platform have the best version possible.
 

Falconbox

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,600
Buffalo, NY
Well. They said that they prefer having it crossplay across platforms, so i said ps4 also fulfils that criterion since sony enable crossplay on pc too at least for now like ff14 does. Am i wrong? But i dont think sony want to go crossplay across all consoles for now, i think this will be their gimmick for next generation

Bethesda wants the game to be crossplay EVERYWHERE. One account, all your purchases and progress go with you everywhere and you can play against anyone.

It doesn't matter to Bethesda that Sony is doing some half-assed cross-play support with PC, since that still leaves out Xbox and Switch.
 

CozMick

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
1,242
The "do it Bethesda" crowd ain't seeing the bigger picture here.

This could seriously backfire in their faces, Imagine releasing their next bundle of games without the 80+ million ps4 users, because guess what that is exactly what Sony is likely to do,
 

ghostcrew

The Shrouded Ghost
Administrator
Oct 27, 2017
30,351
The "do it Bethesda" crowd ain't seeing the bigger picture here.

This could seriously backfire in their faces, Imagine releasing their next bundle of games without the 80+ million ps4 users, because guess what that is exactly what Sony is likely to do,

They're not talking about their next bundle of games. They're talking about a mobile-first, F2P card game that, currently, includes (and requires) full crossplay and cross progression. That's it.
 

CozMick

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
1,242
They're not talking about their next bundle of games. They're talking about a mobile-first, F2P card game that, currently, requires full crossplay and cross progression. That's it.

But my point is if they start making demands Sony would likely tell them in as professional manner as possible to go fuck themselves. They would lose 80-90 million potential customers for future titles if Sony played hardball
 

SuikerBrood

Member
Jan 21, 2018
15,487
The comments dismissing card games are really weird to me. Next sports games, then racing games, etc. as long as you don't care? Or what?