• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Status
Not open for further replies.

ZattMurdock

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
10,333
Earth 616
TRIGGER WARNING: Instances of rape and pedophilia are discussed, not just in the context of shitty edgy jokes.

Someone called Jónína Rebekka made an in-depth analysis on the whole James Gunn situation, she reunites information about an in-depth analysis on James Gunn's tweets but she also brings light to a fact that it seems to have flew completely under the radar to most people: James Gunn was a victim of child abuse, by his own recollections, and talked openly about that on his Twitter as late as literally this year.

Here are some interesting excerpts of Rebekka's analysis:

"The Truth about James Gunn and the Pedophile in his Childhood.

1*aymvEYa_G2TiASovOdOCew.png

Source: https://twitter.com/JamesGunn/status/975580269787758592

I have finally decided to make an in-depth article about the whole James Gunn situation. I've wanted to ever since the whole thing blew off, and finally now, after seeing the whole cast of Guardians of the Galaxy showing their support, releasing a statement, here I will express everything I have to say and rule out any misconception that has been made regarding the situation.

I will go into the subject of what James Gunn's tweets were, who James Gunn truly was 10 years ago, Mike Cernovich, James Gunn's exposed views on subjects of rape and finally James Gunn's own personal experience with child abuse.

There are a lot of arguments against Gunn, such as the following statements:

"James Gunn was 41 when he made those tweets! James Gunn deleted 10,000 tweets of pedophilia and rape jokes" "I've got kids and you are disgusting for defending a pedophile!" "Nobody in their right mind JOKES about pedophila"

But to quote one of James Gunn's films, "Sometimes how it looks and how it is are two separate things".

I think I will start off ruling the biggest misconception that has been made regarding the topic: the number of tweets.
There are a lot of people stating that James Gunn had posted over 10,000 tweets remarking pedophilia, but there were around 20. However, James Gunn did remove around ten thousand tweets from a three year span off his twitter account.
I found a reddit thread which put a lot of James Gunn's tweets into context, showing how some of James Gunns tweets were plain offensive, while others were not exactly what they seemed. I'll post the important ones in here for you to see, although if you would like to take a look at the whole thread, here is the link.

1*oh8W9rAiNDIYSb5hCd_UuQ.png


As stated here, Wesley Von Spears is James Gunn's pet dog. It does put things into a different perspective as I can now "see" the joke. I also found sources describing how the Guardians of the Galaxy character Groot is actually inspired by Gunn's love of his dog, as well as his character Rocket, the talking racoon, is more of an adaption of James Gunn himself.

0*p-gUA_RvDb6r_63I

James Gunn's dog, Wesley Von Spears

1*zSaFmohlTdGzyZahC_VhMg.png


In this tweet, the context is described that James Gunn was doing a public reading when he spotted a convicted pedophile, so the whole thing was not, as misconcepted, a personal reading to a pedophile for the shits and gigs.



1*I8Sb1XgoeDaDulzv83qaXw.png

1*Z1PtatcSbB-b_ZKFa7yQiw.png

1*gVHopZlwgTVNcTkj1CePLg.png


All of these have something in common. Those are all "fake retweets", since twitter retweeting apparently just didn't work like it does today, it would include the "retweet" mark in the beginning of the tweet: RT @twitterusername in the beginning of a tweet and then add the context to it from the following person. In this case, it was more like the equivalent of writing a funny facebook status on your friends news feed while he went to the bathroom for a couple of minutes. All of these people are close friends of Gunns who he has worked with, for example Lloyd Kaufman, who is the founder of Troma Entertainment, which is the company James Gunn started first working for making shock comedy films."

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"I think here I should finally add the subject on child abuse as well.

1*tCJ0PJagXr2NUcepGrEWpA.png

Source: https://twitter.com/JamesGunn/status/975580269787758592


How come through all of these tweets on James Gunn and pedophilia have blown up like they have, but this tweet in particular hasn't gained any attention whatsoever?

After all of these tweets on pedophilia, is James Gunn a victim of child abuse as well? I looked into it, and this is what I found. I'll first mention Mosignor Russell J. Obmann.

1*I_L_HPbKHDDyjRjXCbaTDw.png

Source: https://twitter.com/JamesGunn/status/1008929160947888128

I looked for Mosignor Obmanns name and what info there could be gathered from all this. It turns out James Gunn has expressed a lot on the subject when it came to Obmann.

I found an article from 2014 where two quotes were taken from James Gunn's now deleted blog. It was out of a list he had made of "100 things I hate" which was written in 2006.

On the list he had mentioned Obmann in the two following statements:

10) Monsignor Russell J. Obmann, the pastor at my grade school, St. Joseph's in Manchester, Missouri, who gave the young boys in my class alcohol and showed them porn, and probably other stuff as well. He was later caught having sex with a male student, but was only reprimanded by the Catholic Church. Now he's dead.

11) The fact that we all told our parents that Russell J. Obmann was doing this shit, but they thought we were being silly and making up stories because he was a dick even outside of being a child molestor.

This is only a piece of information, but on another Buzzfeed article I found from 2017, Gunn goes a little deeper into the subject on Russell J. Obmann.

In the article, Gunn describes how his school was dominated by "pretty maniacal bullies" who made his life hell. According to Gunn, the catalyst for that behavior was the school's monsignor, Russell J. Obmann.

He describes again that he was giving young boys in class alcohol and pornography and that he was molesting the kids in fifth grade.

He also talked about how he mentioned this to his parents, but their response having been 'Aw, Jimmy.' James Gunn's noting "You know, this was back in the '80s, before people were sensitive to that stuff. They just thought we were making up something about the monsignor at our school."

Although Gunn doesn't go into deep about what his personal experience with Obmann was, he describes the difficulty coming from home and from being bullied at school.

James Gunn is the oldest sibling of 6 and raised in a Catholic family, a family James Gunn describes having been "dysfunctional". He expressed how there were many alcoholics within the family, explaining how his father made it especially difficult at home. Being the oldest sibling of all 6, this must have been tough for Gunn, taking in a lot of responsibility. "I was a director from the time I was a child".

Sean Gunn, the youngest Gunn's siblings, whom James Gunn has featured in many of his films describes how they had to obtain "survival skills" within the family and how although the difficulty their father had raised, it created a tighter bond between the siblings.

Along with Sean Gunns words, he describes this has a lot to do with the story of Guardians of the Galaxy. "The overarching theme of the movie is that this odd band of space protectors is trying to evolve from a dysfunctional family to a strangely functional one."

James Gunn doesn't go into depths of what really went on during his childhood, but thinking from my own experience of having an abusive alcoholic/drug addict father, I understand he wouldn't expose it publicly, because maybe he knows something I do from my dad sobering up.

He's no longer that person today and although all of those things were wrong he did years ago, I still forgive him and know he is a good person now. (Its crazy how compared to that, people are outraged over tweets)

It doesn't really surprise me that James Gunn grew up having several anger issues, although he never really did anything worse than offensive, it doesn't surprise me he would surround himself with dark humor and hang with fellow misfits, seeking approval through laughter.

"If life gives you lemons, make lemonade, if life gives you assholes, make a Troma movie."

This also makes me think of the Guardians of the Galaxy character Rocket, the talking raccoon, which James Gunn describes "is him". I sort of want to put an interesting quotation by James Gunn regarding his views:

"I guess I am an optimist in a pessimist brain, if that makes any sense. I believe in the innate goodness of most people in this world, and yet I'm a damaged soul like many other people and have my own demons and things I struggle with"

I think it was in the second movie where Rocket softens his edge and describes how his humor is only his defensive shell, as he becomes more vulnerable towards his new "family"."

These are just two excerpts of her analysis. If you are interested on what those tweets meant in context and can stomach reading about the stuff that Gunn has reportedly suffered through his childhood, I'd really encourage it to read the whole thing.

Here's the link to the original article:

The Truth about James Gunn and the Pedophile in his Childhood.
 
Last edited:

Nappuccino

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
13,015

After all of these tweets on pedophilia, is James Gunn a victim of child abuse as well? I looked into it, and this is what I found. I'll first mention Mosignor Russell J. Obmann.

1*I_L_HPbKHDDyjRjXCbaTDw.png

Source: https://twitter.com/JamesGunn/status/1008929160947888128

If people read nothing else of the article, it should be this tweet. Gunn is very familiar with the effects of sexual abuse, and seemed to use dark humor as a coping mechanism to deal with the traumas he witnessed and, perhaps, experienced himself.
 

Weasel

Member
Oct 25, 2017
120
User warned: Thread derailing
"Hollywood's biggest crisis of the literal century, way bigger than #MeToo"
Never forget, ResetEra.
 
OP
OP
ZattMurdock

ZattMurdock

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
10,333
Earth 616
If all the world's a stage, then this story is a tragedy.

Truly disheartening. As a survivor of child abuse, what disheartens me isn't the tweets, it's what he went through, it's how it's obvious when you put in context the two Guardians films. This is bigger than fucking superhero films. This is about not allowing alt-right assholes to get away with bullshit like this, and that's why the more people know what actually Gunn went through, the better. Fuck Disney and whatever they do.

"Hollywood's biggest crisis of the literal century, way bigger than #MeToo"
Never forget, ResetEra.
Like I've said above: I'm a survivor of child abuse. By no means I tried to underplay #MeToo, and I'm one of the several vocal advocates for the #MeToo movement here on Era and in real life. What you are doing is no different than what happened to Gunn, which is ironic: take shit out of context in order to mock / make people feel bad. Fuck this.
 

Raguel

Banned
Oct 28, 2017
2,275
"Hollywood's biggest crisis of the literal century, way bigger than #MeToo"
Never forget, ResetEra.
What's the point of bringing this up other than to derail and attack the OP? Does this make you feel like a real person now? It certainly doesn't make you look like less of a twat
 

Raguel

Banned
Oct 28, 2017
2,275
Truly disheartening. As a survivor of child abuse, what disheartens me isn't the tweets, it's what he went through, it's how it's obvious when you put in context the two Guardians films. This is bigger than fucking superhero films. This is about not allowing alt-right assholes to get away with bullshit like this, and that's why the more people know what actually Gunn went through, the better. Fuck Disney and whatever they do.


Like I've said above: I'm a survivor of child abuse. By no means I tried to underplay #MeToo, and I'm one of the several vocal advocates for the #MeToo movement here on Era and in real life. What you are doing is no different than what happened to Gunn, which is ironic: take shit out of context in order to mock / make people feel bad. Fuck this.
Ignore the twat Zatt.
 

Tahnit

Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,965
Holy shit. with this info maybe the whole situation regarding those jokes needs to be looked at again and reevaluated. Disney needs to see this shit.
 
OP
OP
ZattMurdock

ZattMurdock

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
10,333
Earth 616
Can we please stop derailing the thread?

I'd highly recommend this reddit link already linked on the OP's article as follow up reading:

So in the interests of science, I read every old James Gunn tweet that Mike Cernovich and his hit squad retweeted last week. This is based on Cernovich's Twitter timeline from July 19-20 because he posted most of the screencaps of the tweets and retweeted a lot of other people's screencaps, so it's possible I missed a few that were retweeted elsewhere but fell through the cracks during the heat of the scandal. This covers all of main tweets that you see people referencing individually and that made it into the compilation image that keeps floating around.

Like in my post describing why I think James Gunn likely had a pretty understandable reason for not deleting the tweets sooner, I want to make it clear that I am not defending the content of what he said, except in cases where it's being willfully misinterpreted to push Cernovich's agenda. I just think it's important to be honest about the scope, content, context, and intent of Gunn's tweets and make our judgments based on the facts of the case and not what we saw on Twitter or Reddit or a Breitbart article. For instance, it's not true that Gunn deleted 10,000 tweets about pedophilia.

In fact, the total number of incriminating or offensive tweets that Mike Cernovich and his goons unearthed between 8:49 p.m. on July 19 and 3:04 a.m. on July 20 (plus however long they'd already been digging prior to announcing their intentions) was 38.

That's including not just pedophilia and rape jokes but every offensive and objectionable joke they could find, and also a few that were actually completely innocuous but they retweeted anyway for some reason. These tweets span from June 2008 to December 2014 (well actually December 2012 because there's nothing incriminating about the 2014 tweet, they just pretended there was). I've compiled them here in chronological order, unedited except to censor two unfortunate slurs. I've also included my own commentary to lend context or elaboration where it seemed appropriate. Needless to say, trigger warning for rape and pedophilia.

https://amp.reddit.com/r/marvelstud...0_jokes_about_rape/?__twitter_impression=true
 

Nappuccino

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
13,015
Have you seen the Last Jedi?
The movie is flawless, so I realize now that following my suggestion is a fool's errand.

Edit: seriously though, I hope the content of this post catches on with news media. It highlights these jokes as more than just baseless attempts at humor. And the actual context is sad and troubling.
 

corasaur

Member
Oct 26, 2017
3,988
wow. i figured the edgy humor was just edgy humor, but it makes a lot of sense to hear it could've been a coping mechanism. how sad.

fuck cernovich.
 

Deleted member 15326

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,219
I'd hope some of the posters calling Gunn and anyone not on board with his firing a pedophile take a look but not holding my breath
 

Zubz

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,565
no
Oh wow... this is a layer that I didn't see coming. Fuck Disney for what they did to Gunn.
 

Alice

Banned
Nov 2, 2017
5,867
Seeing as we have like 5 or 6 posters already derailing this topic I'm not even sure what to think.

I've been arguing my ass off against the people he's talking about, and the link Zatt is reporting about is old news to most people partaking in the discussion.

My drive to leave a light hearted joke took over for a second, because I'd already said my dues on the article.. and dealt with people cherry picking tweets in order to disregard it fully.

Either way, sorry for the derail.
 

Dullahan

Always bets on black
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
7,410
I'm still fucking angry at that fuck Cernovich for literally blacking out parts of Gunn's tweets, obscuring punchlines to shitty jokes, to make him look like a pedophile. Shitty jokes sure. But fuck the fake outrage.

As for the article, I read it when it was posted in the other topic and I feel like everyone should read it. It's really eye opening and really well written. Disney fucked up so hard on this.
 
OP
OP
ZattMurdock

ZattMurdock

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
10,333
Earth 616

I find it interesting how some seem to hint that they'd like threads that actually shed a light on this situation locked. I wonder why.

I wasnt aware of any of thos before, thanks for the detailed OP.

You're welcome. It's not a thread that I wish we were talking about, but I think that in the light of the literal character assassination of James Gunn by an alt-right mob, putting things in context is the least we should do.
 

Deleted member 15326

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,219
Not really. They're both about the James Gunn situation outside of the main James Gunn discussion thread

K

Defending Gunn is less about drawing some deal-breaking moral line and more about defending the assumed right of White men to do or say shitty things in the name of edginess and provocation and escape judgment or punishment.

I'm kind of tired of being labeled a supporter of white mediocrity among other things for thinking Gunn got shafted but people can go off if they need to
 

Messofanego

Member
Oct 25, 2017
26,158
UK
People who have watched his films and followed him from the Troma days knew most of this context but I'm glad more people get to see where his tweets were coming from. As a victim of molestation at a young age, I also had a liking for dark humour as a way to cope.

It's just too bad people took the word from a charged rapist over James' own context.
 

painey

Member
Oct 27, 2017
3,617
edit: a dissenting opinion that isn't worth leaving up for the arguments it would drag me into.
 
Last edited:

janoGX

Banned
Nov 29, 2017
2,453
Chile
the incredible lengths people have been going to in order to defend unfunny jokes because it jeopardizes a movie they want to watch is incredible. Dunn could have kicked a schoolboy in front of a bus and people would defend him if the 'alt-right' were the ones who told the police.


Don't try to make a fight here. Seriously.
 

Cuburger

Member
Oct 28, 2017
10,975
It also came through in Gunn's art that he either was the victim of some sort of abuse or was in some way intimately familiar with what people that have gone through it feel like.

Lindsay Ellis' video essay on GotG vol. 2 does a good breakdown of how the film deals with those sorts of themes.



In light of Gunn's own statements about his past experience with abuse, it really drives home for me how wrong this situation was handled and the fucked up irony of it all; whether it's people trying to assassinate his character through baseless accusations of behavior that he himself was a victim of, or whether it's the story of the Guardians who have all come from some sort of abuse and are trying to heal and find love as adults, to break the chain of abuse and find redemption for the hurtful things they may have done in the past.

If this was about a fallout over creative differences or Gunn was accused of really vile and hurtful behavior or many other valid reasons why someone would be fired or abruptly leave a position directing a movie like that, I would have accepted it. I really like the GotG films, but even I think of what it would be like if someone else was able to take the reigns on that universe. This story is like the opposite of a scandal where every rock you overturn brings up more ugliness about a person's past; here it's like the more I learn about Gunn as a person, the more I realize that Disney really made a mistake.
 
OP
OP
ZattMurdock

ZattMurdock

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
10,333
Earth 616
the incredible lengths people have been going to in order to defend unfunny jokes because it jeopardizes a movie they want to watch is incredible.

If that's what you really think people like me are pissed off about, you should really try to look further the Disney / MCU / fandom bullshit and understand this: this is way bigger than stupid superhero films. Fuck Disney at this point. This is about contextualizing the fact that a victim of child abuse was fired by tweets that made out of context jokes about child abuse. Yes, they were shitty jokes, but I'm sure that somewhere inside you you can empathize with that and realize why that's wrong. Fuck Marvel and Disney at this point, this is bigger than people playing fandom wars.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.