• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Status
Not open for further replies.

HarryDemeanor

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,422
Is it me or did Baltimore get a HAUL for Machado rental?
I'm actually surprised the Orioles didn't get any major position players in the deal. I thought Joc or Logan would've been sent over along with some prospects.

It's also a deal I never would've thought Friedman/Zaidi would do considering the amount of prospects.
 

TheeFanatic

Member
Oct 26, 2017
16,753
I think you missed the part where Soria has actually been good this year, and shields has been solid for the most part since the start of May :P (shields is worth .8 WAR on baseball reference Soria is also worth .8 WAR while Forsythe is worth -.5)

not saying shields is great, but he would be a good 5th starter on most teams right now and even a 4th on some (he is like a 3rd on the white sox lol)

both players legit have value to a pitching staff.

now if you really want a player worth Forsythe the white sox recently released Bruce Rondón :P

In general I am not expecting the white sox to get a ton for Soria or Shields, but a decent 5th starter to help eat innings and keep a team in the games should be worth at least a long shot A prospect, and a closer with a 2.75 ERA should be worth a bit more, but again not a ton because he isn't elite anymore.

with not a ton of room on the salary cap both could be decent under the radar pick ups, especially since if the dodgers sweetened the trade a bit there is little doubt the white sox would be willing to eat money since they are far from their budget limit.

I doubt any other players from the white sox could be gotten at a price that would make sense for the dodgers.
I mean you could get Luis Avilán back for little to nothing but he isn't really worth anything.
Xavier Cedeño might be able to be grabbed for cheap and is doing well so far, but I imagine the white sox are hoping he continues to pitch well and can move him during the off season for a bit more.
I really don't know what the Dodgers are going to do. Urias started throwing and RYU should be back this season. Most likely Baez will be back so that's three pitchers right there. Well that's if Urias comes back
 

zulux21

Member
Oct 25, 2017
20,347
I really don't know what the Dodgers are going to do. Urias started throwing and RYU should be back this season. Most likely Baez will be back so that's three pitchers right there. Well that's if Urias comes back
That's why I mentioned the two from the white sox I did. I have a feeling those two will both move before the trade deadline, won't demand a large return, and could provide good value to a team going for a playoff push. They won't be key swing players, but not every move needs to be a huge splash and for some of these races a player that helps them win one more game might be the difference between winning the division and being a wild card team.

I am curious if we see anyone try to make a big splash in general though. Trading the farm for a young top of the rotation starter with many years of control left. I imagine at least one will move given the lack of big name starters on the trade market in general. Should be an interesting last 13 days of the month.

Is it me or did Baltimore get a HAUL for Machado rental?

they got a ton for a rental especially when you compare to what the tigers got for JD last year. But JD was just a high impact bat while machado has historically been valuable both with a bat and on defense (though not so much this year on defense)

Beyond that though, aside from the top 100 prospect, most of the rest are people with potential to become regulars in the majors but far from a sure thing.

Machado was an in demand position, that most teams could use an upgrade at, and while it was likely an overpay for purely his talent, at the same time keeping that from their rivials is worth something.

the dodgers are only a half game in front of arizona, 2 in front of colorado, and 4 in front of the giants.
beyond those teams, machado would have been a huge upgrade to the brewers, a team they could be fighting against down the stretch for a wild card spot.

as I mentioned in an earlier post, a win or two could easily make the difference on if you win the division or are in the wild card race. So even though they paid a lot, and might only get a win or two extra for having machado, one of their rivals now won't get a win or two more from him which could easily impact the final standings.
 
Last edited:

jacks81x

Self-requested ban
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
2,460
NYC
Wow, the Indians just moved a big step closer to the Red Sox and Astros in the AL. BP was their one big weakness. Hand can get righties and lefties out and can also pitch multiple innings. Great get for the Indians.
 

Deleted member 33887

User requested account closure
Banned
Nov 20, 2017
2,109
every team that makes the playoffs has a legit shot, I dont understand why people still dont understand this.

plus the cubs, dodgers, and Indians are still pretty stacked. on paper those 3 teams aren't as far off from the top 3 AL teams as records imply. people just have a hard time looking past win-loss records and past performance.

I mean, it's my opinion. I also thought the 116 win Mariners were paper tigers. The year the NL Central had three really strong teams the weakest of the three slipped through and then lost the World Series, and that didn't surprise me too much (except I expected the Pirates to be the team to drop the World Series).

It is pretty rare you get teams as well rounded as the Red Sox and Astros. Teams like that rarely screw up in the World Series. My guess is the NL's best chance is the Yankees slipping through, then promptly striking out every at bat and struggling to generate any runs.

I don't literally think there is a 0% chance the NL wins, but it doesn't seem like the odds are that great given what we currently know. Usually pitching might give the NL a better chance than expected, but the big three AL teams all have pitching in line with the best NL teams, and the Astros are at the tippity top.
 

EJS

The Fallen - Self Requested Ban
Banned
Oct 31, 2017
9,176
Wow. Cleveland is really going for it. They've been playing good baseball lately but I feel like the Sox, Astros, and Yankees all are even better than last year.

But yeah, Cleveland seriously needed help in the pen so this is a reasonable get, going even beyond this season.
 

NinjaScooter

Member
Oct 25, 2017
54,121
Is it me or did Baltimore get a HAUL for Machado rental?

I mean, they got quantity but I don't know that id describe it as a "haul". They got one Top 100 guy who projects as a average regular, and 4 lottery tickets who you may or may never hear from again. It's probably about in line with what you would expect to get back for a 3 month rental. Baltimore remains absolutely stupid for not trading him 6-12 months ago.
 
Oct 28, 2017
751
Holy shit, Cleveland's going all in, aren't they? It's a shame to lose Mejia, but I feel better about our playoff chances than I did yesterday.
 

Sanjuro

Member
Oct 25, 2017
31,010
Massachusetts
Just picked up my hot weiners shirt!

20180719_143440.jpg
 

Sanjuro

Member
Oct 25, 2017
31,010
Massachusetts

Frozenprince

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
9,158
We'd better trade Familia and whatever other BP assets we see as expendable. If Brad Hand and a throw in with "team control" fetch a top-20 two way catching prospect, something the Mets were in dire need for, then we should at least get a top-10 guy from someones system for Familia considering he's better than Hand.

If we trade everybody for more salary relief again I might blow a blood vessel. Now is the time to sell as high as we can (because we fucked up in 2016 and missed the window to trade Familia and Reed at the height of their value and the RP market).
 

Frozenprince

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
9,158
Man if I'm David Stearns today I'm kicking myself, Corey Ray and Luis Ortiz could have gotten that deal for Machado done and Ray is in that Brinson vein of "will his offense translate with that swing".
 

Malo

Chicken Chaser
Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,153
Bronx, NY
Man if I'm David Stearns today I'm kicking myself, Corey Ray and Luis Ortiz could have gotten that deal for Machado done and Ray is in that Brinson vein of "will his offense translate with that swing".
Ray isn't as good a prospect as Diaz is. And if Duquette is to be believed, Diaz was the best player offered by any team.

Makes me wonder what Cash offered.
 

zulux21

Member
Oct 25, 2017
20,347
Holy shit, Cleveland's going all in, aren't they? It's a shame to lose Mejia, but I feel better about our playoff chances than I did yesterday.
Their run isn't going to last forever.
by 2020 the AL central will likely be very competitive as the white sox will likely have unleashed all of their top prospects and picked up people from FA by then, and the Tigers won't be far behind.

KC will likely suck for a while (they started the rebuild to late), but the Twins could also turn it around pretty quickly.

you might as well go in on a year where you are almost guaranteed to make the playoffs at this point, rather than hope for the future where you will likely be facing harder competition.
 

zulux21

Member
Oct 25, 2017
20,347
The Tigers are really f###ed now.
how so?

there is a strong FA class coming this offseason and a decent looking one after that.

the tigers can go up to a 200 mil payroll and started this season at 125.
they will have about 100 mil to spend next off season which will allow them to buy a number of position players they need, and have a decent amount of pitching talent in the minors.

they aren't in amazing shape, but they should be able to rebuild into a contender pretty quickly.

It would kind of suck for New York or Boston if they lost a Wild Card game after their seasons.

it's a shame they both can't lose a wild card game >.>
 

HomokHarcos

Member
Jul 11, 2018
2,447
Canada
how so?

there is a strong FA class coming this offseason and a decent looking one after that.

the tigers can go up to a 200 mil payroll and started this season at 125.
they will have about 100 mil to spend next off season which will allow them to buy a number of position players they need, and have a decent amount of pitching talent in the minors.

they aren't in amazing shape, but they should be able to rebuild into a contender pretty quickly.



it's a shame they both can't lose a wild card game >.>
I was more specifically talking about this season. The Tigers are a bit behind Cleveland and now with the Indians additions it looks like the division is wrapped up.
 

Deleted member 2785

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
2,119
The secret answer is no but it's Cleveland's problem now to figure out that Hand throws like 90% hard sliders and is a huge health risk.

I'm with you here. Having watched Hand a lot this year, he's really a one pitch wonder and hasn't been pitching as well as his results would suggest. Some of the stuff on Twitter saying that Hand gives the Indians a division the next couple years is making me shake my head.
 

zulux21

Member
Oct 25, 2017
20,347
I was more specifically talking about this season. The Tigers are a bit behind Cleveland and now with the Indians additions it looks like the division is wrapped up.
uh... the tigers haven't been in the playoff picture for a long time. (any tiny bit of playoff chance they had died on june 12th)

you have a funny definition of a bit, as 12.5 games back at the all star break is anything but a bit.

I mean... they only have 62 games left.

to even get back to 500 they would need to go 39-23

if the indians went 1 game over .500 from here on out (aka 33-32) it would require the tigers to go 44-18 to catch them lol.

I'm with you here. Having watched Hand a lot this year, he's really a one pitch wonder and hasn't been pitching as well as his results would suggest. Some of the stuff on Twitter saying that Hand gives the Indians a division the next couple years is making me shake my head.

yeah.... I don't think people realize exactly how much talent the white sox have in the wings right now (they have 8 of the top 100 still in the minors and most of them are expected by the end of next year), and how some of the talent that is currently in the majors is showing a ton of improvement.


It's possible a lot of the talent ends up being a bust, but they aren't nearly as bad of a team as they seem. It doesn't help that two of the bigger offensive forces on the team have been lost for most of the season. Granted one of those was the catcher who was cheating, but still.

It will be interesting to see who the white sox pick up this off season. They are targeting 2020 for the team to get together, but it wouldn't be surprising if they picked up some pieces this off season.

I also wouldn't be surprised to see the white sox involved in a trade or two during the deadline here. It's possible they could want to shift around some of that talent as that is a lot of right handed pitching and outfield help. Though 9th in their org is a 3rd baseman (currently hurt) and at second and short they are set for like 5 more years. 1st is a bit of an issue, but another couple years with abreu wouldn't be horrible.
 
Last edited:

Angry Grimace

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
11,539
I'm with you here. Having watched Hand a lot this year, he's really a one pitch wonder and hasn't been pitching as well as his results would suggest. Some of the stuff on Twitter saying that Hand gives the Indians a division the next couple years is making me shake my head.
Well the AL Central maybe.

Dude throws like 80% sliders and bullpen dudes seem to come out of nowhere so it seems like a desperation overpay even if I want Hand to do well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.