• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.

KHarvey16

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
9,193
Eh it is perfectly reasonable to assert that the US has been one of the main causes of human misery in foreign countries around the globe since the 90s. What is not reasonable is to expect that Russia wouldn't do the same at the very least and probably even worse. Citing US imperialism to justify the destabilization of democracy for Russian gain is ridiculous. You don't have to pick either lmao. Both are shit.

Russia is right now worse than the US by pretty much any measure. To argue otherwise is to not know what's going on. That doesn't mean the US is perfect.

This is very much not ludicrous when US is now still fight shadow wars all over Africa, still in Afghanistan, and destroyed Iraq and Libya. They are all terrible but I know it's the usual 'it's not bad if we do it' narrative you and I are usually at odds with. You're talking about hacking and I'm talking about human lives taken by signature drone strikes.

They annexed another province and yeah, that's fucked up. But again, we're no better. We're occupying Northeastern Syria being salty over a multi-billion dollar regime change attempt that didn't work out and neglecting our own little piece of annexed territory.

We can do this all day. But the point is, the US is absolutely no matter and that's a fact. I won't budge on that.

That's just ignorance. If you're telling me you're just as well off living in Russia as you are in the US, you're either lying or you have no idea what's actually happening in the world.

Haven't you noticed everyone is so afraid of the shit Trump is doing because it looks like he's trying to emulate in small parts the sorts of things Putin does regularly and with impunity? Jailing reporters and dissidents, killing opponents, annexing countries, treating LBGTQ and minorities in ways that make the US look like a utopia, etc, etc, etc. That is all real and happening.
 

Shadowrun

Member
Oct 26, 2017
1,748
They annexed another province and yeah, that's fucked up. But again, we're no better. We're occupying Northeastern Syria being salty over a multi-billion dollar regime change attempt that didn't work out and neglecting our own little piece of annexed territory.

We can do this all day. But the point is, the US is absolutely no matter and that's a fact. I won't budge on that.

The 'Who's Worse' game was, maybe, a fun one to play under the Clinton/Bush/Obama presidency, but today, it really does not matter whatsoever. We're no longer dealing with two Superpowers with their own conflicting agendas, doing their own dirt; we're dealing with two Superpowers beginning to operate in concert.

And, I think we can all agree that Russia and the USA working together is unequivocally worse for the entire world.
 

Wiifitkid

Member
Mar 12, 2018
340
Snowden wasn't headed for Russia, he was going to Ecuador (on Julien Assange's recommendation), but Hong Kong didn't have a direct flight to Ecuador available, while Russia did, so he was going to bounce from Hong Kong to Russia to Ecuador, but then America revoked his passport while he was in the air between Hong Kong and Russia, and he got trapped in Russia as soon as his plane landed.

America pretty much handed Snowden over to Russia.
Was there really no better way to get to Ecuador than Russia? I mean even if it wasnt Snowdens intention, he had to know how that looked
 

VectorPrime

Banned
Apr 4, 2018
11,781
It's still extremely unlikely that votes were tampered with guys. The way electioneering works in the US makes any attempt to do so implausible. The more realistic possibility is registration data was fucked with but it's impossible to know on what scale.

The insidious nature of the Russian interference wasn't that they directly cheated, it's that they were able to sway people into doing their bidding on their own free will.
 

ThreePi

Member
Dec 7, 2017
4,766
Trumps incredible number of references to wiki leaks always struck me back in late 2016.

No way that fucker didn't know what was going on in the background..

For the longest time I figured Trump himself was isolated from the collusion with Russia. He was a useful idiot and the actual criminal acts were his campaign staff, Kushner, Tweedledee and Tweedledum, and the various hangers-on around him. But the degree to which WikiLeaks is involved and how frequently Trump himself brings them up in the campaign is just a sign that it is impossible that he didn't know what was going on.
 

Wiifitkid

Member
Mar 12, 2018
340
That's not what I'm saying at all. I hope you guys understand that by multipolarity, I'm not talking about swapping one for the other.
Multipolarity could very well lead to more world wars.
But yeah, if we were say making countries like Argentina, South Africa and Australia equal powers I could understand. But Russia is one of the worst functioning nation states in the world, imho.
 
Oct 25, 2017
4,293
Russia is right now worse than the US by pretty much any measure. To argue otherwise is to not know what's going on. That doesn't mean the US is perfect.

Let's not pretend like huge parts of this statement are in the context of US propaganda that has, for an incredibly long time, been intensely based on justifying US intervention as a war on terrorism with zero basis in reality. Maybe you consider the attacks and wars stemming from that reasonable. I don't and I consider them war crimes. If you agree with me on that point then it is really hard to argue that Russia has (not for lack of trying, certainly) been worse than the US by any measure aside from LGBT, feminist etc progress – I am assuming we're strictly talking about foreign policy here. Now, if by "right now" you mean literally "right now" as in like... this past year? Maybe you're right? But to what end? Many of the conflicts we are seeing now stem directly from recent US intervention. Just because the US may or may not technically backed out doesn't mean they're not involved. Take the Israel/Palestine conflict for crying out loud. There are ongoing crimes against humanity getting a complete pass because the US continually both arms Israel and vetoes any motions within UN councils to hold the Israeli government accountable for anything. I would posit that that conflict alone overshadows anything Russia has done recently and pretending like the US isn't a huge (or indeed the biggest) part of the reason it is happening is incredibly disingenuous, even if it isn't officially being done by the US directly.

But whatever, I'm sure we agree on the larger point of this thread and that is that both the US and Russia should stay the fuck out of terrorizing other countries and that allowing Russia to take over the US and other western countries with extreme right-wing regimes is damaging to everyone and needs to be stopped right now. Whatever the US has been doing since the 90s certainly won't improve under either fascist regimes like the Trump administration or under Russia.
 

Jackpot

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
1,827
User banned (3 days): off-site sleuthing
Nah, man. The "Russia sympathizer" meme comes from the Sunken Place (the old forum).

Actually, I think it comes from you:

mod edit: don't go playing internet detectives by bringing up stuff from the old site

ad nauseum

And that's before we get into your defense of Russian-proxies like Assad, going so far as trot out the same fabricated talking-points used by Russian trolls farms to defend the use of chemical weapon strikes on civilians.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Sho_Nuff82

Member
Nov 14, 2017
18,413


WikiLeaks said:
Interesting timing choice by DoJ today (right before Trump-Putin meet), announcing indictments against 12 alleged Russian intelligence officers for allegedly releasing info through DCLeaks and Guccifer 2.0

Now they want to talk about timing.
 

Deleted member 19003

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
3,809
Actually, I think it comes from you:
mod edit: don't go playing internet detectives by bringing up stuff from the old site



ad nauseum

And that's before we get into your defense of Russian-proxies like Assad, with full blown crisis actor conspiracy theories and defense of chemical weapon strikes on civilians.
Phew, someone brought the receipts out. Bravo.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

TheOMan

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
7,118
Actually, I think it comes from you:
mod edit: don't go playing internet detectives by bringing up stuff from the old site



ad nauseum

And that's before we get into your defense of Russian-proxies like Assad, with full blown crisis actor conspiracy theories and defense of chemical weapon strikes on civilians.

Yikes. That...is not a good look. Why such the strong defense of clearly horrible activities by the Russian government?
 
Last edited by a moderator:

VectorPrime

Banned
Apr 4, 2018
11,781
Actually, I think it comes from you:
mod edit: don't go playing internet detectives by bringing up stuff from the old site

ad nauseum

And that's before we get into your defense of Russian-proxies like Assad, with full blown crisis actor conspiracy theories and defense of chemical weapon strikes on civilians.

Wow. Nice work.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Oct 27, 2017
7,885
Actually, I think it comes from you:
mod edit: don't go playing internet detectives by bringing up stuff from the old site

ad nauseum

And that's before we get into your defense of Russian-proxies like Assad, with full blown crisis actor conspiracy theories and defense of chemical weapon strikes on civilians.

Yeah, this chud isn't fooling anyone. It's pretty obvious Mr. West Philly prefers his tyrants of the Slavic variety. The fact that WL and Putin have no compunction with beating on minorities is just a little collateral damage in their search for Utopia
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Oct 25, 2017
2,899
Ontario
People in this thread clinging to "who's worse" as if geopolitical reality is manifested based on who's a good guy and who's a bad guy are looking solidly out of their depth.
The US has been demanding its way to friend and enemy alike well before Trump. American interference to support a corporate pillaging of the emerging Russian federation did a lot to create the oligarchs place of power in Russia today. If the US has a problem with Russia acting aggressively within a perceived sphere of influence maybe they should have set a better example over the last 50 years as to limiting aggression.
That isn't to say that it would not be a good thing to have America's current mess sorted out with a hypothetically positive American influence remaining strong into the future, but in the here and now it is straight up disrespectful in my mind to try and equivocate the consequences of America's overseas interventions with the internal repressions of an illiberal state when talking about the international consequences of state action.
 
Phew, someone brought the receipts out. Bravo.
Yikes. That...is not a good look. Why such the strong defense of clearly horrible activities by the Russian government?
Yeah, this chud isn't fooling anyone. It's pretty obvious Mr. West Philly prefers his tyrants of the Slavic variety. The fact that WL and Putin have no compunction with beating on minorities is just a little collateral damage in their search for Utopia
Not really impressive. I don't feel the same way about a lot of that stuff anymore.

My post history is open for all to see.
That's just ignorance. If you're telling me you're just as well off living in Russia as you are in the US, you're either lying or you have no idea what's actually happening in the world.

Haven't you noticed everyone is so afraid of the shit Trump is doing because it looks like he's trying to emulate in small parts the sorts of things Putin does regularly and with impunity? Jailing reporters and dissidents, killing opponents, annexing countries, treating LBGTQ and minorities in ways that make the US look like a utopia, etc, etc, etc. That is all real and happening.
No, you're being ignorant here. You're talking to a Black man in America. US is just as bad. Period.

I don't need to list war with you. This stuff speaks for itself.
 

Wiifitkid

Member
Mar 12, 2018
340
People in this thread clinging to "who's worse" as if geopolitical reality is manifested based on who's a good guy and who's a bad guy are looking solidly out of their depth.
The US has been demanding its way to friend and enemy alike well before Trump. American interference to support a corporate pillaging of the emerging Russian federation did a lot to create the oligarchs place of power in Russia today. If the US has a problem with Russia acting aggressively within a perceived sphere of influence maybe they should have set a better example over the last 50 years as to limiting aggression.
That isn't to say that it would not be a good thing to have America's current mess sorted out with a hypothetically positive American influence remaining strong into the future, but in the here and now it is straight up disrespectful in my mind to try and equivocate the consequences of America's overseas interventions with the internal repressions of an illiberal state when talking about the international consequences of state action.
All states work to maximize and exert their power. Its cruel but its the way the system works.

That doesn't mean that the majority of the world isn't better off with the US being the super power instead of Putins Russia.
 
I knew your username was familiar. What a convenient time to change a mind.
You don't know when I changed my mind.
Multipolarity could very well lead to more world wars.
But yeah, if we were say making countries like Argentina, South Africa and Australia equal powers I could understand. But Russia is one of the worst functioning nation states in the world, imho.
That's true too. And that's a very real limitation. It's not like I'm saying Russia *has* to be one of the nodes but it's just how the current situation presents itself at the moment (even if it's just militarily for them - they aren't a superpower in my opinion
If you don't think you're better off in the US you should travel more. Your opinion on this can't even smell correct from where it lives.
That's a strawman. My argument is not about where l'd be better off. And frankly, the "go live somewhere else" thing is very uncomforting to hear in the current political climate. I know that's not what you're saying, but just in case you were thinking it. As far as traveling, I'm already on my second passport and the first one needed to have extra pages sown in. Ive been all over the planet (still need to hit Southeast and East Asia). Traveling definitely had an impression on my worldview. And certainly have the stamps to prove it.
Funny how this chud likes to ignore both Putin and WL total disregard for LGBTQI safety. So much for FreedumbFighter's intersectionality cred
We still name-calling I see. Cool. But we never had a convo about sexual minorities though. I'm not ignoring any of that stuff at all, I know how hard LGBTQIA have it many societies. And this is not zero-sum. By pointing out US shortfalls, I'm not saying the others are better. In fact, the discussion went the other way with KHarvey and Kirblar saying the US wasn't as bad and me disagreeing with a list of my own. I explained my position on this.
 
Last edited:
Nov 7, 2017
1,476
Fresh reminder that they threw Reality Winner under the jail for even suggesting such a thing might be possible. If even one vote was altered, we will not hear about it before the 2020 elections are over and done with.
I think the election was surely hacked and altered, but releasing that info would be too massive for people to comprehend and the ramifications of it would be incredibly damaging.

I still remember Diane Feinstein and co looking completely shocked and freaked out after her briefing on the election hacking matters.
 

KHarvey16

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
9,193
You don't know when I changed my mind.

That's true too. And that's a very real limitation. It's not like I'm saying Russia *has* to be one of the nodes but it's just how the current situation presents itself at the moment (even if it's just militarily for them - they aren't a superpower in my opinion

That's a strawman. My argument is not about where l'd be better off. And frankly, the "go live somewhere else" thing is very uncomforting to hear in the current political climate. I know that's not what you're saying, but just in case you were thinking it. As far as traveling, I'm already on my second passport and the first one needed to have extra pages sown in. Ive been all over the planet (still need to hit Southeast and East Asia). Traveling definitely had an impression on my worldview. And certainly have the stamps to prove it.

Well if you think the US and Russia are on the same level with regards to how they treat people you either didn't spend much or any time there or didn't pay enough attention. It's an objective fact what you're saying makes no sense. Putin is worse than even Trump, never mind a normal president. The comparison to how the two countries are run couldn't be more stark.

Have you ever listened to someone like Gary Kasparov? You go look and see if he thinks the US and Russia are on equal footing here.
 
Well if you think the US and Russia are on the same level with regards to how they treat people you either didn't spend much or any time there or didn't pay enough attention. It's an objective fact what you're saying makes no sense. Putin is worse than even Trump, never mind a normal president. The comparison to how the two countries are run couldn't be more stark.

Have you ever listened to someone like Gary Kasparov? You go look and see if he thinks the US and Russia are on equal footing here.
No, I just think we have different experiences, and thus, have different perspectives on the matter.
And again, you can't even name Russia as you try to Both Sides the issue at hand. You've been exposed. Sad!
Uhm, not sure what you're on about here but ok.
 
Oct 25, 2017
2,722
Can we get back to indictments now? Because that's kind of the topic here, with all this distraction taking away from the fact that Guccifer 2.0 and Wikileaks are now literally on the table.

What is actually a lot more amusing in this context is that Drumpf must have been briefed before going to the UK, where these links relate to the Brexit fallout as well. No wonder he suddenly 'wanted' a hard Brexit, like a good little puppet.
Man, fiction writers on political shows are going to have a hard time topping this timeline.