• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Cerium

The Former
Member
Oct 23, 2017
1,741
Cross posting:
Hi all,

Giftbot is back up after a short break!

We just completed an upgrade for Giftbot to add anti-abuse functionality and ensure that more members will have a chance to win. Some of you brought it to our attention that there are users who unfortunately exploited Giftbot's kindness in ways that go against the spirit of community and generosity.

The new features are as follows:
  • Added a lengthy cooldown period after a user wins before they are eligible to win another gift.
  • Implemented an internal blacklist of Giftbot abusers. This tiny minority of users are no longer eligible to win any gifts.
Thanks everyone for your patience while we implemented these changes!
 

Musubi

Unshakable Resolve - Prophet of Truth
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
23,611
Shiit. I apologize to everyone who saw the gift bot posts and got an invalid code. I tried using gift bot the other day when originally posted them and had no idea that it was apparently down. It must have auto posted those since I had sent it PM's. :(
 

Ja-

The Fallen
Oct 30, 2017
1,028
Next up is having "pay it forward/givers only" giveaways and manual blocking.
 

SRV

▲ Legend ▲
Member
Oct 29, 2017
2,390
Shiit. I apologize to everyone who saw the gift bot posts and got an invalid code. I tried using gift bot the other day when originally posted them and had no idea that it was apparently down. It must have auto posted those since I had sent it PM's. :(
It's all good, appreciate it all the same!
 

Myradeer

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,427
Canada
Yup. I guess the intent is to prevent new abuse strategy, but obstfucation of detail is rather inconvenient for what's essentially a convenience tool.
 
Last edited:

Deleted member 45

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 24, 2017
338
Hi all,

I've answered some questions in the Giftbot thread re: cooldown, and am chiming in here as well!

The key points are:
  • Currently, the cooldown is 1 month. This cooldown only takes effect after a user wins a gift.
  • The only people on the blacklist are severe abusers of Giftbot.
These are users who would follow Giftbot from thread to thread (regardless of whether they've ever posted there), enter every raffle, amass significantly more wins than the average, and would never give back to the community with their own giveaways.

It's a tiny list (less than 10 individuals). This wasn't undertaken lightly, and it involved a concerted effort on our part to cross-reference user activity to ensure that no one was placed on the list who didn't belong there. This was done in response to repeated complaints from the communities about these types of abusers.

Let me know if you have any questions!
 

GiftBot

Official Giveaway Bot
Verified
Mar 7, 2018
11,833
Hello, I am a bot! I come bearing 1 gifts from Spamlynguist!

This is a first come first serve giveaway. The first user with a valid entry will win the prize!

How to Participate:

To enter this giveaway click here to send a private message to me, GiftBot, with the subject line entry.

In the message body, copy and paste the entire line below for the prize you wish to win. You are allowed only 1 entry per giveaway.

Available Prizes:

Asteroid Bounty Hunter -- GB-86fb8281-3ff4-4799-9cd6-7feeba11ceea - Won by retrobotjr
 
Last edited:

Illusionary

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,612
Manchester, UK
Shiit. I apologize to everyone who saw the gift bot posts and got an invalid code. I tried using gift bot the other day when originally posted them and had no idea that it was apparently down. It must have auto posted those since I had sent it PM's. :(
Don't worry about it, these things happen. It's a bit of a shame to be blocked from others for a month, but nothing's lost and everything will still find a home somewhere. Thanks for the generous thought in the first place!
 

GiftBot

Official Giveaway Bot
Verified
Mar 7, 2018
11,833
Hello, I am a bot! I come bearing 3 gifts from Corine!

This is a raffle that will expire in a day. The winner will be drawn at random! Any prizes leftover after the deadline will become available on a first-come first-serve basis.

t1531427829z0.png


How to Participate:

To enter this giveaway click here to send a private message to me, GiftBot, with the subject line entry.

In the message body, copy and paste the entire line below for the prize you wish to win. You are allowed only 1 entry per giveaway.

Available Prizes:

Conan Exiles(PC) -- GB-1ff39ca6-c863-430c-aca0-0917478f9fd5 - Won by MonsterJail
Portal Knights(PC) -- GB-b57cb475-f50a-4bb7-825d-4f417a4730f9 - Won by OmegaDL50
Titan Quest: Anniversary Edition + Titan Quest: Ragnarok DLC(PC) -- GB-70fa722e-c144-42b2-9b21-027d717271c9 - Won by ClownsAreATen
 
Last edited:

Deleted member 45

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 24, 2017
338
Don't worry about it, these things happen. It's a bit of a shame to be blocked from others for a month, but nothing's lost and everything will still find a home somewhere. Thanks for the generous thought in the first place!

Musubi Can you reach out to me with the link to your giveaway. I'll make sure the people who won do not get it counted as a win, due to the extenuating cirumstances.
 

SRV

▲ Legend ▲
Member
Oct 29, 2017
2,390
Musubi Can you reach out to me with the link to your giveaway. I'll make sure the people who won do not get it counted as a win, due to the extenuating cirumstances.
Hello, I am a bot! I come bearing 4 gifts from Musubi!

This is a first come first serve giveaway. The first user with a valid entry will win the prize!

How to Participate:

To enter this giveaway click here to send a private message to me, GiftBot, with the subject line entry.

In the message body, copy and paste the entire line below for the prize you wish to win. You are allowed only 1 entry per giveaway.

Available Prizes:

Forts -- GB-49ff0c78-063a-4343-99c3-56cefa04b3b4 - Won by Kanito8a
Interplanetary Enhanced Edition -- GB-f5913713-9812-40ea-95d0-6334c856f2c4 - Won by SRV
Shiness The Lightning Kingdom -- GB-de3d8fa2-bfe6-4ca3-8947-2175befad8ea - Won by Illusionary
Titan Quest Anniversary Edition -- GB-e6d57b27-6509-45dd-8a3a-bebf6d4cbcc8 - Won by Vipu
 

Vivian-Pogo

Member
Jan 9, 2018
2,033
At least the 1 month cooldown will mean people only enter for things they really want.

It would suck if you end up getting an accidentally used code as your win though.
 

fspm

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
1,086
Hi all,

I've answered some questions in the Giftbot thread re: cooldown, and am chiming in here as well!

The key points are:
  • Currently, the cooldown is 1 month. This cooldown only takes effect after a user wins a gift.
  • The only people on the blacklist are severe abusers of Giftbot.
I'll make sure the people who won do not get it counted as a win, due to the extenuating cirumstances.
Just like no restrictions one month cool down is another kind of extreme. Which leads to the the part where someone has to manually take care of expired, already used, mixed up keys etc.
 

ASaiyan

Member
Oct 25, 2017
7,228
One month seems like a long time for a win cooldown. I totally understand the intention though.

Maybe consider shortening it to a week, or 10 days? That's my suggestion anyway.
 

low-G

Member
Oct 25, 2017
8,144
One month is OK by me. People will have a greater chance of winning something they actually want, and nobody can be too greedy.
 

Myradeer

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,427
Canada
The key points are:
  • Currently, the cooldown is 1 month. This cooldown only takes effect after a user wins a gift.
  • The only people on the blacklist are severe abusers of Giftbot.
These are users who would follow Giftbot from thread to thread (regardless of whether they've ever posted there), enter every raffle, amass significantly more wins than the average, and would never give back to the community with their own giveaways.
Thank you for prompt response! Only improvement I could suggest is that to keep a month as default cooldown, but also give the users the ability to set custom cooldown length for their own givewaways.
 

GiftBot

Official Giveaway Bot
Verified
Mar 7, 2018
11,833
Hello, I am a bot! I come bearing 1 gifts from Jordyn11!

This is a raffle that will expire in a day. The winner will be drawn at random! Any prizes leftover after the deadline will become available on a first-come first-serve basis.

t1531436830z0.png


How to Participate:

To enter this giveaway click here to send a private message to me, GiftBot, with the subject line entry.

In the message body, copy and paste the entire line below for the prize you wish to win. You are allowed only 1 entry per giveaway.

Available Prizes:

Alpha Protocol Steam Key -- GB-1ca71047-4a0e-4928-9100-38cacc620345 - Won by kinezu
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
Tebunker

Tebunker

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,844
Just like no restrictions one month cool down is another kind of extreme. Which leads to the the part where someone has to manually take care of expired, already used, mixed up keys etc.

One month seems like a long time for a win cooldown. I totally understand the intention though.

Maybe consider shortening it to a week, or 10 days? That's my suggestion anyway.

Yeah, if you win a invalid or already used key would suck

One month is OK by me. People will have a greater chance of winning something they actually want, and nobody can be too greedy.

Guys make sure to give this feedback in the official giftbot thread.

Honestly I think 1 month is fine, I wouldn't go less that 17 or so days. Why? Because you can see in multiple threads some people have won more often than not, like Dusk Golem's thread which went on for weeks and some people won multiples even in that span of time. So a week or ten days isn't really anything. It can be frustrating for some users to see that.
 

GiftBot

Official Giveaway Bot
Verified
Mar 7, 2018
11,833
Hello, I am a bot! I come bearing 3 gifts from Tebunker!

This is a raffle that will expire in 8 hours. The winner will be drawn at random! Any prizes leftover after the deadline will become available on a first-come first-serve basis.

t1531383309z0.png


How to Participate:

To enter this giveaway click here to send a private message to me, GiftBot, with the subject line entry.

In the message body, copy and paste the entire line below for the prize you wish to win. You are allowed only 1 entry per giveaway.

Available Prizes:

Interplanetary Enhanced Edition -- GB-26566781-452e-4548-acc7-1a24cb7949ca - Won by Satanic Saint
Black Wake -- GB-31a835f5-6a0e-489f-ae48-f1d79ad98c25 - Won by Trekkie
Forts -- GB-f561dedb-2cf1-4992-be90-5e00bcf69908 - Won by mikenoob
 
Last edited:

Keym

The Fallen
Oct 26, 2017
9,191
Oh damn, I entered one of the raffles without knowing about the new cooldowns. My bad. :(
 

Deleted member 45

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 24, 2017
338
Guys make sure to give this feedback in the official giftbot thread.

Thanks everyone so much for the feedback! Feel free to drop your feedback in the official Giftbot thread. It helps us keep everything organized so we have a one-stop shop to refer to feedback from.

Honestly I think 1 month is fine, I wouldn't go less that 17 or so days. Why? Because you can see in multiple threads some people have won more often than not, like Dusk Golem's thread which went on for weeks and some people won multiples even in that span of time. So a week or ten days isn't really anything. It can be frustrating for some users to see that.

This was one of the driving factors behind the choice of 1 month, including metrics showing how often people on average win gifts, weighted heavily towards preventing further Giftbot abusers.

We've heard everyone's feedback and will be discussing possible reductions to the cooldown period and other solutions.

Giftbot is constantly changing and is nowhere near close to feature complete. We'll keep you in the loop re: changes and upcoming features!

Again, thanks everyone so much. Giftbot embodies the community's hospitality, kindness, and generous spirit and we're always looking for suggestions and feedback on how to improve!
 

Auto

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
858
Guys make sure to give this feedback in the official giftbot thread.

Honestly I think 1 month is fine, I wouldn't go less that 17 or so days. Why? Because you can see in multiple threads some people have won more often than not, like Dusk Golem's thread which went on for weeks and some people won multiples even in that span of time. So a week or ten days isn't really anything. It can be frustrating for some users to see that.
It also doesn't help that most giveaways are 24 hours. A week is nothing.
 
Nov 2, 2017
592
I have no idea if anyone will be interested in this, but I got a 15% discount code for Slitherine/Matrix Games if anyone wants to use it. All my purchases from them were on iOS so no good to me.

Happy Anniversary!
Did you know you've been with us for 4 year/s! We'd like to say a big thank you and offer you this coupon to get a discount off your next purchase:

15%-5825-3716-1944-6565

This entitles you to 15% discount on your next purchase!
To use your coupon just:
· Go to the Matrix Games or Slitherine shop.
· Add your desired games to your shopping cart and on the checkout page enter your coupon.

Your coupon is valid for 30 days so don't delay. Enjoy your great new games!

The Slitherine & Matrix Games team
 

Endruen

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,107
Spain
Woah, one month. I think it's too much, a couple of weeks would be better like the rest say, but it will increase the chances of winning for everyone.

I just wish I knew beforehand, haha.
 

Maxi

Member
Oct 25, 2017
283
1 month does seem a bit crazy especially for the usual Humble/Indiegala fodder giveaway but makes sense if people have been abusing it!

Are you able to set a flag for the giveaway to ignore this cooldown & not add to it? Would be useful for giveaways that contain bundle dupes to bypass the cooldown system letting the author of the giveaway decide how they are given away.
 

Baz

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
669
St. Helens
1 month is good cos it means people will be more selective about their entries but I understand where people are coming from when they say it's harsh if they win some $1 humble bundle bundle throwaway game and then miss out on something they really want.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.