If a game releases on GP on day 1, you know beforehand and buying or not is your choice.
This is not "day 1" per sè, but people paid 40$ for a 3 months-long early access to episode 1, with no way of knowing it would pass on GP.
Having the full game on GP after Ep5 would have been ok imho. People who bought it day 1 would have had their money's worth.
That's poor value, and that's basically a slap in the face of people who wanted to support the franchise.
It's not on MS, thou. This is all on Squarenix imho. This doesn't bode well from the franchise.
To me, the game failing commercially doesn't bode well for the franchise so I'd much rather it get out to a wider audience and hopefully enjoyed by more people.
Pre-ordering any game, but a digital-only title especially comes with its own set of risks, least of which is "Oh it may end up on Gamepass too early".
I"m guessing that this deal wasn't made before the game launched and I'm also guessing that something about the market realities caused Square Enix to look for new partnerships. Could it have been done in a cleaner fashion? Sure.
Let's not kid ourselves, Gamepass is not ubiquitous so the venn diagram of Gamepass users who also preordered on Xbox is probably pretty small and of that group, those who are upset at its inclusion in Gamepass would be smaller still.
Looking at the first page of this thread, the posters with the most concern have: bought the game on a different platform, are not subscribed to Gamepass, or a combination of the preceding.
I think it's reasonable for someone to wish they have waited but ripped off? Nah. They are still getting what they originally paid for. That's like saying it's justifiable for someone to feel ripped off if there is a big discount for the season once all the episodes are released. No one put a gun to anyone's head to buy these episodes early. To be legitimately ripped off, the product would have to come up short in a major way or the sale was done on the basis of a lie. Neither has happened in this instance. So it looks more like typical gamer outrage instead of people just realizing that jumping in early in any product carries inherent risks and owning up to that fact.
Agree with the bolded.