• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Jun 23, 2019
6,446
Same was said about PS+ when IGC was a thing. Look at it now. Such a shitty service. At least GP made PS Now to what it is but I expect more old games to be released for it.

giphy.gif
 

Rzarekta

Banned
Nov 27, 2017
1,289
DLC is not included with Gamepass, unless of course there is a GOTY version in Gamepass. There may be exceptions to this, but you will need to buy most DLC/expansions for games still.
Which means future games will ship even more barebones so developers can grab that DLC and mtx cash.

No joke, GamePass is going to be another shitty turning point for video games. I get that people are loving it right now, but this service is NOT good for the future of gaming. I personally hope it fails. MS keeps trying to fuck this industry up for it's own benefit because it has the money and power to do so.
 

Omnistalgic

self-requested temp ban
Member
Oct 27, 2017
8,973
NJ
Game pass isisnt streaming. You download the games.

Also I can't take anyone serious who says Gamepass doesn't have games. It has PLENTY of awesome games on there.

Also someone really compared GP with EA Access? Seriously ?
Hmmm?? It doesn't have the games I want to play, like at all. why you can't take that seriously I dunno, is it hard to understand how this might not be universally appealing to everyone?
 

DevilMayGuy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,577
Texas
You know that we have a lot of PC gamers on this site that subbed to Gamepass (and yes, we know, all of them were smart for getting 10 years for $0.50...)?
Tons of us did get 3 years for a buck, though. Why the snark when that deal is singlehandedly responsible for the explosion of subscribers and interest in GamePass? You don't get to laud how amazing/game-changing a service is while dismissing how it has largely achieved its recent success in the same breath lol
 

JayWood2010

Member
Oct 27, 2017
3,120
The evidence being Uber, moviepass, DoorDash... And dozens of failed tech services that never got to the profitability window. I don't think MS will kill GamePass, only that it won't look anything like it currently does when it transitions to being a profitable service.
Where is your evidence that GamePass is sustainable?
Why are you focusing on something years and years away? Why is it that instead of letting people enjoy it as it is right now, that you feel the need to bring up "sustainability" without evidence that microsoft will or will not continue things as they are? And to compare a company like Microsoft to those others no less?
 

degauss

Banned
Oct 28, 2017
4,631
User Warned: Driveby trolling
Disagree, I think it sucks.

At least I'm going to say that every time the weekly thread advertisiing the service pops up.
 

Voke

Banned
Oct 28, 2017
1,336
I'm very excited to get an Xbox soon because I essentially have all of their games day 1 once I buy it lol. PsNow on the other hand isn't worth it for me at all because I buy a shit ton of games on my PlayStation, and I just so happen to have about 90% of the titles on the service Im interested in. I don't see the value in these services if you're already heavily invested in the ecosystem.
 

Deleted member 20297

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 28, 2017
6,943
Tons of us did get 3 years for a buck, though. Why the snark when that deal is singlehandedly responsible for the explosion of subscribers and interest in GamePass? You don't get to laud how amazing/game-changing a service is while dismissing how it has largely achieved its recent success in the same breath lol
But how representative is that? Do you say gamepass is not reason enough on its own to a standard price to make people subscribe? There is so much talk about gamepass also in the PC community that I don't believe nobody will see the value in it if it isn't cheap as f.
 

cowbanana

Member
Feb 2, 2018
13,693
a Socialist Utopia
It won't be long until the honeymoon phase ends and you'll get pitiful updates on Game Pass while having to subscribe to Ubi-Pass, EA-Pass, WB-Pass, 2K-Pass, ActiBlizzXi-Pass etc. for your dose of wholesome mainstream subscription gaming.
 

crpj31

Member
Dec 13, 2017
560
For me renting is different of buying. I don't know the impact of this for the big publishers but for the small ones it could be very bad. Lot of people just don't buy games anymore because they will be waiting for it to be free in these services. Maybe it won't be sustainable in a long term.
 

Jssom

Avenger
Oct 26, 2017
470
You know that we have a lot of PC gamers on this site that subbed to Gamepass (and yes, we know, all of them were smart for getting 10 years for $0.50...)?

Still what make the service get such praise is the day 1 Microsoft games because if are you subbing to the service for the months or even years old 3rd party games then they are several ways to get those cheap equal to GamePass or even better.

So yes the service could be the best thing ever only if you are an XBox/Microsoft games fan. And I'm not faulting their excitement, I bet ya most Nintendo/Sony fans would also be happy if they had a service that offers all 1st party games day 1 for about 100 box. I would be too. But to me personally I would still not be hyperbolic and call it the best thing to happen to gaming.
 

SnatcherHunter

The Fallen
Oct 27, 2017
13,496
Which means future games will ship even more barebones so developers can grab that DLC and mtx cash.

No joke, GamePass is going to be another shitty turning point for video games. I get that people are loving it right now, but this service is NOT good for the future of gaming. I personally hope it fails. MS keeps trying to fuck this industry up for it's own benefit because it has the money and power to do so.

Okay.. I'll going to screenshot this. It will be fun revisiting this conversation.
 

DevilMayGuy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,577
Texas
Why are you focusing on something years and years away? Why is it that instead of letting people enjoy it as it is right now, that you feel the need to bring up "sustainability" without evidence that microsoft will or will not continue things as they are? And to compare a company like Microsoft to those others no less?
Literally my first post in here was lauding how awesome it is. If you want nothing but unbridled positivity, I don't know what to tell you.
 

Fisty

Member
Oct 25, 2017
20,221
Why are you focusing on something years and years away? Why is it that instead of letting people enjoy it as it is right now, that you feel the need to bring up "sustainability" without evidence that microsoft will or will not continue things as they are? And to compare a company like Microsoft to those others no less?

Because sustainability is important for the future of gaming? There are clear implications for a service like this from a profit-driven company like MS, especially with regards to budget and monetization
 

christocolus

Member
Oct 27, 2017
14,932
Yeah I'll love paying literally $10 for every exclusive game over the next 3 years, rather than the $200+ I was going to spend. The thing is, as people keep saying, at some point they have to start making money. What does that look like? Higher fees? A GamePass lite at the current rate and a GamePass ultra with day 1 FP titles? Just like Netflix losing tons of non-original content and raising their subscription price nearly 100%, I expect something similar down the line for GamePass. For the value currently on display, the service should be closer to $15-20 a month, and definitely not $1. What happens when the 3rd party content creators that comprise the majority of their offering decide to get in on that action (something we are already seeing with the expansion of EA Access-type services to Ubisoft and likely others). What's to stop consumers from jumping ship when the price increases, or when it becomes onerous to have 4 to 5 subscriptions, totaling $50+ a month? I just see a near future that is very similar to the current streaming market. And, when the dust settles, will GamePads have devalued the worth of games to an extent that the broader market suffers in the aftermath when the money faucet gets turned off on all of these subsidized games?

GamePass is very much like moviepass at this point: giving away other people's games at an obviously unsustainable price point to gain market share in the hopes that at some undisclosed future point profitability will materialize
Why not wait until that happens before worrying about all that.. cos as it stands now, Game pass is here and is delivering ultimate value. Netflix hasn't lost its subscribers yet by increasing the price of it's sub, instead they doubled down on creating their own content and have done a great job offering variety. There will always be the cheap looking stuff but there is also lots of great content. If what insiders have been saying is true then this is just the start, expect MS to double down on game pass content/offerings going forward.. They will do what it takes to keep people subbed. It isn't a sprint for them. People seem to forget the fact that Microsoft is behind this service, they will push this as hard and as long as they need to...something most of the others can't afford to do.
Agreed! Can't wait until the Scarlett reveal when we get a look at all the next-gen Titles I've already locked in through June 2022
I have been saying this. All I will need is Scarlet on launch day. I will obviously continue with my GPU sub and I don't even need to by an extra next gen controller (thanks to MS). Gives me enough free cash to spend on the one or two 3rd party launch titles I may be interested in.
 

RoninStrife

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,002
My only worry... third parties releasing half assed AAA games (with half the content it's supposed to have), just to have it on Gamepass, they get paid the millions by Microsoft to have it there, knowing you, the fan, will pay for the expansions that contains the other 50% of the game down the line. Then new releases slowly become more and more thin on content, games become more episodic in nature (because the money for publishers are the MS Millions for Gamepass + you buying expansions) and the value if a $60 game gets eroded.

Am I wrong to think this could happen if the Gamepass experiment is successful?
 

Deleted member 20297

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 28, 2017
6,943
Still what make the service get such praise is the day 1 Microsoft games because if are you subbing to the service for the months or even years old 3rd party games then they are several ways to get those cheap equal to GamePass or even better.

So yes the service could be the best thing ever only if you are an XBox/Microsoft games fan. And I'm not faulting their excitement, I bet ya most Nintendo/Sony fans would also be happy if they had a service that offers all 1st party games day 1 for about 100 box. I would be too. But to me personally I would still not be hyperbolic and call it the best thing to happen to gaming.
I wouldn't say the same either :) But some takes paint a pessimistic future of that service that is sometimes although we don't know it yet. Being open minded is sometimes not a given.
 

xabbott

Member
Oct 28, 2017
1,065
Florida
Which means future games will ship even more barebones so developers can grab that DLC and mtx cash.

No joke, GamePass is going to be another shitty turning point for video games. I get that people are loving it right now, but this service is NOT good for the future of gaming. I personally hope it fails. MS keeps trying to fuck this industry up for it's own benefit because it has the money and power to do so.
Microsoft didn't invent game subscriptions though. Subscription and games have been going back since Intellivision. Even big players like Sega and Nintendo tried it out, just way ahead of their. Hell even Sony beat MS to a gamesub but they just hesitated on downloads until MS tried it. Blaming Microsoft is just short sighted, we were going to get here eventually and if its destined to bomb some other solution will come.
 

OldBenKenobi

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,696
I love how Gamepass threads on this forum bring out all the Fanboys who come in with their hot takes on why its a bad for the industry and how it's going to ruin gaming.
giphy.gif
 

RoninStrife

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,002
Which means future games will ship even more barebones so developers can grab that DLC and mtx cash.

No joke, GamePass is going to be another shitty turning point for video games. I get that people are loving it right now, but this service is NOT good for the future of gaming. I personally hope it fails. MS keeps trying to fuck this industry up for it's own benefit because it has the money and power to do so.
This. And I do not think we are paranoid to think this.
 

RingRang

Alt account banned
Banned
Oct 2, 2019
2,442
I just finished playing Gears of War 5, and what a ride it was. And this was only possible thanks to game pass.

There really is no better value proposition than game pass. I am gobsmacked at how good of a service it is - it doesn't cost much per month, and you have a wealth of AAA titles including brand new releases such as Gears 5 and The Outer Worlds! I have always considered a subscription based service similar to Netflix inconceivable due to insane budgets and rising dev costs, but I for one am glad that Microsoft have provided a consumer centric service. Thank you MS. Thank you very much.
You concerns in that regard were always justified. Let's have this conversation again in a few years.
 

upinsmoke

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
2,566
The single most best thing to happen in gaming? C'mon man wtf.

And gears was good but average compared to other offerings on Switch or PS4. Cant help but feel like this is such an ott reaction to a service offering good games at a good price and thats basically it.
 

Mass Effect

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 31, 2017
16,790
I don't know about "best thing," but it's a pretty good deal... for now anyway. Who knows if that will remain true in a few years. I mean look at the movie/tv industry to see that it can all go to hell for consumers pretty quickly.

But I can't complain too much. Can't beat 100% free. I'll be riding that Game Pass train until at least 2021 for $0 :D

I'm not a Gamepass subscriber anymore but I'm grateful that it forced Sony's hand twice. The first time to add PS4 download games to PSNow and the second time To cut the price for the service in half to make it in line with Gamepass. Microsoft getting Sony (the leader by far this generation) to do such a consumer friendly move for their players is a big deal.

Pretty sure it was to combat Stadia, not Game Pass.

At least according to the investors, that is.
 

OldBenKenobi

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,696
Questioning the long term viability of a service and how it might change the industry in a positive or negative way doesn't make you a fanboy....

Ok you guys continue to worry about that kind of stuff while i enjoy another good game to hit GP, Outer Worlds, which is getting awesome Reviews, on my PC this weekend.
 

Prine

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
15,724
The single most best thing to happen in gaming? C'mon man wtf.

And gears was good but average compared to other offerings on Switch or PS4. Cant help but feel like this is such an ott reaction to a service offering good games at a good price and thats basically it.

What offering do Sony/Nintendo then offer that is comparable to Gears 5 then? With a comprehensive SP/Multi with free support for maps and content? Because its not Splatoon or Unchrated, they're completely different games compared to Gears.
Being concerned about the sustainability of our hobby for the years/decades ahead makes us fanboys? LOL

To sum it up as doom and gloom without any data to back it up, its hard not to assume fanboy-ism.
 

Hace

Member
Sep 21, 2018
894
The evidence being Uber, moviepass, DoorDash... And dozens of failed tech services that never got to the profitability window. I don't think MS will kill GamePass, only that it won't look anything like it currently does when it transitions to being a profitable service.
Where is your evidence that GamePass is sustainable?

you can keep losing money forever, the market doesnt care
 

nib95

Contains No Misinformation on Philly Cheesesteaks
Banned
Oct 28, 2017
18,498
It's far too early to claim that. We don't yet know what the long term ramifications of Game Pass and similar future services will or will not have on gaming as a whole.

Microsoft is most likely eating big losses at the moment in order to heavily push the service and its growth, but eventually they'll want the service to bring in more revenue and at some point be profitable. When that point arrives, we'll have a better understanding of what it entails. Though I'd agree in the mean time we as consumers are certainly benefiting.
 

DevilMayGuy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,577
Texas
Hmmm?? It doesn't have the games I want to play, like at all. why you can't take that seriously I dunno, is it hard to understand how this might not be universally appealing to everyone?
My man it has games of all genres, spanning indie to AAA. If there is nothing that interests you on there, it's your narrow tastes rather than any indication of the quality of the service.
 
Jun 23, 2019
6,446
I love how Gamepass threads on this forum bring out all the Fanboys who come in with their hot takes on why its a bad for the industry and how it's going to ruin gaming.
giphy.gif

Yikes. This is not it chief. Discussing the viability of subscription services especially one with a plan such as MS's is not "being a fanboy". Did you have an actual argument or just wanted to stick it to the Sonyponies and Nintendrones?
 

nerdv2

Member
Apr 23, 2019
175
As a student, Game Pass seems like a gift from God to save my wallet.

With my 2 year subscription, now I know that I will continue using Xbox and maybe able to save money for Scarlett.
 

RingRang

Alt account banned
Banned
Oct 2, 2019
2,442
I love how Gamepass threads on this forum bring out all the Fanboys who come in with their hot takes on why its a bad for the industry and how it's going to ruin gaming.
giphy.gif
So certainly you've heard how wildly successful Netflix is, right? Did you know last year when you took all the money they made, and all the money they spent, they came up 3 billion in debt? That's not a sustainable business model, and it's the same story with music streaming services. Artists are making peanuts on those services because the business model just doesn't generate enough revenue.

If a service like Game Pass were to get very successful it would almost certainly have negative ramifications for the games industry. I subscribed for 3 years during the E3 deal, but with each passing month I realize that I kind of regret it. I don't want to encourage this business model in gaming.
 

DevilMayGuy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,577
Texas
Yikes. This is not it chief. Discussing the viability of subscription services especially one with a plan such as MS's is not "being a fanboy". Did you have an actual argument or just wanted to stick it to the Sonyponies and Nintendrones?
Funny how the fanboys always show their asses with nonsense like this. One finger points, 3 point back and all that
 

Deleted member 15395

Unshakable Resolve
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
3,145
On PC at least, I've ended up realizing most of the games are just a few dollars on Steam (except the 1st party releases obviously). That being said, it still is a tremendous value proposition at least on my country.
 

OldBenKenobi

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,696
Yikes. This is not it chief. Discussing the viability of subscription services especially one with a plan such as MS's is not "being a fanboy". Did you have an actual argument or just wanted to stick it to the Sonyponies and Nintendrones?

Huh? I have posted many times in other Gamepass threads on why I think it's NOT bad for the industry.


Funny how the fanboys always show their asses with nonsense like this. One finger points, 3 point back and all that

I don't even own and Xbox yet I still have my Switch and launch day ps4.
 

Deleted member 15447

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
1,728
Is there a description of how the Devs receive their cut and how much?

Would it be a payment for simply being on the service and/or additional for every user playing?

Because, as the Catalog increased, surely that would mean bigger and bigger losses for MS?

Something like Spotify made 10 billion dollars but after paying royalties, ended up with a 500 million dollar loss in a recent year apparently.

I can't see this lasting. At least not for new games.
 
Jun 23, 2019
6,446
Funny how the fanboys always show their asses with nonsense like this. One finger points, 3 point back and all that

Are you insinuating that I'm being a fanboy? My guy, we already have Netflix as an example of streaming services not being as financially viable as it once seemed. Now you have the video game version with MS undoubtedly eating big costs to keep it going, especially with the $1 offers and placing of day and date new titles that are taking away from unit sales. Its obvious he had no intent on discussing the topic at hand and wanted to rail against the "fanboys" in the group.
 

DevilMayGuy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,577
Texas
Are you insinuating that I'm being a fanboy? My guy, we already have Netflix as an example of streaming services not being as financially viable as it once seemed. Now you have the video game version with MS undoubtedly eating big costs to keep it going, especially with the $1 offers and placing of day and date new titles that are taking away from unit sales. Its obvious he had no intent on discussing the topic at hand and wanted to rail against the "fanboys" in the group.
No I was talking about the dude you quoted. You're good lol
 

Rzarekta

Banned
Nov 27, 2017
1,289
Microsoft didn't invent game subscriptions though. Subscription and games have been going back since Intellivision. Even big players like Sega and Nintendo tried it out, just way ahead of their. Hell even Sony beat MS to a gamesub but they just hesitated on downloads until MS tried it. Blaming Microsoft is just short sighted, we were going to get here eventually and if its destined to bomb some other solution will come.
It's not about inventing subscription services, it's about MS being the super corporation who is actually able to push it on us at a huge loss for them because they can handle that huge loss. MS are the ones making this real and legit because they can. So I will absolutely blame them if this model ends up being the norm and game quality takes a huge hit because of it.
 

RoninStrife

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,002
What offering do Sony/Nintendo then offer that is comparable to Gears 5 then? With a comprehensive SP/Multi with free support for maps and content? Because its not Splatoon or Unchrated, they're completely different games compared to Gears.


To sum it up as doom and gloom without any data to back it up, its hard not to assume fanboy-ism.

Mmm... I don't think I need data specifically for gamepass to comment on it's sustainability, and how it affects the industry because it's model isn't new in other industries.

It makes me worried how it would have permanently changed the industry, by the time they want to actually start making a profit on this though. It is a valid concern.
 

Jade1962

Banned
Oct 28, 2017
4,259
I'm going to go with the release of Virtua Fighter and Virtua Racing. Changed my expectations of gaming forever.
 

Jahranimo

Community Resettler
Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,013
I love how Gamepass threads on this forum bring out all the Fanboys who come in with their hot takes on why its a bad for the industry and how it's going to ruin gaming.
giphy.gif
Right and we all know who those type of people are lol.

Without Game Pass I would never try out a game like The Outer Worlds on PC for free*