Armchair historians are one of most ill-informed hobby groups out there. The problem is that these people tend to read the historical record on a shallow level, often relying on information of poor accuracy. Combine that with the Dunning-Kreuger effect where the people who know the least about a subject feel the strongest about their grasp on it, and the tendency to only use any information they learn to reinforce their prejudices, and you get the mess that an awful lot of Total War fans belong to.
I got a sense of this when I read SPQR by Mary Beard (the woman you may have heard of from a twitter fight with people criticizing a depiction of an African Roman soldier in some cartoon). The book not only goes into what we know about a period of ancient Rome, but how we know what we know about it -- what the actual original sources are and what the archaeology tells us.
The biggest implication of this in the book is that we really know jack shit about Rome prior to maybe the 4th century BC (which I think is the point where Rome Total War campaigns start), but a ton of people parrot stories about the original kings of Rome and the tradition that it was founded in the 7th or 8th century BC as if it's historical fact. Even the Wiki articles on Rome do this.
Also how Hollywood and other forms of media present them too. There was a video that was made about the Burning of Alexandria and the myths that came out about and how there were also, but also in the video, the presenter showed various YouTubers spouting very similar stuff and told them they were not actually given any factual evidence but something that was in a said in the tv series Cosmos by Carl Sagan and other non-historical sources. People get their infomantion about history from media and not historical information and when they do, it tends to riddle with mistakes.
This has got me thinking about all the history videos I like to watch on YouTube. They usually seem to extensively report their sources though, and those sources are usually thick books on the subjects of each video. They're probably a step above people on some forums.