I Will defend squall and i hate cd 3 and 4 of ff8 with passion.
There's no emo MC in the main line final Fantasy games. You can say that to advent Children Cloud and i understand.
But squall Just likes to be alone, he's stoic, and doesnt express himself Very good. He doesnt go to the corner and cry, he does stuff he Must do and don't want to get involved with people
My hot take is if squall is emo, Kratos in the last game is emo too since they share those characteristics.
Cloud is not emo in ff7 who says that, only watched AC, the only part cloud is emo, IS when Sephiroth says he's a fake and during his recovery, and even then It has a reason why for that part. After this cloud returns to normal Very quickly.
Cloud should be way more emo btw like:
- Sephiroth impaled the girl he liked in front of him
-he beated the shit out of aeris by mind Control
- his Village and mom burned in front of him
- his best friend in the army sacrificied for him
- he got tortured by bio experiments
- he couldnt stop a genocide in front of him
I would be extremely emo in cloud place, but he isnt, he's a dorky normal Guy from most of the game.
Zidane is not emo, tidus is not emo, vaan is not emo, noctis is not emo besides the look.